LU Panthers Forum Player of the Year

[Kilkenny]

Was at work and only saw half the game in bits and pieces. Did watch some but not all of the replay so not in a proper position to give assessments of player ratings.

I will say it was pleasing to see RCG having a crack. One game does not make a season but if the weekend is an indication of his returning to his best then that will be great for us. We need him to deliver on his pay check and be our forward leader along with Tamou who seemed to have another good game against the Knights.

It was a decent win even if our attack overall remains clunky and not anywhere near the level it needs to be.

 

[Pomoz]

This is Panfa's ratings made easier to read, and not Pomoz's ratings which are identical? Am I right?

yes. A bit easier. I stopped at removing the words.

 

[GongPanther]

Edwards 6

MWZ 8

Whare 7

Blake 6

DWZ 6

Maloney 10

Cleary 8

Tamou 9

Katoa 6

Leota 8

Fisher Harris 8

Yeo 8

Sele 6

Benchies.

Campbell-Gillard 9

Egan 7

Winterstein 8

Hetherington 6

 

[unKwn]

Dyl 6
Malakai 7
Whare 5
Blake 7
Dallin 7
Maloney 8
Cleary 6
Tamou 8
Katoa 6
Leota 6
Fisher 7
Yeo 7
Sele 5

RCG 9
Egan 6
Frankenstein 8
Hethro 5

 

[TheFrog]

Closing ratings for Round 2 an hour before today's kickoff time, ie 6.30pm today.

 

[TheFrog]

Round 2 average ratings:
Edwards 6.5
MWZ 6.5
Whare 5.6
Blake 6.5
DWZ 6.5
Maloney 7.7
Cleary 6.5
Tamou 7.9
Katoa 6.4
Leota 6.3
Sele 6.1
Yeo 7.2
Fisher-Harris 7.7
Campbell-Gillard 8.3
Hetherington 5.1
Winterstein 7.1
Egan 5.7

Standings

Tamou 15.9 (2)
Fisher-Harris 14.2 (2)
Maloney 13.7 (2)
Campbell-Gillard 12.9 (2)
Yeo 12.7 (2)
Leota 11.8 (2)
Cleary 11.7 (2)
Egan 11.4 (2)
Blake 11.3 (2)
Edwards 10.8 (2)
DWZ 10.6 (2)
Sele 10.4 (2)
Whare 10.3 (2)
Hetherington 9.8 (2)
Winterstein 7.1 (1)
MWZ 6.5 (1)
Katoa 6.4 (1)
Luai 5.3 (1)
Fuimaiono 4.8 (1)
Mansour 3.5 (1)

 

[age.s]

Edwards 1
DWZ 5
Blake 6
Whare 5
Mansour 5
Maloney 6
Cleary 5
Tamou 6
Katoa 5
Leota 4
JFH 6
Winterstein 5
Sele 5

Egan 5
RCG 4
Fuimaiono 4
Martin 4

 

[Black Magik]

I thought this was going to be enjoyable, having a difficult time choosing MOM, but it getting hard to find a decent player at all.

Edwards 1
DWZ 5
Blake 5
Whare 5
Mansour 4
Maloney 6
Cleary 4
Tamou 6
Katoa 5
Leota 4
JFH 5
Winterstein 3
Sele 5

Egan 5
RCG 4
Fuimaiono 4
Martin 4

 

[TheFrog]

Well I'm not watching that again so gere goes

Edwards 3
Mansour 6
Whare 6
Blake 5
DWZ 5
Maloney 6
Cleary 6
Tamou 6
Katoa 5
Leota 5
Fisher-Harris 6
Winterstein 5
Sele 5
RCG 5
Egan 5
Martin 5

 

[mxlegend99]

Well I'm not watching that again so gere goes

Edwards 3
Mansour 6
Whare 6
Blake 5
DWZ 5
Maloney 6
Cleary 6
Tamou 6
Katoa 5
Leota 5
Fisher-Harris 6
Winterstein 5
Sele 5
RCG 5
Egan 5
Martin 5

Pretty sure you missed a '-' infront of Edwards score.

