What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

I'm going to sue the Cronulla Sharks, says veteran doctor Dave Givney

Poss

Juniors
Messages
1,465
VETERAN Cronulla doctor Dave Givney has become the first official to hit back at the Sharks over his sacking after confirming last night he was taking legal action against the club he served tirelessly for 28 years.

Givney, head trainer Mark Noakes, physiotherapist Konrad Schultz and football manager Darren Mooney were dismissed last Friday while head coach Shane Flanagan was stood down pending a review for failing to inform the board of alleged doping practices at the club in 2011.
Givney was the first to sound the alarm over the methods of controversial sports scientist Stephen Dank at the Sharks - Dank is under investigation for his work at clubs across the NRL and AFL - and even tendered his resignation to Flanagan and Mooney. It was rejected.
Givney met his lawyer Sam Macedone at his Miranda offices last night to consider his options. The veteran doctor was stunned at his sacking after being a loyal servant to the struggling club. Givney was also the Australian and NSW doctor during his career.
"After meeting with my lawyer today I've decided to take legal action," Givney said last night.
"I have no desire to do anything to harm the club but I'm forced to leave matters in the hands of my lawyers at this time."
It is believed that Macedone has already issued the Cronulla club with a cease-and-desist letter to prevent directors from referring to Givney publicly.
Meanwhile, interim Cronulla coach Peter Sharp holds grave fears for the wellbeing of several players after yesterday revealing the strain the doping scandal had placed on the team.
"They're in pieces, mate," Sharp said. "There's blokes that haven't slept for days. There's blokes that have lost weight. I'm seriously worried about them. I've got two boys the same age and I wouldn't like them to be put under this sort of pressure."
Players returned to Sharks Stadium yesterday for a recovery session where they slipped into ice baths and had massages after Sunday night's win over the Titans. Sharp, Cronulla captain Paul Gallen and centre Ben Pomeroy caught up with Flanagan and Noakes yesterday following the club's emotional 12-10 win over the Gold Coast at Sharks Stadium on Sunday night. "He's a mate and we get together and talk about footy," Sharp said.
Gallen looked distressed after the match and it is believed he is one of several players to have lost weight since the doping scandal broke last week. Players were allegedly told they would face six-month bans if they co-operated with the ASADA investigation or risk two years if they didn't. It is believed the six-month offer expired last night.
The Sharks' next assignment will be South Sydney at ANZ Stadium on Monday night and at this stage Sharp has no plans to stand down anyone. However, he said he would not be afraid to step in and make a tough call if he thought players were suffering too much stress after NRL chief executive Dave Smith said the ASADA investigation could drag on for a month. "I wouldn't hesitate in giving a couple of them a rest, but they don't want to rest. They all want to desperately play."
The speculation continued yesterday that chairman Damian Irvine was poised to stand down from his position - or already had - after going public on Sunday and confirming that players had been administered with horse drugs in 2011.
The Sharks will receive some relief tomorrow when former Brisbane boss Bruno Cullen is expected to arrive at the club. Cullen has been recruited by the NRL along with a financial officer and a welfare officer to provide help.
The situation has again raised concerns over the Sharks' financial future - they still have a debt of more than $3 million - which has prompted speculation the club might have to look at moving in order to survive. The bid chief of the Perth-based West Coast Pirates consortium said he would be willing to discuss the situation with the NRL, but that it would need to be done properly or risk irreparable damage to the sport.
Perth has been mooted as one potential destination should the NRL decide to shut down the Sharks' southern Sydney base.


http://www.theaustralian.com.au/sport/nrl/im-going-to-sue-the-cronulla-sharks-says-veteran-doctor-dave-givney/story-fnca0von-1226595051250?sv=2250b45f0d91e1692399bf3d008e24aa#.UT5HnxtORD8.twitter
 
Messages
21,903
the more i read into this the more you have to wonder just how good we were doing financially and wether the development getting approved was of any real consequence.

whats doing with the financial reports?
 

Poss

Juniors
Messages
1,465
In the press conference on Friday, the dude said that the Sharks had recently paid off a large chunk of the debt to St George Bank. I can't remember the exact figure but I seem to recall $10mil. Don't know if it was $10mil that was paid off, or if it was $10mil and is now down to $3mil.
 

millersnose

Post Whore
Messages
65,223
It is now beyond all doubt the financials are a f**king mess

Forget the asada nightmare

The biggest threat to the club is the inability to get finances in order

And the potential for huge payouts to defamed people publicly by the board

I doubt Tricia will be willing to fork out
 
Messages
21,903
yep.

you have to wonder if we have all been deceived here at just how good the clubs finances were turning dont you.

considering sponsorship is minimal.

considering the total lack of staff.

hmmmm
 

Craigshark

First Grade
Messages
6,874
Why agree to a deal which see's only $10 million payed off the $13 million debt?

