What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Knock-on Effect NSW Cup - Eels Team

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
16,504
No, testing starts long before merkins get a run in higher grades. That’s how clubs decide who gets a run and who doesn’t. They already know which Flegg players (or Flegg graduates) will struggle in NSW Cup, because they observe them in the junior grades and test them at training. If you can’t do it at training you’ll never do it on game day.

This isn’t to say that players who train well will automatically make it. But it’s the first barrier. They need to prove they deserve a chance in a higher grade (e.g. NSW Cup). Then they need to prove they can handle that grade. There aren’t enough reserve grade opportunities to give every Flegg player a run. Those opportunities go to the players who prove their speed/strength/fitness/technical ability and professionalism beforehand.

f**k me you love to be argumentative...

Those guys I named have proven in Flegg over the past 14 or so weeks that they can defend against players under 21 it's now time for them to do it against older more experienced players...

There is no harm putting them in CUP instead of those Merkins I named that are RMC players.

If they make it they make it if they don't they don't...

But putting them in cup benifits the club more than playing these Merkins
Alfred Smalley
Kayne Kalache
Meni Luke
Beau Newlands
Beni Valu

As well as wasting time with Carty Greig ect who are gone next year...
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
95,012
f**k me you love to be argumentative...
Says the merkin arguing with me
Those guys I named have proven in Flegg over the past 14 or so weeks that they can defend against players under 21 it's now time for them to do it against older more experienced players...
Why do you think Guymer and Pryke (both Flegg eligible) got a run instead of all these other Flegg forwards you think will be able to keep up in reserve grade?
There is no harm putting them in CUP instead of those Merkins I named that are RMC players.
The harm is that they haven’t earnt the right over the players who have. How is that good for club culture?
If they make it they make it if they don't they don't...

But putting them in cup benifits the club more than playing these Merkins
Alfred Smalley
Kayne Kalache
Meni Luke
Beau Newlands
Beni Valu

As well as wasting time with Carty Greig ect who are gone next year...
Reserve grade is to prepare merkins to be NRL backups, as well as to test youngsters deemed ready (e.g. Nanva, Twidle, Penisini, Guymer, Pryke). The ones getting an opportunity show that the club are happy to pick players out of Jersey Flegg. So the ones not getting picked must not be up to standard.
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
16,504
Says the merkin arguing with me

Why do you think Guymer and Pryke (both Flegg eligible) got a run instead of all these other Flegg forwards you think will be able to keep up in reserve grade?

The harm is that they haven’t earnt the right over the players who have. How is that good for club culture?

Reserve grade is to prepare merkins to be NRL backups, as well as to test youngsters deemed ready (e.g. Nanva, Twidle, Penisini, Guymer, Pryke). The ones getting an opportunity show that the club are happy to pick players out of Jersey Flegg. So the ones not getting picked must not be up to standard.

And you say you are not a troll 🧌 Merkin
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
16,504
Any other Merkin wants to discuss our juniors and development I am all ears. Pou Pou can go sit in a corner for a while
 
Last edited:

Timana

Juniors
Messages
613
For those playing at home, TCT don’t really talk up Richard Penisini as a glowing prospect. They do Twiddle however.

Fishing Fail GIF by Conesulfoz
They did during the pre-season. They were saying what a physical specimen he was.

Post injury.... zip
 

Latest posts

Top