Maguire Might Not Choose Teddy This Year

[betcats]

Absolutely, teddy out played him twice this season.

I concede ponga might be a different story.

Yet last origin Walsh smoked Teddy,

 

[ColdWetPanther]

Except for this year as the stats show.

The only year Edwards has been better in his entire career was last year

Hopefully someone more tech savvy than me has found the clip of Karen Robbo pompously dismissing the journalist who suggested that ‘SuperCoach’ was something people should consider when comparing fullbacks.

 

[Mr. Shaman]

Absolutely, teddy out played him twice this season.

I concede ponga might be a different story.

Even Lehi Hopoate is a better team player and attacking fullback than Tedesco.

 

[Valheru]

Teddy touching the ball 3 times a set has been NSW's biggest failure in the last 5 years

He had to because of that dud at halfback

QLD must be petrified of Dylan running the ball lol

 

[Valheru]

Hopefully someone more tech savvy than me has found the clip of Karen Robbo pompously dismissing the journalist who suggested that ‘SuperCoach’ was something people should consider when comparing fullbacks.

Who mentioned supercoach?

 

[Valheru]

Yet last origin Walsh smoked Teddy,

Neither Walsh nor ponga would have played a single game for QLD if teddy was on that side unless it was off the bench.

 

[Chins get the wins]

He had to because of that dud at halfback

QLD must be petrified of Dylan running the ball lol

You're ŕetarded

 

[Danish]

Edwards could stat pad if he liked but he's a team player unlike Teddy

half of his metres gained - you know, his crowning glory stat which is the only place is ever ranked 1st out of the fullbacks - is off of making easy yards from kick returns.

he’s the true Paul Gallen of the backs. A super coach hero.

NSW have absolutely zero attacking prowess in 2 of our spine positions, and Hynes is going to be half fit to boot. Por Luai is going to be carrying the entire attack himself

 

[betcats]

Neither Walsh nor ponga would have played a single game for QLD if teddy was on that side unless it was off the bench.

lol sure.

 

[betcats]

half of his metres gained - you know, his crowning glory stat which is the only place is ever ranked 1st out of the fullbacks - is off of making easy yards from kick returns.

he’s the true Paul Gallen of the backs. A super coach hero.

NSW have absolutely zero attacking prowess in 2 of our spine positions, and Hynes is going to be half fit to boot. Por Luai is going to be carrying the entire attack himself

every fullback gets those metres

 

[Munky]

If Squiddy has outplayed Walsh twice this year are we able to use Edwards vs Teddy as an argument.

Because it's a little one sided since 2020...

 

[betcats]

If Squiddy has outplayed Walsh twice this year are we able to use Edwards vs Teddy as an argument.

Because it's a little one sided since 2020...

Yes fair point. Dyl has been outplaying Teddy in most of our games since 2021.

 

[Valheru]

lol sure.

Slater retired in 2018

You want to argue teddy wouldn't have been picked for QLD in 2019 and not lose his spot

Lol ok

 

[Valheru]

If Squiddy has outplayed Walsh twice this year are we able to use Edwards vs Teddy as an argument.

Because it's a little one sided since 2020...

Yes you can but winning and outplay are not the same thing.

Teddy also has way better stats than Walsh this season.

 

[Woody90]

He would walk in to the QLD team

LOL

 

[Valheru]

If NSW lose Dylan Edwards is solely to blame.

Doesn't matter what he or anyone else does.

 

[Valheru]

LOL

It wouldn't even be a debate

First picked

 

[Woody90]

Neither Walsh nor ponga would have played a single game for QLD if teddy was on that side unless it was off the bench.

I know you’re the most biased bloke on this site but this is objectively wrong and you know it.

 

[Chins get the wins]

If NSW lose Dylan Edwards is solely to blame.

Doesn't matter what he or anyone else does.

If he plonks himself next to the 7 all game cutting off all other passing options, gets the ball then crabs across to the sideline either taking the tackle or throwing a pass to the winger with zero room sure

 

[betcats]

Slater retired in 2018

You want to argue teddy wouldn't have been picked for QLD in 2019 and not lose his spot

Lol ok

Slaters dropped plenty guys. You think he wouldn’t drop 30yo out of form teddy last year? Please you’re delusional