Judiciary Charges 2019

[League Unlimited News]

Yep, you're right, forgot about the two charges in the one week. The NRL site had him 20% loading but 40% would be correct.

The Judiciary Code suggests Grade 1 Tripping is a $1500 fine, so the entire charge sheet is a little confusing in this instance.

Judiciary Code: https://www.nrl.com/operations/the-game/judiciary-code/

 

[Someguy]

Sam Burgess good chance to get the downgrade imo. Not that bad a hit.

Given the way he plays it won’t be long untill his carry over points add up to enough to get him suspended though

 

[aqua_duck]

So interestingly Evans who was sin binned yesterday wasn't even charged by the MRC (and rightly so). Co-incidently it's the 3rd time this year Ashley Klein has sin binned a player for an offence which the MRC hasn't even deemed worthy of a charge yet we have Mr Burgess escape the sin bin for a grade 2. First of all if that doesn't indicate that Klein is out of control and operating differently than other refs then not sure what does, secondly does anyone actually know what foul play incidents constitute a sin bin?

 

[skeepe]

The Judiciary Code suggests Grade 1 Tripping is a $1500 fine, so the entire charge sheet is a little confusing in this instance.

Judiciary Code: https://www.nrl.com/operations/the-game/judiciary-code/

3rd charge of the season, so not eligible for a fine.

 

[firechild]

So interestingly Evans who was sin binned yesterday wasn't even charged by the MRC (and rightly so). Co-incidently it's the 3rd time this year Ashley Klein has sin binned a player for an offence which the MRC hasn't even deemed worthy of a charge yet we have Mr Burgess escape the sin bin for a grade 2. First of all if that doesn't indicate that Klein is out of control and operating differently than other refs then not sure what does, secondly does anyone actually know what foul play incidents constitute a sin bin?

Meh. 2 Souffs players got charged by the MRC a few weeks ago despite the on field refs not deeming neither incident worthy of a penalty. Who the f**k knows what infringements are worth what? Clearly the officials have no clue.

 

[SBD82]

So interestingly Evans who was sin binned yesterday wasn't even charged by the MRC (and rightly so). Co-incidently it's the 3rd time this year Ashley Klein has sin binned a player for an offence which the MRC hasn't even deemed worthy of a charge yet we have Mr Burgess escape the sin bin for a grade 2. First of all if that doesn't indicate that Klein is out of control and operating differently than other refs then not sure what does, secondly does anyone actually know what foul play incidents constitute a sin bin?

As much as it grates me to have to stick up for Klein, I’m 99% sure that call came from the bunker.

 

[aqua_duck]

As much as it grates me to have to stick up for Klein, I’m 99% sure that call came from the bunker.

Whatever the case there seems to be a massive discrepancy between the views of the refs and the MRC, they're so far apart in their views they might as well be looking after different sports

 

[forby]

As much as it grates me to have to stick up for Klein, I’m 99% sure that call came from the bunker.

Nobody should ever stick up for Klein!
Worst ref in the NRL bar none!

 

[Front-Rower]

What? How exactly can he say he didn’t try to trip him?

Told the BSB this morning he reckons he tried to kick the ball. Problem is the doggies player had already picked it up and took a step. Blatant trip imo

 

[TheFrog]

So interestingly Evans who was sin binned yesterday wasn't even charged by the MRC (and rightly so). Co-incidently it's the 3rd time this year Ashley Klein has sin binned a player for an offence which the MRC hasn't even deemed worthy of a charge yet we have Mr Burgess escape the sin bin for a grade 2. First of all if that doesn't indicate that Klein is out of control and operating differently than other refs then not sure what does, secondly does anyone actually know what foul play incidents constitute a sin bin?

You are right. Klein is a card-carrying muppet.

 

[carcharias]

Both Maloney and burgess deserve to be suspended.

 

[Generalzod]

Sam Burgess good chance to get the downgrade imo. Not that bad a hit.

Given the way he plays it won’t be long untill his carry over points add up to enough to get him suspended though

He was lucky not to be sent off,.

 

[carcharias]

He was lucky not to be sent off,.

Ha
He basically knocked him out with a swinging forearm to the jaw

For Burgess that’s not too bad I suppose.

 

[Generalzod]

Ha
He basically knocked him out with a swinging forearm to the jaw

For Burgess that’s not too bad I suppose.

Oh Carcharias it wasn’t a bad hit lol

 

[carcharias]

Oh Carcharias it wasn’t a bad hit lol

Not a bad one

 

[Jean Capdouze]

That hit from Sam was dangerous. He is very much like his eye gouging brother George.

 

[aqua_duck]

That hit from Sam was dangerous. He is very much like his eye gouging brother George.

In that they're protected species in terms of referees

 

[League Unlimited News]

 

[Jean Capdouze]

In that they're protected species in terms of referees

I wasn’t insinuating that at all.

 

[Vic Mackey]

Penrith about to get a view to next year. It will be glorious