LU Panthers Forum Player of the Year

[Fangs]

Edwards 6 (Very little in attack)
Mansour 7
Yeo 7
Naden 6
To’o 6
Maloney 8 (The ice man)
Cleary 6 (Not bad tonight, better than last week I thought)
Tamou 9
Kenny 3 (His worst game to date)
JFH 8
Winterstein 5
Kikau 8
Martin 5 (Not all his errors were his fault, but overall had one to forget)

Egan 6
Luai 4
Leota 5
RCG 6

 

[OldPanther]

I docked him for the first Souths try.

Why? He was still one of the best on ground only second to probably Maloney. Anything less than a 7 and the score isn't legit in my opinion.

 

[TheFrog]

Why? He was still one of the best on ground only second to probably Maloney. Anything less than a 7 and the score isn't legit in my opinion.

My feeling with these ratings is that rather than questioning the ratings of others, you do your own. That way the outcome is a collective decision. I thought Nathan was nervous tonight. He never has a bad game, but it wasn't his best game.

 

[OldPanther]

My feeling with these ratings is that ratings is that rather than questioning the ratings of others, you do your own. That way the outcome is a collective decision. I thought Nathan was nervous tonight.

I have no intention of that. I thought it was just you doing the numbers though.

 

[age.s]

Edwards 7
Mansour 6
Yeo 7
Naden 6
To’o 6
Maloney 7
Cleary 6
Tamou 8
Kenny 5
JFH 8
Winterstein 5
Kikau 7
Martin 6

Egan 6
Luai 4
Leota 5
RCG 6

 

[soc123_au]

Edwards 7
Mansour 6
Yeo 7
Naden 7
To’o 6
Maloney 8
Cleary 7
Tamou 8
Kenny 5
JFH 8
Winterstein 5
Kikau 7
Martin 6

Egan 6
Luai 4
Leota 5
RCG 6

 

[Thirsty Panther]

Rd 14

Edwards 7
Mansour 5
Yeo 7
Naden 7
To'o 7
Maloney 8
Cleary 7
Tamou 7
Kenny 5
Fisher-Harris 8
Kikau 7
Winterstein 5
Martin 7

Egan 6
Luai 5
Leota 6
Campbell-Gillard 6

 

[mxlegend99]

Edwards 6
Mansour 6
Yeo 7
Naden 6
To’o 7
Maloney 8
Cleary 7
Tamou 9
Kenny 4
JFH 9
Winterstein 4
Kikau 8
Martin 6

Egan 6
Luai 4
Leota 5
RCG 6

 

[Tronald Crump]

Edwards 7
Mansour 6
Yeo 7
Naden 7
To'o 7
Maloney 8
Cleary 6
Tamou 8
Kenny 5
Fisher-Harris 8
Kikau 8
Winterstein 4
Martin 7

Egan 6
Luai 4
Leota 6
Campbell-Gillard 6

 

[martielang]

Edwards 7
Mansour 6
Yeo 7
Naden 7
To'o 7
Maloney 8
Cleary 7
Tamou 8
Kenny 3
Fisher-Harris 8
Kikau 7
Winterstein 4
Martin 6

Egan 7
Luai 4
Leota 7
RCG 6

 

[Pomoz]

Rd 14

Edwards 6
Mansour 4
Yeo 5
Naden 5
To'o 6
Maloney 7
Cleary 6
Tamou 7
Kenny 5
Fisher-Harris 7
Kikau 6
Winterstein 4
Martin 5

Egan 5
Luai 4
Leota 5
Campbell-Gillard 4

A couple of points:

• RCG 54m and 22 tackles at 84.5%. Lazy rubbish for the contract he is on.
• Egan 28 tackles 1 missed. Good tidy work. Now Wayde, about your attack....
• Winterstein 25m and 8 tackles in his 26 minutes. Lazy.

 

[Fangs]

A couple of points:

• RCG 54m and 22 tackles at 84.5%. Lazy rubbish for the contract he is on.
• Egan 28 tackles 1 missed. Good tidy work. Now Wayde, about your attack....
• Winterstein 25m and 8 tackles in his 26 minutes. Lazy.

