What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Knights vote to extend Brian Smith's contract

Frederick

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
27,660
Knights vote to extend Brian Smith's contract
BY ROBERT DILLON
29/01/2009 4:00:00 AM

BRIAN Smith's tenure as Knights coach is set to continue beyond this season after the club's board of directors voted unanimously last night to offer him a contract extension.

Knights chairman Rob Tew told The Herald after the monthly meeting that the club would begin negotiations aimed at re-signing Smith, who has one year to run on a three-season deal.

"The board has instructed the CEO [Steve Burraston] to approach Brian with a view to extending his contract," Tew said.

Despite speculation that the board may have been divided over whether to retain the 54-year-old veteran, Tew insisted the vote was unanimous.

"It was indeed," he said.

The decision to retain Smith was largely expected, given that both Tew and Burraston have publicly endorsed him in recent months.

But there was also a surprise announcement after last night's meeting that Newcastle's deputy chairman, Tony Butterfield, was standing down from his board position to accept a paid role with the club as its corporate and community liaison officer.

Newcastle's constitution states that club employees are not allowed to serve on the board, so Butterfield's resignation creates a vacancy on the nine-person executive, which the club hopes to fill as soon as possible.

Tew was uncertain what length of tenure would be offered to Smith but said last night's decision was a vote of faith in the coach, who steered Newcastle to within one win of the play-offs last year after a controversial cleanout in 2007.

"It will come down to a negotiation between Brian and our CEO," Tew said.

"Our recommendation is that we extend it, and it is going to come down to a two-party agreement."

Smith said he did not want to "jump the gun" by speculating on the possible length of tenure he would be offered.

"Steve just rang me to ask if we could get together and negotiate, so I'm pleased about that and I'll look forward to doing that at some stage next week," Smith said.

"But the thing needs to be paid respect.

"I'm just happy to listen to what Steve's got to say. I'm sure that if we've both got the will, we'll work it out."

In a top-grade career that started in 1984 and included stints at Illawarra, St George and Parramatta before Newcastle, Smith has coached in 505 games, behind only Tim Sheens and Wayne Bennett.

He also spent three seasons with Hull and a year with Bradford in the United Kingdom.

Meanwhile, Knights officials believe Butterfield was the ideal candidate to fill their newly created position, which they hope can help forge closer relationships between players, corporate supporters and the community.

"We've created this position to assist with managing our community presence and to further strengthen our ties with the region," Burraston said.

"When I first tabled the idea and then Tony expressed interest, we were delighted and all agreed he was a perfect fit for the position.

"Tony has strong credentials. He's a foundation player, a member of the Knights' Team of the Era, a former club captain and Origin player and has a business background with strong ties in the Newcastle community."

Tew said he spoke at length about the position with Butterfield and both felt he can make "a significant contribution" in his new role.

Butterfield said 2009 was shaping as a big year for the Knights and he felt he could make a greater impact in his new capacity.

"Now is the time to galvanise support behind the club and the team," he said. "I know that in this role I can play a more meaningful part in that process."
LINK
 

Spike

First Grade
Messages
7,115
Not surprising really. I'm kinda concerned that the wheels may fall off some time down the track if he stays long enough similar to the Eels.
 

Karmawave

Bench
Messages
4,950
Biggest personnel mistake since the inception of the club.

Re-signing Smith long term before a ball is kicked off this year, will be ranked right up there with the failed Leagues Club fiasco as the worst business decision ever made at the Knights.
 

Jobdog

Live Update Team
Messages
25,696
Biggest personnel mistake since the inception of the club.

Re-signing Smith long term before a ball is kicked off this year, will be ranked right up there with the failed Leagues Club fiasco as the worst business decision ever made at the Knights.
:lol:
 

Karmawave

Bench
Messages
4,950
Time will tell JD...

We won't all be laughing if we are sitting in the bottom 6 of the table this year come the end of August and Smith has 3 more years to run on his contract...

That situation is a very real possibility. In reality, we are just as likely to make the bottom 6 as the top 6.

And then what?

I mean if people were all so certain the Knights will make the Top 4 or Top 8, then I assume everyone is putting their houses on it?

I didn't think so...
 

Jobdog

Live Update Team
Messages
25,696
Time will tell JD...

We won't all be laughing if we are sitting in the bottom 6 of the table this year come the end of August and Smith has 3 more years to run on his contract...

That situation is a very real possibility. In reality, we are just as likely to make the bottom 6 as the top 6.

And then what?

I mean if people were all so certain the Knights will make the Top 4 or Top 8, then I assume everyone is putting their houses on it?

I didn't think so...
Does it actually mention how long the contract extension is for?

IMO Brian's job in the first two years he's been here was firstly, to clean out the deadwood, which he did. The second year was building a team, which he did and the third year, this year, is where we can expect to be competitive in every game - win a few more of those close games we lost last year, and make the eight. But then again, maybe I'm being far too optimistic.
 

Karmawave

Bench
Messages
4,950
But the point is, why not take away ALL doubt ( and financial risk ) , and just sit back and see how we start the year before committing money we can't afford to lose?


The extension will be multi year JD, you can bet your house on that.


On one hand we can take a risk and extend his contract now in the hope the team performs well ( based on a 15th and 9th ).

or..

On the other hand we can simply wait it out and see before diving in with an extension.

It should be the most basic business decision in the world.

The NRL - the only job where you can get rewarded with secured employment and financial security based on hope! :lol:
 
Last edited:

Yosh

Coach
Messages
12,012
Biggest personnel mistake since the inception of the club.

