What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Katich cut from contract list

Jono1987

Juniors
Messages
1,533
Why is Hildud still there, please tell me they didn't give him another contract

They probably will. Us lucky rugby league fans are treated to the same sort of shit through NewsLimited, NSWRL, QRL and ARL. On top of that Sutherland makes Gallop look like a world conquer.

- Cricket in this country needs an independent commission
- Sack Sutherland
- Sack the selectors

Fresh start.

Katich should be there. It's clear now more than any other time that Australian cricket is still an exclusive boys club. Pathetic.
 

Matt23

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
16,495
- Cricket in this country needs an independent commission
- Sack Sutherland
- Sack the selectors
I dunno about an Independent commission, but your right about Sutherland & the selectors, also you left Nielsen & Langer of the list, they also need to be sacked, I'll reserve judgement on Craig McDermott however.
 

Jono1987

Juniors
Messages
1,533
I dunno about an Independent commission, but your right about Sutherland & the selectors, also you left Nielsen & Langer of the list, they also need to be sacked, I'll reserve judgement on Craig McDermott however.

The coach...I feel disgusted that he escaped my thoughts...

CA appears to be the only major sporting body in Australia that is more corrupt and disorganised than the NRL.

And the NRL is actually getting it's act together (slowly). Meanwhile we're all still awaiting the findings of 'the review'. Unless significant change occurs, nothing has really been achieved.
 

Matt23

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
16,495
I think you find the "review"was nothing more then a token gesture, nobody will be at fault, as "they all tried really hard"
 

Captain BF

Juniors
Messages
1,974
Congrats to young Pat Cummins! He is the first junior from Glenbrook-Blaxland Cricket Club to earn a Cricket Australia contract. Great young bloke from a good family.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
154,551
Hilditch's decision stinks of hypocrisy

Decision to dump veteran opener Simon Katich puts more pressure on Australia's cricket selectors

By Martin Smith
FOX SPORTS
June 08, 2011 3:46PM


The decision to dump Simon Katich as one of 25 players contracted by Cricket Australia has raised questions about the suitability of the current selection panel.

Katich was on Tuesday a shock omission from the 25-man list despite being Australia's best performed batsmen in the past three years.

Andrew Hilditch - stay or go?
Should Andrew Hilditch resign as chairman of selectors?
Yes

80.31%
No

19.69%

Since he regained his Test berth in May 2008, Katich has scored eight centuries in 33 Tests at an average of 50.48. His 2928 runs in that period is bettered only by England opener Alastair Cook and puts the 35-year-old ahead of players like Sachin Tendulkar, Virendar Sehwag and Jacques Kallis.

Chairman of selectors Andrew Hilditch said the decision to dump Katich was a difficult one, but was made with an eye for the future.

Cricket Australia Contacted Players

Doug Bollinger (NSW)
Michael Clarke (NSW)
Patrick Cummins (NSW)
Xavier Doherty (TAS)
Callum Ferguson (SA)
Brad Haddin (NSW)
Ryan Harris (QLD)
John Hastings (VIC)
Nathan Hauritz (NSW)
Ben Hilfenhaus (TAS)
Phillip Hughes (NSW)
David Hussey (VIC)
Michael Hussey (WA)
Mitchell Johnson (WA)
Usman Khawaja (NSW)
Jason Krejza (TAS)
Brett Lee (NSW)
Shaun Marsh (WA)
Tim Paine (TAS)
James Pattinson (VIC)
Ricky Ponting (TAS)
Peter Siddle (VIC)
Steven Smith (NSW)
Shane Watson (NSW)
Cameron White (VIC)

And following Australia's second Ashes defeat in two years last summer, no doubt change was needed in Australian cricket.

Do you think Andrew Hilditch should remain chairman of selectors? Vote in our poll and have your say below

But the decision to end the career of Katich, the one man who has held his own during a disastrous two years, stinks of hypocrisy if Hilditch remains in a job.

The National Selection Panel has undergone several changes in the past year, with Greg Chappell coming on board and David Boon quitting his post to become a match referee.

