What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Leagues club AGM 2012

Messages
15,428
Gronk,

This question was raised at the FC AGM in December. The response from the chairman had a few points.

1) He didn't believe 3P had that as a promise when elected.
2) He believed the current system worked well and saw no reason to change it.

I also want to be clear. Roy Spagnolo didn't run for the Football club board on the 3P ticket. Indeed I spoke with Roy after the election of the 3P team on two occasions before the Leagues Club election and on both times Roy was "considering" running and indeed considering what side to run with.

The constitution does not need to be amended. The issue is ownership of the NRL license. Currently the license has been granted to the Parramatta National Rugby League Club Limited (PNRLC or NRL / NYC operations), which is a fully owned subsidiary of the Parramatta Leagues Club Group (PLC). If that company was sold to the Parramatta District Rugby League Football Club (PDRLFC or Football Club.) for a dollar that would suffice as far as I understand. The problem comes down to the funding.

Last year the Leagues club subsidies the football operations to tune of 3.6 million and gave another Million to the PDRLFC as a Grant. As far as I understand, a parent organization can fund a child organization tax free. Whereas granting money to another organization starts to get taxed quite extremely once you get above a certain value (1.1 million or something like that). This is why the clubs organization was changed back in 1999, partially in preparation for a merger, partially to reduce the tax burden and partially to attract players as the leagues club would “guarantee” any contract, and in the wake of the Bears and Bunnies both leaving players out of pocket, that was seen as a positive.
 

bartman

Immortal
Messages
41,022
Gronk,

This question was raised at the FC AGM in December. The response from the chairman had a few points.

1) He didn't believe 3P had that as a promise when elected.
Wow, you could've fooled me. I recall that being one of the main points that swayed me to vote for them in the FC elections in late 2008?
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,719
Gronk,

This question was raised at the FC AGM in December. The response from the chairman had a few points.

1) He didn't believe 3P had that as a promise when elected.
2) He believed the current system worked well and saw no reason to change it.

I also want to be clear. Roy Spagnolo didn't run for the Football club board on the 3P ticket. Indeed I spoke with Roy after the election of the 3P team on two occasions before the Leagues Club election and on both times Roy was "considering" running and indeed considering what side to run with.

The constitution does not need to be amended. The issue is ownership of the NRL license. Currently the license has been granted to the Parramatta National Rugby League Club Limited (PNRLC or NRL / NYC operations), which is a fully owned subsidiary of the Parramatta Leagues Club Group (PLC). If that company was sold to the Parramatta District Rugby League Football Club (PDRLFC or Football Club.) for a dollar that would suffice as far as I understand. The problem comes down to the funding.

Last year the Leagues club subsidies the football operations to tune of 3.6 million and gave another Million to the PDRLFC as a Grant. As far as I understand, a parent organization can fund a child organization tax free. Whereas granting money to another organization starts to get taxed quite extremely once you get above a certain value (1.1 million or something like that). This is why the clubs organization was changed back in 1999, partially in preparation for a merger, partially to reduce the tax burden and partially to attract players as the leagues club would “guarantee” any contract, and in the wake of the Bears and Bunnies both leaving players out of pocket, that was seen as a positive.

OK fair enough. Thnx
 

Maroubra Eel

Coach
Messages
19,044
Wow, you could've fooled me. I recall that being one of the main points that swayed me to vote for them in the FC elections in late 2008?

Well it looks like the structure was correct all along. Maybe 3P realized they were wrong about changing it.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,719
Wow, you could've fooled me. I recall that being one of the main points that swayed me to vote for them in the FC elections in late 2008?

Yeah but perhaps that was just Terry Leabeater shooting his mouth off ? He was the 3P spin doctor at the time and was behind some quite outrageous statements and (I think) fed Josh his daily leads. So not really sure if it was policy on the 3P website or just Seven's spin.

It's a shame that the election thread has been "archived" and we could solve this minor mystery in a flash.
 
Last edited:

forward pass

Coach
Messages
10,209
Yes mate, that is the night, it is the same night as the supporters club meeting. I do plan to be there and question the minutes of the AGM, (available Online) I am mentioned in the minutes 3 times. The first time they got my name wrong. . . .

Good because the spelling of your name is one of the biggest issues we have........
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,786
ok people, this is a golden opportunbity to turn up and make your presence felt in front of the board and CEO, I can't believe this hasn't been spoken about in great length but I would like to ask, would you consider turning up and really putting the blow torch on our reprentatives?..if you're A member you have a god given right to and should do it..

PS: unfortunately I can't make it due to work committments but would love to hear or read what went on..
 

Eels Dude

Coach
Messages
19,065
ok people, this is a golden opportunbity to turn up and make your presence felt in front of the board and CEO, I can't believe this hasn't been spoken about in great length but I would like to ask, would you consider turning up and really putting the blow torch on our reprentatives?..if you're A member you have a god given right to and should do it..

PS: unfortunately I can't make it due to work committments but would love to hear or read what went on..

This is for Leagues Club members as opposed to football club members is it not?
 

Kornstar

Coach
Messages
15,578
appreciated mate, you could be on your own by the looks of it..

Out of curiosity, what would we ask?

There was an interview during the week that answered everything. He is safe till next year, we will not get the spoon, they completely support him, they will give him help if he needs it.........what else could we ask?

Anything that will be asked will only be dodged. Have you not seen the Facebook questions?

I am betting every tough question could be asked and we would still know nothing more than we already currently know.
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,786
Out of curiosity, what would we ask?

There was an interview during the week that answered everything. He is safe till next year, we will not get the spoon, they completely support him, they will give him help if he needs it.........what else could we ask?

Anything that will be asked will only be dodged. Have you not seen the Facebook questions?

I am betting every tough question could be asked and we would still know nothing more than we already currently know.

have you been to a football or leagues club AGM???...believe me they will get absolutely smashed, particularly if Fitzy and his mate John Fenwick turn up, I'm so cut about not being able to make Tuesday but for those who do i guarantee fire works plus!!
 

Latest posts

Top