Re-signing Smith long term before a ball is kicked off this year, will be ranked right up there with the failed Leagues Club fiasco as the worst business decision ever made at the Knights.


Hagan? Had us at the bottom of the table for 4 years ^^
 

voltron

Juniors
Messages
1,454
hmmm...im a bit tentative
i would want more than a 2 year extention
so a total of 5 years at the club
that would be the max
but then again i would be a bit disappointed to see smith go before he could do anything (assuming he will)
 

Karmawave

Bench
Messages
4,950
Hagan? Had us at the bottom of the table for 4 years ^^


And a premiership win in his first season?


Oh sure, anyone could have coached that gun team to a premiership right?

It was all because of Warren Ryan's great work , and having Andrew Johns in the team?

Well maybe some young coach can come in and do what Hagan did based on the good work of Brian Smith?

Because wrong or right - Hagan 1 premiership - Smith 0.


Hagan is not necessarily a great coach - far from it. But he wasn't a financial mistake in the same way Brian Smith could potentially be for this club.

Hagans contract was extended based on a premiership win and other semi final appearances.

What are we basing Smiths extension on? A 15th and 9th?

And I'm talking purely from a business perspective.
 

Jobdog

Live Update Team
Messages
25,696
And a premiership win in his first season?


Oh sure, anyone could have coached that gun team to a premiership right?

It was all because of Warren Ryan's great work , and having Andrew Johns in the team?

Well maybe some young coach can come in and do what Hagan did based on the good work of Brian Smith?

Because wrong or right - Hagan 1 premiership - Smith 0.


Hagan is not necessarily a great coach - far from it. But he wasn't a financial mistake in the same way Brian Smith could potentially be for this club.

Hagans contract was extended based on a premiership win and other semi final appearances.

What are we basing Smiths extension on? A 15th and 9th?

And I'm talking purely from a business perspective.
Well, in fairness, our gameplan that year was "give it to Joey" and that was it. You saw how much we struggled when he was out injured - look no further than that 40-0 spanking we got from Parra earlier in the year. At least Smith has got the team not being reliant on one individual ...
 

Yosh

Coach
Messages
12,012
Karma but like sure you can judge a man's achievements by numbers on a page. I mean sure a coach should be judged by their teams achievements. HOWEVER

this is totally different. The club was in the s*#ts before BSmith came in. I mean it might be coincidental but not only have our team improved drastically, our that is Joeyless,

but the club as a whole seems to have taken a new direction for the better, upgraded facilities, stadium upgrades etc etc. You must admit when Hagan was around

the club seemed 2nd rate however as this new team progresses we look more like a team who looks like a winning team.
 

Karmawave

Bench
Messages
4,950
This needn't be a discussion comparing Hagan v Smith.

And no one here is taking away what Smith has achieved so far!

It is a discussion on whether or not Brian Smith deserves an extended contract based on a 15th, 9th and HOPE, while risking guaranteed money the Knights cannot afford to lose financially.

What is the harm, in sitting back, and waiting to see how the Knights perform this year before extending his contract?

Do people really think that half a dozen other clubs would be lining up to poach Smith away from the Knights in the meantime?

Why extend his contract based on hope, when we have the opportunity to sit back and actually SEE how he performs before committing all that money.

No other business would commit long term employment to someone based on mediocrity, when they have an opportunity to actually see how they perform during the remainder of their first contract!
 

Yosh

Coach
Messages
12,012
You have to look at it from a varity of angles.

1. BSmith would obviously like to know whether he is signed or not so he can decide what to do with his life so he is only concerntrating on his footy.

2. BSmith would have different gameplans if he knew he was only here for one year or 3 years. Know what I mean? Uncertanity is a very bad thing.

3. Players obvoiusly want to know if their coach is staying or going, similar to point 1.

4. Who else if not BSmith?

There must be another gazillion reasons to sign him up before the season kicks off... I think maybe 2 year extention so he has a good 5 year stint here to see what he is capable

of. And seroiusly I am sure everyone in Rugby League would love to see BSmith win a premiership then retire right?
 
Messages
16,034
is where we can expect to be competitive in every game - win a few more of those close games we lost last year, and make the eight. But then again, maybe I'm being far too optimistic.

I am not as optomistic I am hoping that we will but it wont suprise me if we have another disappointing year if injuries take their toll.....
 
Messages
3,813
Biggest personnel mistake since the inception of the club.

Re-signing Smith long term before a ball is kicked off this year, will be ranked right up there with the failed Leagues Club fiasco as the worst business decision ever made at the Knights.
Yep. Glad you have yourself to listen to cos noone here is interested mate. You actually believe your own press which is what makes me laugh the most.
 

General Knight

Juniors
Messages
1,380
I can see where Karma is coming from but to say Smith has achieved nothing based on 15th and 9th result is absolutey rubbish and one dimensional. And if your gonna say that us fans are happy with Smith because he got the team producing such mediocore results is a pretty piss weak reply too.
 

TooheysNew

Coach
Messages
1,150
I can see where Karma is coming from but to say Smith has achieved nothing based on 15th and 9th result is absolutey rubbish and one dimensional. And if your gonna say that us fans are happy with Smith because he got the team producing such mediocore results is a pretty piss weak reply too.
That's not really the point. We can't afford to pay out a contract, and we had the opportunity to wait and see how this season panned out before we did anything. Instead, we've jumped the gun, made a rash decision, and risk severe monetary consequences if we don't perform.
 
Top