kris keating future with the eels?

[Suitman]

I'm not ALWAYS an idiot

Don't worry. I'm not getting you confused with parra pete.

Suity

 

[Bazal]

:lol:

Well in sir

 

[Eelementary]

I am more than willing to give the 7 to robson and I think Pete sums it up the best. If KK ends up there, then he must be in scintilating form to take the 7 away from robbo.

Eele, how come everytime I felt when Robson kicked it went to the fullback ala finch.

Hayne found spaces and Mortz was getting better towards the end, but I think Robbo found the fb more than he found grass

I don't know. But I took particular care of watching his games against the Titans and Broncos and in both games his kicking game was pretty good. Certainly no worse than his counterparts, being Prince and Lockyer.

But I do agree that Kris Keating is a phenomenal little player and if he wrestles the halfback position from Jeff, it can only be good.

I'm just trying to illustrate that yes, Jeff Robson isn't the world's most skillful halfback. But he's doing a good job doing what he does, and he does actually have a bit of skill. Let us also not forget that although he is mature in age, he is still a rookie in NRL First Grade games standards...

 

[yy_cheng]

I don't know. But I took particular care of watching his games against the Titans and Broncos and in both games his kicking game was pretty good. Certainly no worse than his counterparts, being Prince and Lockyer.

But I do agree that Kris Keating is a phenomenal little player and if he wrestles the halfback position from Jeff, it can only be good.

I'm just trying to illustrate that yes, Jeff Robson isn't the world's most skillful halfback. But he's doing a good job doing what he does, and he does actually have a bit of skill. Let us also not forget that although he is mature in age, he is still a rookie in NRL First Grade games standards...

As much as I prefer a different style of halfback, I watched him in the interview after the dogs game and I too wish him all the best to succeed. He has worked hard enough.

 

[parra pete]

Don't worry. I'm not getting you confused with parra pete.

Suity

I might be a merkin, I might be a know it all, I might be a pain in the arse, but Suity and Bazal, one thing I definitely am not is AN IDIOT...

 

[TheParraboy]

I might be a merkin, I might be a know it all, I might be a pain in the arse, but Suity and Bazal, one thing I definitely am not is AN IDIOT...

I wouldnt say your an idiot, merkin or know it all pete

as for pain in the arse, im sure the jury is out in these neck of the woods :lol:

 

[Avenger]

Pete is just a passionate old bastard set in his ways. I have actually learnt to like him over these cyber years.

 

[Captain BF]

Pete has his place, they just haven't dug it yet...

 

[Springs]

Why the comparison of Robson and Sterlo? Why not compare Keating and Sterlo, I'm sure Keating will hardly do any better than Robson there. And Hindmarsh is the same kind of player as Price. The 80s had Kenny and Sterlo as the 'visionarys'. We have Mortimer, and even without Robson we still have Mateo.

 

[parra pete]

Pete has his place, they just haven't dug it yet...

Bad Minton.....:lol:

Rules about holes...when you find yourself in one, stop digging

 

[parra pete]

I wouldnt say your an idiot, merkin or know it all pete

as for pain in the arse, im sure the jury is out in these neck of the woods :lol:

I'll put my hand up to being all three - but as I said I am not a f**king idiot. I find it offensive to be called an idiot by people who don't agree with my point of view on a Internet forum.
I don't resort to those name calling tactics, and I don't expect them to be levelled at me.
Call me what you like, Call me a merkin, call me a know all bastard ---- but IDIOT is not one that fits my description.

 

[yy_cheng]

I'll put my hand up to being all three - but as I said I am not a f**king idiot. I find it offensive to be called an idiot by people who don't agree with my point of view on a Internet forum.
I don't resort to those name calling tactics, and I don't expect them to be levelled at me.
Call me what you like, Call me a merkin, call me a know all bastard ---- but IDIOT is not one that fits my description.

alright you Dullard

 

[mickdo]

I am not a f**king idiot

Tied a knot in it eh? ;-)

 

[Bazal]

Harden the f**k up pete, you idiot

 

[Suitman]

Harden the f**k up pete, you idiot

:lol:

Suity

 

[parra pete]

bite cha arse

 

[Suitman]

bite cha arse

That's better, you idiot. :lol:

Suity

 

[btaag]

I like Robson, but if Keating plays just above average, and his defence is not a complete liability, I can see him replacing Robson by Round 10. If Mortimer and Hayne provide enough of the try assists and strategic kicking, Robson might play most of the season with Keating as the impact player.

Keating is easily the more talkented player of the two, though I have lots of respect for Robson.

PS - YY - lets win a GF before comparing the 2010 Eels to the 1983 Eels....

 

[BissyB]

I like Robson, but if Keating plays just above average, and his defence is not a complete liability

it's not bad at all if you watch the replays of him playing. has a great technique, gets low in tackles. However, his goal line defense is lacking.
I'd say he defends better than Mortimer.

 

[Craig Johnston]

it's not bad at all if you watch the replays of him playing. has a great technique, gets low in tackles. However, his goal line defense is lacking.
I'd say he defends better than Mortimer.

i remember kk's effort in the toyota cup semi final at fb and it wasn't pretty :lol:

but true his defence up in the line is as good as anyone