What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Knock-on Effect NSW Cup - Eels Team

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
63,763
Not a big sample size but we have lost both games without him.

Anyway I said at the start of the year that he wasn't in our top 17. I've got no defeat to admit. My point is that he's better than you whingers make out. Wayne Bennett himself said nobody is ever as good or as bad as the fans think. I trust his opinion over a bunch of nuffies, thanks.

You could be evolving Pou and left the rest of us behind?
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,772
Fortunately I can form my own opinion on players. Paulo is just not a first grade player. It's not a whinge,
But rather stating a fact. Not my fault if you fail to see it or won't admit it after months of talking him up.

I'll concede we've looked better without him, though that has coincided with not having Sandow defending in the line. Plus with Kelly attacking at right halfback there has been no need for Paulo at first receiver. Kelly was quite good against Souths.
 

T.S Quint

Coach
Messages
14,975
I'll concede we've looked better without him, though that has coincided with not having Sandow defending in the line. Plus with Kelly attacking at right halfback there has been no need for Paulo at first receiver. Kelly was quite good against Souths.

Glad I wasn't the only one who thought so.
Reading back through the game thread all I saw were posts putting shit on him.
I don't remember him doing too much wrong, plus he set up a couple of our tries.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
154,209
I think some people are worried about getting bashed if they say he had a half decent game.
 

Parra47

Juniors
Messages
1,252
Some brief thoughts on the game while I sit around at the station:

Wenty actually played alright in the first 20 and last 20 minutes. These periods corresponded with the times that Alvaro and Lasalo were on and we weren't simply getting hammered up the middle.

Joseph Paulo has a shocker. Don't fret Poups, I am not going to scapegoat him for the loss but he did not play a game that warranted a first grade recall. Easily had 3 or 4 errors to his name and it was all round pretty disappointing given the quality effort he had last week.

Cody Nelson had a real go. Not a flash player by any yard stick but plugged away in attack and defence all game.

Matterson had one of his worst defensive efforts today, getting brushed off twice but was otherwise pretty good I think. Still a bit hesitant to fully pull the trigger when he runs to the line but he got through quite a bit of support work, threw some very good balls out to his left (Folau bombing a certain try from one) and was really sound with his attacking kicks. Bombs dropped short of the goal line and grubbers either had to be taken spectacularly by a forward or otherwise found the in goals. Still a work in progress but he is stringing together more consistent efforts.

French was very good versus the kick. On point all game and did his share of return work. Not sure if Wenty have figured out decent attacking structures for him though. Both Henry and Matterson seemed to prefer to play at the line instead of using him throughout the game. Produced a nice try assist at the end when he jumped out of dummy half and worked across the goal line.

Outside backs didn't have too much input positively on the game. Folau bombed a try and also had a very silly double movement attempt. Crooks and Faraimo looked pretty brittle together on the right. Crooks had some nice runs out wide while Faraimo did some grunt work up the middle but on the whole that edge got carved up pretty badly. Goodall was probably the best of the backs having a good balance between ruck work and metres on the edge. Also came up with two near perfect kicks that produced repeat sets. Both he and Folau had a bad miss on the goal line when they were scrambling after a Gardner line break.

Oh and the refs continue to be abysmal at all grades. What else is new...

Alvaro and Nelson have been pretty good for weeks now. Hard to know how they'd go at NRL level. Nelson I think would be a solid worker like he is in the NSW Cup, he was a very talented youngster but has had a shocking run with injuries over the years, a bit like Henry. Good to see him getting some solid football time. Alvero could still develop into a very good NRL player. Needs to improve his speed and mobility though.
 
Last edited:

Parra47

Juniors
Messages
1,252
He got picked, by nobody from our club's management, for the City-Country match. It wasn't because he's not good enough for reserve grade.

Talk about flogging a dead horse, its the "Hoppa is a great fullback" crap all over again. Your a sensational judge of football talent Poo.
 

Parra47

Juniors
Messages
1,252
Fortunately I can form my own opinion on players. Paulo is just not a first grade player. It's not a whinge,
But rather stating a fact. Not my fault if you fail to see it or won't admit it after months of talking him up.

Nailed it.
 

Casper The Ghost

First Grade
Messages
9,924
When I came across this thread I sensed intense violence within it. Yep, was right again.
I prefer dirty dirty talk.
Oh well back to the footy, just what did you say about princess paulo?
What's happened to the owl man?
He talked dirty with his owl?
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,772
Does anyone know what happened to Ualesi and Newbigging? Both still alleged members of the NRL squad. Ualesi hasn't even played for Wenty for months and I don't think Eric Newbigging has played at all this year.
 

Forty20

First Grade
Messages
7,677
Does anyone know what happened to Ualesi and Newbigging? Both still alleged members of the NRL squad. Ualesi hasn't even played for Wenty for months and I don't think Eric Newbigging has played at all this year.

Last I saw of Ualesi a few weeks back he was stomping around in a knee brace. Not sure what happened to Newbigging though.
 
Top