Opinion Is Ricky Stuart the most overrated coach ever?

[MilkShark]

Papali could be Towelmalolo if he lost 15kgs of fat and replaced it with muscle.

 

[Pete Cash]

Against the panthers

16 runs for 137m. 5 tackle breaks. 3 offloads and 28 tackles

Against the sharks

11 runs for 117m. 2 tackle breaks. 1 linebreak and 19 tackles (by far our best forward that game and he shit all over the sharks backrowers)

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Who is going to win the Stephen Dank medal for the sharks this year?

 

[Pete Cash]

Papali could be Towelmalolo if he lost 15kgs of fat and replaced it with muscle.

Jason taumalolo is the best forward in the game but isnt an edge forward

 

[Pete Cash]

Hodgson is obviously our key player but Papalii has been our most consistently good player all season.

Plus that hit on Gallen still stings Shark’s fans, so that’s just a bonus.

Has papalii had a bad game this year? He was one of Queenslands best in origin too. Just a real class edge forward

 

[carcharias]

Calm down you bunch of Ricky's .

I said he isn't as good as he was.
He goes good but I've seen him sucking in the big ones a little too often now he's playing the real games.

 

[MilkShark]

Against the panthers

16 runs for 137m. 5 tackle breaks. 3 offloads and 28 tackles

Against the sharks

11 runs for 117m. 2 tackle breaks. 1 linebreak and 19 tackles (by far our best forward that game and he shit all over the sharks backrowers)

You rate those stats?

The ''best'' edge runner in the comp can't even average 10m a run.

Jason taumalolo is the best forward in the game but isnt an edge forward

I said he was?

 

[Mr Angry]

Who is going to win the Stephen Dank medal for the sharks this year?

Flanno, does every year

 

[Pete Cash]

Calm down you bunch of Ricky's .

I said he isn't as good as he was.
He goes good but I've seen him sucking in the big ones a little too often now he's playing the real games.

This has easily been his best year ?

 

[Walt Flanigan]

Jason taumalolo is the best forward in the game but isnt an edge forward

Exactly. Plus Paps leaves him for dead in the play-making department with a sh*tload more try assists, linebreak assists and offloads.

 

[carcharias]

This has easily been his best year ?

Read the very first sentence that I wrote regarding this today.

 

[Pete Cash]

You rate those stats?

The ''best'' edge runner in the comp can't even average 10m a run.


I said he was?

Edge forwards arent expected to churn out 10m a run. You are kind of embarrassing yourself here lol

 

[Pete Cash]

Read the very first sentence that I wrote regarding this today.

You must be hallucinating because he has been among our best in both finals games

Sharks fans are letting dislike of a player make them go insane. He is an 80 minute forward and has a good game pretty much every week

 

[carcharias]

You must be hallucinating because he has been among our best in both finals games

Sharks fans are letting dislike of a player make them go insane. He is an 80 minute forward and has a good game pretty much every week

I said I've only watched the last few games closely
He looked good in the end of a smashing off the back of Hodgson but other blokes did loads more.
Against the sharks?
Nuthin - had one good run
Dropped one cold in his own 20 when he saw he was about to get smashed if I recall.
Against the panthers?
Again looked a bit of a bludger out wide .

 

[carcharias]

Hang on who the f**k are talking about?
Ricky or fatty?

 

[Pete Cash]

He plays out wide ? I mean compare his numbers against the sharks edge forwards. Lewis didnt even crack 50m.

Papalii would walk into any team in the comp and has probably been the raiders best player this year. I mean i reckon on balance he has been.

I honestly think sharks fans have lost the plot here.

 

[myrrh ken]

 

[Mr Angry]

It is possible that Ricky as head coach could win the NRL, NSW Cup, Ron Massey Cup and the Sydney Shield.

Not bad for an over rated coach.

 

[Pete Cash]

No i think sharks fans genuinely dont like papalii

He has 50 tackle busts this year. To put that into context wade graham who is an excellent edge forward has 30

 

[MilkShark]

Edge forwards arent expected to churn out 10m a run. You are kind of embarrassing yourself here lol

An edge forward should be getting alot of metres running wider of the ruck.