LU Panthers all time 17 Team. Final Result.

[betcats]

Depends how you are doing it really. On achievements at penrith then its basically all the current guys. Sorro has 4 rings, Kenny 3. Hard to leave them out based on their resume., But if its on talent or favourites then there were be some of the older guys in there.

 

[soc123_au]

Depends how you are doing it really. On achievements at penrith then its basically all the current guys. Sorro has 4 rings, Kenny 3. Hard to leave them out based on their resume., But if its on talent or favourites then there were be some of the older guys in there.

It's subjective really. Like you say if it's achievement then its' just a matter of coming up with the best 17 from the past 4 years. I'll be looking at it as the ultimate Panthers dream team, so will be interested in the discussions on how you narrow down Cleary, Luai, Brandy, Freddy, Preston, Carter, Gower etc into the limited spots. Some positions imo will pick themselves, but others will be hotly contested with some gun players missing out. Something to keep us amused over the off season.

 

[Frankus]

It’s a tough one

1. Edwards
2. Rooney
3. Fittler
4. S Crichton
5. To’o
6. Luai
7. Cleary
8. Leota
9. Royce
10. Fisher-Harris
11. Lewis
12. Liam Martin
13. Yeo
14. Gower
15. Geyer
16. G Alexander
17. Priddis

I know that isn’t a real bench but just picking best 13 and 4 others.

Pains me to omit guys like Girds, Big T, Cartwright, Steve Carter, Api, Kenny, Kikau.

I know there will be some brow raising selections like Lewis in the 2nd row considering he won a prem on the wing over someone like Puletua, Kikau or Sorro. I just loved Lewis - could play anywhere but I always thought his best body of work was in the second row. Won a Clive although not with us.

Possibly even Royce at 9 over Priddis, Api or Kenny. Maybe nostalgia for me - was our first ever Kangaroo rep.

 

[Pjf04b]

Memories vs recency. Impossible choices.

 

[TheEroticGamer]

People who were around in the early 90’s will have to share who was better out of Geyer and Cartwright. Might decide a spot. Our 2nd row historically is stacked.

 

[soc123_au]

People who were around in the early 90’s will have to share who was better out of Geyer and Cartwright. Might decide a spot. Our 2nd row historically is stacked.

Depends what you want from a player. Cartwright was more skillful and reliable. Geyer was a flat out lunatic. Both great, but in different ways.

 

[Alintheeast]

Funny no one mentions Trent Waterhouse played for Australia 12 times. Maybe move Critta to wing bring in Fittler to centre.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Rooney might be our most overrated Panther of all time

 

[MugaB]

It's a difficult task.

Where does a bloke like Sorro fit? Four rings but probably not as talented as others.

Number ONE for all time rigg and studliness

 

[MugaB]

This would be my team..

1. Dylan Edwards
2. Stephen Crichton
3. Ryan Girdler
4. Brad Fittler
5. Brian To’o
6. Jerome Luai
7. Nathan Cleary
8. Moses Leota
9. Royce Simmons
10. Fisher-Harris
11. Tony Puletua
12. Liam Martin
13. Isaah Yeoweh
14. Greg Alexander
15. Mark Geyer
16. Luke Lewis
17. Luke Priddis

18th. Preston Campbell,
Honourable mentions
Steve Carter,
Rhys Wesser,
John Cartwright,
Scott Sorrenson,
Villiame Kikau.

 

[Alintheeast]

This would be my team..

1. Dylan Edwards
2. Stephen Crichton
3. Ryan Girdler
4. Brad Fittler
5. Brian To’o
6. Jerome Luai
7. Nathan Cleary
8. Moses Leota
9. Royce Simmons
10. Fisher-Harris
11. Tony Puletua
12. Liam Martin
13. Isaah Yeoweh
14. Greg Alexander
15. Mark Geyer
16. Luke Lewis
17. Luke Priddis

18th. Preston Campbell,
Honourable mentions
Steve Carter,
Rhys Wesser,
John Cartwright,
Scott Sorrenson,
Villiame Kikau.

I know Brandy is an all time panther great but the team would be better served with Gower at 14 and then Cartwright replacing Priddis. Also include Colin Vandervoort in Hon Mention.

 

[Luke Bowden]

I was born in 1987, so my knowledge of the older boys has definitely played a huge role in my team.

1.Edwards
2.Taylan May
3.Critter
4.Burton
5.Bizza
6. Romey
7.Cleary

8.Leota
9.Api
10.Fish
11.Kikau
12.Marto
13.Yeo

14.Kenny
15.Spencer
16.Capewell
17.Scottie to Hottie

That team would be unstoppable

 

[ColdWetPanther]

Depends what you want from a player. Cartwright was more skillful and reliable. Geyer was a flat out lunatic. Both great, but in different ways.

I would have Tony P over both of them. Had the skill of Cartwright but on his day could be as physical at Geyer; made many a half his speed bump…

 

[ColdWetPanther]

1. Wesser
2. To’o
3. Fittler
4. Critta
5. Flash
6. Cleary
7. Alexander
8. Moses
9. Kenny
10. Clinton (mostly because he loves his dad)
11. Tony P
12. Martin
13. Yeo

14. Fish
15. Spencer.
16. Geyer
17. Lewis.

 

[Chins get the wins]

I was born in 1987, so my knowledge of the older boys has definitely played a huge role in my team.

1.Edwards
2.Taylan May
3.Critter
4.Burton
5.Bizza
6. Romey
7.Cleary

8.Leota
9.Api
10.Fish
11.Kikau
12.Marto
13.Yeo

14.Kenny
15.Spencer
16.Capewell
17.Scottie to Hottie

That team would be unstoppable

May over Mick Gordon? No way in the world

 

[Luke Bowden]

May over Mick Gordon? No way in the world

Everyday of the week.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Everyday of the week.

Yeah no chance. Gordon was f**king amazing

 

[Luke Bowden]

Yeah no chance. Gordon was f**king amazing

Yep excellent player.

May fits way better into this team than he does though and it’s not even a contest.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Yep excellent player.

May fits way better into this team than he does though and it’s not even a contest.

Not quite on the level of your Soni and Api opinion but it gives it a run! Doubt you'd find another human not named May that agrees with you.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Not quite on the level of your Soni and Api opinion but it gives it a run! Doubt you'd find another human not named May that agrees with you.

Ok mate… you can’t actually tell me why Mick Gordon would be a better fit, you can just yet again drudge up Somi Luke…

Pathetic.