 

[mxlegend99]

Edwards 0
DWZ 5
Blake 5
Whare 5
Mansour 5
Maloney 5
Cleary 6
Tamou 5
Katoa 5
Leota 4
JFH 5
Winterstein 2
Sele 5

Egan 5
RCG 5
Fuimaiono 3
Martin 4

Our halves made more metres than our f**king forward pack for christs sake.

 

[Panfa]

1.EDWARDS =Absolute shocker 1pt 2.MANSOUR=Soft runs looks injured 3pts 3.WHARE=wont see out his 5yrs 3pts 4.BLAKE=our best back no quality ball 6pts 5.WATENE ZELEZNIAK =needs to go back to fullback 4pts 6.MALONEY=super league is calling stalling luai from playing 1st grade 3pts 7.CLEARY=run across field and pass back inside 50 times 4pts 13.SELE=small guy runs hard tries hard bench player at best 5pts 12.FISHER=our best defender tries hard needs to go back to lock 5pts 11.WINTERSTEIN=got size good hole runner another bench player 5pts 10.LEOTA=not a starter form is crap needs to go back to Canterbury cup 4pts 9.KATOA=small slow and always day dreaming at dummy half 2pts 8.TAMOU=worst game this yr looked slow and lethargic 3pts 14.EGAN=we looked much better when he came on not enough game time needs to start 5pts 15.CAMPBELL GILLARD=pick of the front rowers some strong runs needs to start games 6pts 16.MARTIN=tough debut playing against storm not ready for 1st grade 4pts 17.FUIMAONO=too slow in the backs too small in the forwards 3pts

 

[Thirsty Panther]

Here we go.

Edwards 1
Mansour 5
Whare 6
Blake 6
DWZ 6
Maloney 6
Cleary 6
Tamou 6
Katoa 5
Leota 5
Fisher-Harris 6
Winterstein 5
Sele 5
RCG 5
Egan 6
Martin 6

 

[Fangs]

Edwards 1
Mansour 6
Whare 4
Blake 4
DWZ 4
Maloney 5
Cleary 4
Tamou 6
Katoa 5
Leota 5
Fisher-Harris 5
Winterstein 4
Sele 5

RCG 4
Egan 4
Martin 6
Fuimaiono 4

Edwards...wanted to give him another mark for trying hard but sorry. Worst game I've seen from a Penrith fullback.

Maloney slightly dangerous, Cleary had nothing. Katoa some nice touches but nothing much in attack. Very disappointing performance from the spine overall.

Martin has promise, good debut. Decent comeback Mansour.

 

[GongPanther]

Edwards 0
Mansour 5
Whare 6
Blake 6
DWZ 6
Maloney 7
Cleary 1
Tamou 8
Katoa 4
Leota 6
Fisher-Harris 6
Winterstein 6
Sele 6

RCG 2
Egan 6
Martin 8
Fuimaiono 5

Ref 0.

 

[Pomoz]

Edwards 2
Mansour 4
Whare 3
Blake 4
DWZ 3
Maloney 4
Cleary 3
Tamou 5
Katoa 3
Leota 3
Fisher-Harris 5
Winterstein 3
Sele 6

RCG 5
Egan 4
Martin 4
Fuimaiono 3

 

[TheFrog]

Pretty sure you missed a '-' infront of Edwards score.

You're big on metres. Edwards ran 168. That gets him 3/10 from me.

 

[Black Magik]

You're big on metres. Edwards ran 168. That gets him 3/10 from me.

How many of those with the ball?

 

[unKwn]

don't remember half the game and I'm glad I don't, so my ratings might be a bit off

Dickfingers Dyl - 2
Sauce - 4
Whare - 3
Waqa - 4
DWZ - 4
Maloney - 5
Cleary - 3
Tamou - 5
Katoa - 3
Leota - 3
JFH - 4
Frankenstein - 3
Sele - 5

RCG - 4
Egan - 4
Martin - 4
Tyrell - 3

 

[TheFrog]

Closing round 3 6.30pm Friday.