I can't really disagree with anything you've said 73 I think he is at a cross roads, and needs to change.
I am a "moderate" in regards to Noddy I know how bad he was playing after SSO1 last year, however I also remember unlike some how well he was playing before it. He was the form HB in the comp (Johns was injured though) and was playing outstanding footy and it wasn't Ando ball it was deep play with kicks almost always finding space and the forwards rolling forward.
He has proved before he can play that style and he can play it outstandingly well. I think the problem is when under pressure such as SSO1 and trying to prove to the world afterwards that he is good, he goes back to his comfort zone. Ando ball it what comes naturally to Noddy and he seems to really struggle not to fall back into it when the pressure is applied.
I for one hope he has seen the light and comes back playing the style of footy we all want to see from him, if not then I really think his time may just about be up and i hope he likes warm beer, wet weather and soggy chips.