What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Ins & outs for 2015

Messages
2,494
I think next year will be the year where Dallin either sinks or swims. He is he kind of player who you can love and hate at once. It would be incredibly frustrating when he would drop the ball or throw a stupid pass (however being his rookie year it was ok) but then there were other moments of brilliance and hopefully the off season will give him a chance to get some experience and smash it in 2015
 

maple_69

Bench
Messages
4,598
He's 19. I'd rather him dropping balls and pulling off freak plays. He'll become more consistent but we don't have many players that could pulled off those two freak plays in the finals.

Not sure how ready he is for fullback though.
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
23,956
VTk trialling for Northern pride, cowboys feeder. Big loss.

It could turn out to be a loss we regret, but really he is stuck behind Taylor, Peachey, Brown, Cartwright, BMM, Sika, Yeo, Docker....all those guys were picked ahead of him for backrow spots last season.
 

maple_69

Bench
Messages
4,598
Shame none of the Tia Kilifis really kicked on. Vaipuna looked an absolute freak at 17 or so. Hopefully he gets an injury free run and does well.
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,878
Shame none of the Tia Kilifis really kicked on. Vaipuna looked an absolute freak at 17 or so. Hopefully he gets an injury free run and does well.

Akeripa Tia Kilifi to the cowboys as well named in there side for this week's trial.
 

murraymob

Coach
Messages
10,338
VTk trialling for Northern pride, cowboys feeder. Big loss.

no he never kicked on and has been passed by Cartwright Yeo smith.not to mention peachey taylor docker all ahead of him .Good luck to him hope he goes well
 

Pomoz

Bench
Messages
2,997
It is often the case that youngsters who have a physical advantage over their peers during their junior football, stand out as being better than what they really are. Once their peers improve their strength, they come back to the field. I think VTK fitted that pattern. Physically imposing at a young age which allowed him to dominate and as others grow and catch up with him, he has turned out to be just ok, not exceptional.

Very few continue their dominance. Brad Fittler is the one who stands out in my years of watching juniors. Physically imposing at every age and when he steps up to First Grade and plays against man mountain Meninga in the GF, he runs him down and tackles him as he streaks away for a certain try. He then physically lifts him above his head. I have a great photo somewhere of him holding Meninga off the ground. He was 19 and Meninga was a colossus.
 

Fibroman

First Grade
Messages
8,216
It is often the case that youngsters who have a physical advantage over their peers during their junior football, stand out as being better than what they really are. Once their peers improve their strength, they come back to the field. I think VTK fitted that pattern. Physically imposing at a young age which allowed him to dominate and as others grow and catch up with him, he has turned out to be just ok, not exceptional.

Very few continue their dominance. Brad Fittler is the one who stands out in my years of watching juniors. Physically imposing at every age and when he steps up to First Grade and plays against man mountain Meninga in the GF, he runs him down and tackles him as he streaks away for a certain try. He then physically lifts him above his head. I have a great photo somewhere of him holding Meninga off the ground. He was 19 and Meninga was a colossus.
I remember it well. Fittler is a once in 100 years player.
 

TheFrog

Coach
Messages
14,300
Meninga was a colossus.

Meninga was indeed a colossus, but Ken Irvine he was not, and as such you'd expect a talented young centre to catch him.

The Sattler Grand Final tackle, a backrower on a winger, was more remarkable in my opinion.
 
Last edited:

Pomoz

Bench
Messages
2,997
Meninga was indeed a colossus, but Ken Irvine he was not, and as such you'd expect a talented young centre to catch him.

The Sattler Grand Final tackle, a backrower on a winger, was more remarkable in my opinion.
Is Jessica Alba ugly because another woman is considered more beautiful?
 

soc123_au

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
19,893
It's one thing catching Meninga, stopping him is a whole new adventure. Especially at speed.
 
Top