But Hilditch, who has been on the panel for 15 years, and has been chairman since 2006, shows no signs of moving on.

"I'm really enjoying this role and doing the best I possibly can," Hilditch said on Tuesday.

"If someone decides there's a better way to go, I'd be fully supportive of that as well."

The news that Hilditch would move on if asked would be music to the ears of frustrated fans desperate for change.

During his time as chairman, Hilditch has seen Australia regain the Ashes in 2006-2007 and win a third consecutive Cricket World Cup.

But he has also been at the helm for two consecutive Ashes defeats, a World Cup quarter-final exit and a plummet down the world Test rankings.

Obviously, there have been extenuating circumstances. The retirements of Shane Warne and Glenn McGrath have left a huge gap in the Australian set-up - a gap that will never be filled.

And it must be acknowledged that Hilditch, while he has to take some of the blame for Australia's fall from grace, cannot bat, bowl and field for the 11 players out on the field. The blame must be shared.

Fox Sports cricket commentator Mark Waugh believes Hilditch and his panel have done a reasonable job during Australia's decline.

"I don't think the selectors have made too many bad blunders over the past few years," Waugh told foxsports.com.au.

"Obviously, they've chopped and changed the spinners a bit too much. I think at the start they should have kept solid with (Jason) Krejza, but apart from that I don't think there have been any major blunders.

"There are always players that you think could have gone in the squad or might not have. But if you look around, I don't think there are many players who could have made the team better that they haven't picked. I'm not fully going to blame Andrew Hilditch for it."

But Waugh says the decision to end Katich's career is incorrect.

"But I think on this occasion it's a very harsh decision," Waugh said.

"Simon Katich has been playing well and he's 35. He could have a couple of years left in him. So it's a tough call. But I can sort of see how it's happened given the circumstances."

While Waugh defended Hilditch's record, the chairman doesn't have much support in the cricket community.

Former Test opener Michael Slater and former selector John Benuad were among several respected figures to call for Hilditch's head last summer, while foxsports.com.au users have been scathing in their assessment of the 55-year-old.

Hilditch doesn't have much support and the decision to dump Katich has alienated him even more - and indicated that he is out of touch.

Hilditch has been a fine servant of Australian cricket, and he should be proud of his achievements.

But with Chappell now on board as a full-time selector and change needed at all levels, Hilditch’s time is up.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/cricket...ricket-selectors/story-fn2mcu3x-1226071821071
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
154,551
THE outrage over Simon Katich's axing has reached levels not experienced since Steve Waugh was dumped from the one-day team almost a decade ago.

Cricket Australia has been forced to defend chairman of selectors Andrew Hilditch and dismissed as "a joke" claims new captain Michael Clarke contributed to Katich's demise.
Former Test opening batsman Michael Slater wondered if the infamous Clarke-Katich dressing room confrontation might have played its part before pointing the finger squarely at Hilditch.
Katich's manager, Robert Joske, said he had been flooded by well-wishers and those outraged by 35-year-old's dumping from CA's list of 25 contracted players.
Slater was staggered Katich had been dumped after reading yesterday that the NSW captain was second only to England's Alastair Cook as the most prolific batsman in world cricket in the past three years.

"I think he has been appallingly hung," Slater said.

"Maybe the new captain (Clarke) hasn't been a great supporter, but I don't think that can be blamed for him (Katich) not making the list of contracted players."
Slater said Katich's age was irrelevant given he was Australia's best-performed batsman in the past three years.
He questioned how Katich could be sacked when his injury replacement for the last three Tests in Australia's losing Ashes series, Phil Hughes, averaged just 16.
"If his replacement came in scoring hundreds and was red-hot, then I can understand an injury stopping some in their mid-30s, but that clearly hasn't happened," Slater said.
"The system that is being reviewed at the moment around the country, what are they reviewing?
"The first thing they should be reviewing is the selectors and the selection process, and I'd start with the chairman of selectors (Hilditch)."
CA is furious that a clash between Katich and Clarke in the SCG dressing rooms 2 1/2 years ago is being offered as a reason for the evergreen left-hander's demise.
"It's hardly worth dignifying with a response," CA public affairs manager Peter Young said yesterday.
"The selection panel reports direct to the board and is independent of the influence of players, administrators, states or anybody else. Anyone who knows Andrew (Hilditch) would know that it's a joke.
"Andrew is a person who is both resolute and committed to absolute principles of integrity in what he does and how he manages the national panel."
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/simon-katichs-axing-storm/story-e6frf9if-1226071947711
 

