Josh Addo Carr

[AyiosYiorgos]

I'm still amazed that we are still looking at him after what he did, just think if he was in our side and pulled that stunt after not being in finals for many years, we would all want his head on a platter, not to mention he is still professing his innocence. Oh well Flanno knows best, I stand to be corrected and I hope I am.

Well we signed Val Holmes, seems most people have forgotten what he did.

 

[Coffs dragon]

I'm still amazed that we are still looking at him after what he did, just think if he was in our side and pulled that stunt after not being in finals for many years, we would all want his head on a platter, not to mention he is still professing his innocence. Oh well Flanno knows best, I stand to be corrected and I hope I am.

I hope he goes to the Eels as the bloke seems a flog!

 

[justadragon]

Well we signed Val Holmes, seems most people have forgotten what he did.

true and point taken

 

[justadragon]

There is a slight difference between the 2 incidents though, JAC actually had it in his system whilst VH was never proven to be, still not condoning what he did.

 

[SAP58]

Coaches/clubs are in a very difficult position, I am sure most would like to have a definate no dickhead policy & have nothing to do with players for unacceptable behaviour & most of the "mature" members of this forum would definitely share that view as I do. BUT if coaches/clubs have that policy it would restrict their ability to build a successful side significantly. Another club will always come along & pick up that "rogue" if they have ability & hope they can change their attitude & make them a better person & player. Bennett has been doing that for years & has been very successful at it. Flanno has a small window to bring success to the club or he will end up like Kevie Walters, we all saw how the number of good players available at the right price reduced when the Dolphins came in & it will continue to happen with 2 new teams coming in. Im not saying it is right but its reality IMO.

 

[AyiosYiorgos]

There is a slight difference between the 2 incidents though, JAC actually had it in his system whilst VH was never proven to be, still not condoning what he did.

So one of them is stupider than the other, is basically what your saying