If they're spending $300 million on a development, surely they have a spare $3 million to get rid of the whole debt..
 

Madsharkie

First Grade
Messages
5,026
f**k Givney then if he wants to sue. How can people do this to the club "they love"

Exactly! That too is poor form (as was shown to him). My guess is some lawyers have been in his ear... Or maybe he's part of the mundine crew! Lol
 

Isurus

Juniors
Messages
517
f**k Givney then if he wants to sue. How can people do this to the club "they love"

So Givney should sit back and let his reputation be forever tarnished as a doctor who turned a blind eye to doping in sport...............are you serious mate???
 
Messages
21,903
well.

his dismissal was reccomended by that review. so there has to be something to it.

they were booted due to management failings. what were these failings?

he may have a case he may not.
 

Special K

Coach
Messages
19,520
So Givney should sit back and let his reputation be forever tarnished as a doctor who turned a blind eye to doping in sport...............are you serious mate???

I don't think his reputation has been tarnished in fact he probably has more support then ever right now due to this shitty situation. I haven't seen anyone say a bad word about him and the fact the sharks have told him he is no longer required (and he did not have a contract). It is universally accepted the sharks are the ones in the wrong here not the people sacked hence his lawyer believes he has a case.

I don't agree he should of been sacked but to sue to the club you claim to love so much is a shitty move. I believe the board has sadly to go because of their actions on Friday and the weekend but to sue the club over this will only hurt the club and the fans(who the majority want him to have his job back).

This is a case of "f**k me? f**k you!". Nobody wins.
 
Messages
3,224
well.

his dismissal was reccomended by that review. so there has to be something to it.

they were booted due to management failings. what were these failings?

he may have a case he may not.

Maybe there wasn't much in it at all. Maybe, as I've posted in another thread, it's arse covering 101.

There are so many unanswered questions from the board. It appears so far there has been a lot of knee jerk reactions which is par for the course for the Sharks.

The more I do not hear from the NRL, the more I see them as wanting to relocate us.

There has been no leadership from the NRL, the ARLC, the Players Association or our club. Someone, anyone should be saying to ASADA - 'put up or shut the f**k up' - simple.
 

Eion

First Grade
Messages
7,988
Being in 'the hands of lawyers' does not mean Givney wants a squillion. What he's done is what the sharks should have done when put under pressure.

ie hire an expert to protect your interest.

Can't believe people are bagging him for doing what we have been bagging the sharks for not doing...
 

Isurus

Juniors
Messages
517
So special - hypothetically you love where you work, you are passionate about it and then one day you are sacked for something you feel you had no control over.

All of your ex colleagues support you to the hilt, yet the organisation you love says you have failed in your duties.

Your ability to work in this industry is questionable because your reputation has been tarnsihed. Forget the fact that you may not want to work with another employer in this industry because it is this employer that you love.

What would you do - take the hit and just sit back because "you love" this ex employer?

Are you saying you are a person of greater integrity that David Givney?? Obviously Ausguy thinks he is!!!
 

Frenzy.

Post Whore
Messages
51,277
He's pissing in the wind. A tactic to get the board to walk. He can't get blood out of a stone
 

Frenzy.

Post Whore
Messages
51,277
3 mil?
that is nothing...my mortgage is not far off that.

There's also the costs to run the footy club, the ground, player and staff payments, paying out staff, potentially paying out lawsuits, the tiler etc etc.

So this, with the debt and no new revenue streams with reduction of existing revenue streams causes suspiciaon that things are bleaker then made out. Don't they?
 

webShark

Guest
Messages
4,295
Exactly! That too is poor form (as was shown to him). My guess is some lawyers have been in his ear... Or maybe he's part of the mundine crew! Lol

First in best dressed. Phys, Trainer, Moons, Flanno, all the players, sponsors for starters. Current players could sue for lack of duty of care. The 14 clearly have a case. Who does TC negiotiate his contract with ? Cullen? What is he going to do when offerred a better deal from another club? Hang around here!

Talk of Flanno being re-instated next week amazes me. Stay where you are Flanno. Keep on the phone to Sharp. Dont come back unless completely exonerated. If you dont come back sue the Perth Sharks.
 

Latest posts

Top