I'll take the couple. 3rd one I'm not sure about.

I feel like Winterstein is playing a poor man's CHN role. Run lines. He pulled off a great one early in the Manly game that got us into space. Unless we have injuries in game I wouldn't expect any significant game time or high workload stats.

 

[OldPanther]

Rd 14

Edwards 6
Mansour 4
Yeo 5
Naden 5
To'o 6
Maloney 7
Cleary 6
Tamou 7
Kenny 5
Fisher-Harris 7
Kikau 6
Winterstein 4
Martin 5

Egan 5
Luai 4
Leota 5
Campbell-Gillard 4

A couple of points:

• RCG 54m and 22 tackles at 84.5%. Lazy rubbish for the contract he is on.
• Egan 28 tackles 1 missed. Good tidy work. Now Wayde, about your attack....
• Winterstein 25m and 8 tackles in his 26 minutes. Lazy.

We were better when Egan came on. Kenny was our worse hooker for that game and doesn't get a mention

 

[mxlegend99]

I'll take the couple. 3rd one I'm not sure about.

I feel like Winterstein is playing a poor man's CHN role. Run lines. He pulled off a great one early in the Manly game that got us into space. Unless we have injuries in game I wouldn't expect any significant game time or high workload stats.

Whatever his role. It's not very effective and it's a waste of a spot in our pack.

 

[Fangs]

Whatever his role. It's not very effective and it's a waste of a spot in our pack.

I don't disagree. I just don't think he is lazy. His job isn't to rack up a big workload.

 

[TheFrog]

Closing R14 noon Saturday. Update after that.

 

[martielang]

Whatever his role. It's not very effective and it's a waste of a spot in our pack.

He’d be on minimum wage or close too. Think he’s provided great value when he’s been given more than 20mins, I don’t think we utilise him enough.

 

[TheFrog]

Round 14 (Rabbitohs) Average Ratings

Edwards 6.8
Mansour 5.8
Yeo 6.7
Naden 6.5
To’o 6.6
Maloney 7.6
Cleary 6.5
Tamou 7.9
Kenny 4.4
JFH 7.9
Winterstein 4.3
Kikau 7.2
Martin 6.1

Egan 5.9
Luai 4.1
Leota 5.5
RCG 5.7

Standings (games)

1. Fisher-Harris 903 (14)
2. Tamou 891 (14)
3. Cleary 765 (13)
4. Maloney 750 (13)
5. Campbell-Gillard 712 (13)
6. Leota 696 (14)
7. Mansour 605 (12)
8. Kikau 600 (10)
9. Yeo 585 (10)
10. Egan 534 (10)
11. Blake 501 (10)
12. Edwards 491 (10)
13. Martin 471 (8)
14. DWZ 467 (10)
15. Katoa 467 (11)
16. Whare 416 (9)
17. Winterstein 353 (7)
18. Grant 335 (7)
19. To'o 314 (5)
20. Luai 312 (7)
21. Sele 279 (5)
22. Fuimaono 255 (6)
23. Kenny 246 (4)
24. MWZ 206 (4)
25. Naden 200 (3)
26. Aekins 152 (3)
27. Hetherington 98 (2)
28. Ellis 54 (2)

 

[TheFrog]

Round 15

Edwards 7
Mansour 7
Yeo 7
Naden 9
To'o 6
Luai 6
Maloney 8
Tamou 7
Kenny 5
Fisher-Harris 8
Kikau 7
Winterstein 5
Martin 7

Egan 5
Campbell-Gillard 6
Leota 5
Whare 6

I didn't dock either sin binned player because I thought neither deserved to be binned.

 

[Fangs]

Round 15

Edwards 7
Mansour 9 (His best game of the year. Professional performance)
Yeo 6
Naden 9 (The machine)
To'o 5 (Disappointing, maybe playing injured?)
Luai 5
Maloney 9
Tamou 7
Kenny 5
Fisher-Harris 8
Kikau 8
Winterstein 6
Martin 6

Egan 6
Campbell-Gillard 7
Leota 6
Whare 7