Cliffhanger

Coach
Messages
15,228
Kat's guts not enough, nine lives are up




THE Kat is on the mat. Kicked. Skinned. Gutted. Belled. And almost certainly at the end of his nine lives.


With the dumping of Simon Katich, the Australian cricket team has lost one of the world's best openers and lost that old-fashioned grit and determination that has been missing in recent seasons from its flighty batsmen.

The conspiracy theories started early. Tweets bounced between hemispheres wondering if the infamous dressing-room scuffle with new captain Michael Clarke could explain the baffling decision to disregard one of the world's highest-scoring batsmen over the past three seasons.

An old cricket writer used to advise us that when faced with the choice between conspiracy and c**k-up, always choose the latter. Particularly where this selection panel is concerned.

Chairman of selectors Andrew Hilditch claims Katich had to go because he and his fellow wise men are planning for the next Ashes series.

Makes you wonder how much the panel rates the coming series against Sri Lanka, South Africa, New Zealand and that cricketing backwater called India, which happens to be here this summer.

The Kat has been on the mat before. Selectors have, over the years, done their best to end his Test career.

In Sri Lanka in 2004, Katich had just scored a century in a tour game when they put him in a weighted sack and discarded him for Andrew Symonds. He fought his way out and played again.

He was dumped after the 2005 Ashes disaster and rightly so. His technique had drifted and his scores were low. Although, it might be argued a poor decision from an umpire cost him the chance of a century and Australia the chance of an important fourth Test victory.

Katich lost his contract after that and most people thought he was gone for good, but he tweaked his technique and scored 1506 runs for NSW - the most any domestic cricketer has made in a Sheffield Shield summer.
Injuries to Matthew Hayden and then Phil Jaques saw Katich offered another chance at Test level - and he grabbed it with both hands.

Since returning to the side he has averaged more than 50 runs an innings. His ability to dig in at the top of the order has been critical in the transition period of Australian cricket. He held up an end while Hayden suffered death throes in his last summer, did the same as Hughes came and went, then made hay when his new partner Shane Watson arrived.

Katich was gritty not pretty. He was prone to getting out in the 80s or 90s and, while he finishes his career with 10 centuries, he probably should have had many more.

He trudged to the wicket like a soldier heading to the front and looked like a man working down a salt mine as he picked away at the rock face to fill his bucket. It might have been his Croatian heritage.

When the last Ashes summer turned turtle, Katich was battling an achilles injury.
He should not have played in Adelaide but was asked to battle on because somebody had to take the shine off the ball.

By the time he came to the crease in the second innings, Katich was hobbling like an old man. He had refused to leave the field or hide in an easy fielding position.
In the searing Adelaide heat, Katich grafted his way to 43 before being given out to a nick behind. There was speculation he had missed it, but the opener had given his all and had no arguments left. He limped off and Australia lost by 71 runs.
Katich must now decide if he will play on for NSW. His state needs a senior player who can show the fancy young boys what it takes to make it at the top.
Australian cricket will be poorer for his loss.

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/new...ine-lives-are-up/story-e6frg7t6-1226071292981
 

Hallatia

Referee
Messages
26,433
Cricket Australia has been forced to defend chairman of selectors Andrew Hilditch and dismissed as "a joke" claims new captain Michael Clarke contributed to Katich's demise.
I think this sort of response is a good thing for Australian cricket because it should put some pressure on those in charge and force them to give real reasons for their stupid decisions
 

MSIH

Bench
Messages
3,807
Great article.

Love the Kat. Really hope he plays on for NSW for a while yet.
 

Latest posts

Top