What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

kimmorley and tour chances

millersnose

Post Whore
Messages
65,223
THERE is good news and bad news about Brett Kimmorley and the Kangaroo tour.

The good news is Kimmorley made a successful comeback for the Sharks last week. The bad news is he has gone from bolter's odds to odds-on to wear the Australian No.7 jumper usually reserved for Andrew Johns.

It's not the sort of news Craig Gower, Brent Sherwin, Shaun Berrigan and maybe Matt Orford and Mark McLinden would like to hear on the eve of the playoffs.

Particularly when Kimmorley will not be taking part in the post-season battles leading to the grand final.

It appears the people charged with making selection decisions for the tour were mightily impressed with Kimmorley's comeback game against the Rabbitohs.

They are also well aware that Australia have not lost a Test with Kimmorley calling the shots. He also breaks the line more consistently than most halfbacks and, most importantly, Kangaroo coach Chris Anderson is his No.1 fan.

Having established those factors, the burning question about his match time won't go away.

While the other contenders remain alive in the premiership for varying periods, Kimmorley won't have played a game for nearly five weeks when Australia take on New Zealand the weekend after the grand final.

That means he will have had only two games in more than two months.

No doubt he will continue to train at the required levels but there will be opposition to his selection because of lack of match practice.

Of the other contenders, Gower and Sherwin are likely to be the front-runners, even though they did not play Origin football this year.

And should one or both of them appear in the grand final, their chances of touring will escalate.

The selectors will take two halves anyway - Kimmorley and an understudy whose identity is likely to remain a mystery until the squad is announced after the grand final.
 

Southernsaint

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
20,228
Great post Millersnose, you could get a job writing for the Daily Telegraph if you keep it up :roll:

There is no way that Kimmoreley should be the number one choice for the 'Roo tour's halfback position. Gower has been the form Number Seven all season & deserves his chance & Sherwin should also go, if only as a back-up & for experience

To think a bloke that has been injured more often than not & been quite average when actually on the field will get the job pretty much on the basis of form he showed in 1999 & because his club coach is also the national coach is a joke.

But then again, the tour is long and a man does get lonely...

Cheers,
Ben S.
 

millersnose

Post Whore
Messages
65,223
good post southern saint

you should write for the queens "i hate anything to do with the sharks" paper
 

Southernsaint

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
20,228
millersnose said:
good post southern saint

you should write for the queens "i hate anything to do with the sharks" paper

If you're going to copy-and-paste entire newspaper acticles onto the forum, at least quote the source. I'm sure Peter Frillingoose put minutes of work into it.

And for the record, I don't hate the Sharks or their supporters - I pity them.

Cheers,
Ben S.
 

brook

First Grade
Messages
5,065
Southernsaint said:
There is no way that Kimmoreley should be the number one choice for the 'Roo tour's halfback position. Gower has been the form Number Seven all season & deserves his chance & Sherwin should also go, if only as a back-up & for experience

To think a bloke that has been injured more often than not & been quite average when actually on the field will get the job pretty much on the basis of form he showed in 1999 & because his club coach is also the national coach is a joke.

But then again, the tour is long and a man does get lonely...

Cheers,
Ben S.

grrr why does matt orford not exist to most people?

(but i agree with the rest)
 

legend

Coach
Messages
15,150
I think Kimmorley will go, bruised nuts and all. :lol:

The selectors will always go with the tried and true policy of using players who have done the job in the past.

The form halfback at present is Mark McLinden. He absolutely blitzed Brent Sherwin last weekend and IMO, Sherwin has still yet to dominate in a high pressure match. It's all well and good playing like a champ against nevilles like Manly, Cowboys and Souths but when he came up against a quakity side, he was disappointing.

Will the selectors risk the Ashes to give him a run? I don't think so.
 
Messages
12,936
I can definitely see the Aussies losing the ashes over there without Johns. It all depends on who they pick in the 7 & 6, and the amount of Raiders they select naturally. 8)
 

eloquentEEL

First Grade
Messages
8,065
We're just lucky Australia has no real competition and can get away with having pretty much anyone as coach and no.7, otherwise the papers would be filled with articles calling for Opes to be stood down. If he wasn't the national coach, Kimmorley would not even be rating a mention.
 

Southernsaint

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
20,228
brook said:
grrr why does matt orford not exist to most people?

(but i agree with the rest)

Brook, the same reason people think Glenn Morrison doesn't exist!!

Really, besides Gower, any number of players could take the back-up spot. They'll be taking Wing as well so he could cover too.

It's more the fact that Kimmoreley is even being considered considering what he (hasn't) done this season that is pissing me off.

Cheers,
Ben S.
 

brook

First Grade
Messages
5,065
Southernsaint said:
brook said:
grrr why does matt orford not exist to most people?

(but i agree with the rest)

Brook, the same reason people think Glenn Morrison doesn't exist!!

Really, besides Gower, any number of players could take the back-up spot. They'll be taking Wing as well so he could cover too.

It's more the fact that Kimmoreley is even being considered considering what he (hasn't) done this season that is pissing me off.

Cheers,
Ben S.

yeah well you'll get no arguments from me about that...

(although as a vindictive balmain supporter i'm always glad to see morrison miss out ;-) )
 

Alan Shore

First Grade
Messages
9,390
If it was up to me, I'd select Gower, Orford and McLinden. Gower can cover 5/8th, half and Hooker, Orford is a decent halfback and McLinden can play anywhere between 1 and 7.
 

millersnose

Post Whore
Messages
65,223
legend said:
I think Kimmorley will go, bruised nuts and all. :lol:

The selectors will always go with the tried and true policy of using players who have done the job in the past.

The form halfback at present is Mark McLinden. He absolutely blitzed Brent Sherwin last weekend and IMO, Sherwin has still yet to dominate in a high pressure match. It's all well and good playing like a champ against nevilles like Manly, Cowboys and Souths but when he came up against a quakity side, he was disappointing.

Will the selectors risk the Ashes to give him a run? I don't think so.


good post

Australian selectors will always go for a sure bet and kimmorley is tried and tested and has never played in a loosing aussie side

you may hate him - but he is a good halfback with runs on the board in pressure games
 

Southernsaint

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
20,228
brook said:
yeah well you'll get no arguments from me about that...

(although as a vindictive balmain supporter i'm always glad to see morrison miss out ;-) )

I knew you were going to say that :D

Cheers,
Ben S.
 

Matt23

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
16,495
Kimmorley's a walk up start depite the fact that Gower, Sherwin, McLinden, Wing, Orford and even Shaun Berrigan have all shown more form this season. Is Kimmorley a chance of playing 5/8?
 

Billy Gunn

Juniors
Messages
322
Kimmorley will not play for Australia that my friend is a dead cert!!!!

Who cares if they are undefeated with him at number 7 how many games has Australia lost in the past 10 years wouldn't be more that 2 or 3 I would guess (I'd lke to know if anyone can tell me)

In saying that there are just too many form players in fromt of him to get a start.....I think Stevens is more chance and now that's saying somthing as he has absolutly no form on the board.

Billy
 
Top