LU Panthers Forum Player of the Year

[Abacus]

Any chance of having a punt on the eventual winner of this prestigious award?

Come on Jimmy Tamou!!

 

[mxlegend99]

In an effort that poor i don't think many players deserve above average scores. Guys makings lots of errors or giving away penalties or not doing their job effectively don't deserve a decent score.

Edwards 3
Mansour 3
Whare 4
Blake 4
Watene-Zelezniak 4
Maloney 5
Cleary 5
Tamou 7
Egan 5
Leota 4
Sele 3
Yeo 5
Fisher-Harris 6

Campbell-Gillard 4
Hetherington 3
Fuimaoiono 4
Luai 5

 

[Abacus]

In an effort that poor i don't think many players deserve above average scores. Guys makings lots of errors or giving away penalties or not doing their job effectively don't deserve a decent score.

Edwards 3
Mansour 3
Whare 4
Blake 4
Watene-Zelezniak 4
Maloney 5
Cleary 5
Tamou 7
Egan 5
Leota 4
Sele 3
Yeo 5
Fisher-Harris 6

Campbell-Gillard 4
Hetherington 3
Fuimaoiono 4
Luai 5

Looks pretty close. My only question is the 5 for Luai? Did Luai do something in his 19 minutes that warranted more than a 3?

 

[mxlegend99]

Luai changed momentum of the game for mine. Which was pretty much his job from the bench.

I think he did as much in as little time as any of our spine did to help us out. Seeing him have a positive effect on the team boosted his score for me.

 

[Abacus]

I must have missed that at the ground. I saw the momentum shift to us when Jenko went to the bin - Luai came on a few minutes later after Egan had already scored. For a 5 in 19 minutes I'd have expected a try, a try assist , a linebreak or something?

I know these are subjective ratings but a 5 against a suite of 3's and 4's would/should indicate somthing tangible from Luai?

I don't mean to single you out - a couple of posters gave him 6's but their scoring seems generally higher across the board. How anyone gave RCG a 7 is f**king beyond me.

 

[Black Magik]

Could you edit your first post to say it's been updated, otherwise I might either count you twice or not at all. Thanks

No problem.

 

[TheFrog]

Can I just say that the idea here is not to argue with the ratings of others but to post your own.

 

[martielang]

I thought Hetherington was better than people are rating him. Should of had a try assist, ran & tackled hard.

 

[age.s]

I thought Hetherington was better than people are rating him. Should of had a try assist, ran & tackled hard.

Gave away his usual bone headed penalty though.

 

[Pomoz]

Round 1

Edwards 5
Mansour 4
Whare 4
Blake 4
Watene-Zelezniak 4
Maloney 6
Cleary 5
Tamou 8
Egan 5
Leota 5
Sele 3
Yeo 5
Fisher-Harris 6.5

Campbell-Gillard 5.5
Hetherington 4
Fuimaoiono 4
Luai 5

 

[Thirsty Panther]

Ok, after I've calmed down a bit.

Round 1

Edwards 4
Mansour 4
Whare 5
Blake 5
Watene-Zelezniak 4
Maloney 6
Cleary 5
Tamou 8
Egan 6
Leota 6
Sele 4
Yeo 5
Fisher-Harris 7

Campbell-Gillard 4
Hetherington 4
Fuimaoiono 5
Luai 4

 

[Fangs]

I too will put forward a legit rating:

Edwards 4
Mansour 3
Whare 4
Blake 5
Watene-Zelezniak 3
Maloney 5
Cleary 3
Tamou 9
Egan 5
Leota 5
Sele 5 (Unlucky)
Yeo 5
Fisher-Harris 5

Campbell-Gillard 1
Hetherington 4
Fuimaoiono 4
Luai 5

 

[soc123_au]

Round 1

Edwards 4
Mansour 2
Whare 5
Blake 5
Watene-Zelezniak 5
Maloney 6
Cleary 5
Tamou 8
Egan 5
Leota 6.5
Sele 4
Yeo 5
Fisher-Harris 6

Campbell-Gillard 4
Hetherington 6
Fuimaoiono 5
Luai 6

 

[GongPanther]

I'm taking in consideration the mistakes in the 1st half coupled with the enormous penalty count:

Edwards 6

Mansour 4

Whare 7
Blake 4 (push in the back pen & unable to simply put down a ball over the tryline.)

Watene-Zelezniak 3

Maloney 8

Cleary 7

Tamou 9

Egan 7

Leota 5

Sele 6

Yeo 7

Fisher-Harris 7

Reagan Campbell-Gillard 5

Hetherington 6

Fuimaoiono 6

Luai 6

 

[TheFrog]

Ok, after I've calmed down a bit.

Probably wise after a loss.

 

[Kilkenny]

Edwards 5
Mansour 3
Whare 5
Blake 6
Watene-Zelezniak 5
Maloney 6
Cleary 5
Tamou 8
Egan 6
Leota 5
Sele 4
Yeo 5
Fisher-Harris 7

Campbell-Gillard 5
Hetherington 5
Fuimaoiono 5
Luai 5

 

[TheFrog]

Ratings for round 1 close at kick-off for the round 2 match. We've got 10 people so far. You can still vote on round 2 even if you didn't on round 1. I'll put up the result of round 1 sat after kickoff.

 

[Panfa]

Edwards 5 mansour 4 whare 5 blake 5 zelezniak 4 maloney 6 cleary 5 sele 5 yeo 5 fisher harris 6 leota 4 egan 6 tamou 7 campbell gillard 5 hetherington 5 fuimaono 5 luai 6

 

[TheFrog]

Average Ratings for R1

Edwards 4.3
Mansour 3.5
Whare 4.7
Blake 4.8
DWZ 4.1
Maloney 6.0
Cleary 5.2
Tamou 8.0
Egan 5.7
Leota 5.5
Sele 4.3
Yeo 5.5
Fisher-Harris 6.5
Campbell-Gillard 4.6
Fuimaiono 4.8
Luai 5.3

 

[age.s]

Edwards 6
MWZ 7
Blake 6
Whare 6
DWZ 7
Maloney 8
Cleary 6
Tamou 8
Katoa 7
Leota 6
JFH 8
Yeo 7
Sele 6

Egan 6
Winterstein 8
RCG 9
Hetherington 6