Match Discussion: Round 25 vs Manly @ Leichhardt Oval, Lilyfield / Wanngal

[Vic Mackey]

Weird game, not sure what to take/make of it. Just happy we got the rub of the green and 2 points.

6 wins for the year was my pass mark, as sad as that sounds.

 

[Vic Mackey]

Such a good line and tough run from Seyfarth along with a beautiful pass from Latu. Twal even did some ball playing in the middle there as well.

I reckon i could argue Seyfarths been one of our top 5 players this year.

Api, Galvin, Bula, Samuela easily the top 4. Would say hes probably next down.

 

[Tiger05]

I reckon i could argue Seyfarths been one of our top 5 players this year.

Api, Galvin, Bula, Samuela easily the top 4. Would say hes probably next down.

I'd probably agree. I'm trying to think who else has been better.

....

I mean Doueihi's defense has been top notch but he hasn't played enough games.

 

[Tiger Ted]

I'd probably agree. I'm trying to think who else has been better.

....

I mean Doueihi's defense has been top notch but he hasn't played enough games.

I’m hoping Doueihi realises during off season it’s time for him to retire

 

[Nutz]

I’m hoping Doueihi realises during off season it’s time for him to retire

AD frustrates me. One minute he scores a nice try in the corner then the next minute he gets pushed off in a pathetic attempt to tackle which leads to a potential try to Souths, but held up by a baby Luki Laulilii.
4:35 min mark

When things are going good for him he can be the best on ground but more often that not its the opposite.
He's not costing us anything next year so I don't really care what happens to him.

 

[Tiger Ted]

AD frustrates me. One minute he scores a nice try in the corner then the next minute he gets pushed off in a pathetic attempt to tackle which leads to a potential try to Souths, but held up by a baby Luki Laulilii.
4:35 min mark

When things are going good for him he can be the best on ground but more often that not its the opposite.
He's not costing us anything next year so I don't really care what happens to him.

If he’s getting picked in the NRL team next yr then we r in trouble.Hes a massive liability.I had hope for him when he was talking the talk when returning from the long layoff but he’s shown that he’s incapable of walking the walk.Someone he respects needs to pull him aside & tell him
It’s time to put the cue in the rack.

 

[Nutz]

If he’s getting picked in the NRL team next yr then we r in trouble.Hes a massive liability.I had hope for him when he was talking the talk when returning from the long layoff but he’s shown that he’s incapable of walking the walk.Someone he respects needs to pull him aside & tell him
It’s time to put the cue in the rack.

When AD returned he took an intercept to race the full length of the field to out pace Weekes who is a young gun speedster. I thought is this the new AD.
But alas his defence is again poor for an experienced back.


I think he can be a contributor next year but depth only. I can't see him ousting our current stock plus new additions....unless of course his boyfriend Benji thinks otherwise.

 

[Nutz]

I'd probably agree. I'm trying to think who else has been better.

....

I mean Doueihi's defense has been top notch but he hasn't played enough games.

I'm sorry Tiger buddy, AD's defense is fair, even improved but not top notch. He tends to arm grab too much

 

[Tigerm]

I’m hoping Doueihi realises during off season it’s time for him to retire

I mentioned earlier last week, that the Parra thread is saying, they are chasing him.
They don’t need to be too fast to catch him, if they want him.

 

[Tiger Ted]

I mentioned earlier last week, that the Parra thread is saying, they are chasing him.
They don’t need to be too fast to catch him, if they want him.

It has to b fake news.Have they not been watching the impostor

 

[Tiger Ted]

I mentioned earlier last week, that the Parra thread is saying, they are chasing him.
They don’t need to be too fast to catch him, if they want him.

Maybe another Shamrocks old boy buckets O’Neill is trying to help us

 

[Tiger05]

I'm sorry Tiger buddy, AD's defense is fair, even improved but not top notch. He tends to arm grab too much

It was a joke. I honestly think the guy is a massive liability. That game you showed highlights of he was great but since then he has been horrible. You remember the good game but not the crap that he dishes out all the time. I should add it isn't just one good game followed up by 5 bad ones. It's one good 15 minute period followed up by 65 minutes of crap.

 

[Nutz]

It was a joke. I honestly think the guy is a massive liability. That game you showed highlights of he was great but since then he has been horrible. You remember the good game but not the crap that he dishes out all the time. I should add it isn't just one good game followed up by 5 bad ones. It's one good 15 minute period followed up by 65 minutes of crap.

Sorry mate, I'm a bit slow ha ha

 

[Nutz]

@Tiger05
What about his statement a few weeks ago when he said the stds were too low and some players need a stint in reserves. He'd be the first ha ha

 

[Tiger05]

@Tiger05
What about his statement a few weeks ago when he said the stds were too low and some players need a stint in reserves. He'd be the first ha ha

The delusion is real strong in him. Real strong. The reality is that he doesn't deserve a spot in the 17 anywhere unless we are decimated with injuries. He could be a really good utility back-up for us on minimal dollars.

 

[Tiger05]

Sorry mate, I'm a bit slow ha ha

Or my jokes are pretty shit.

 

[Nutz]

The delusion is real strong in him. Real strong. The reality is that he doesn't deserve a spot in the 17 anywhere unless we are decimated with injuries. He could be a really good utility back-up for us on minimal dollars.

AD is a reasonable goal kicker. Who else is there...
Api
Sezer - possibly leaving
Lobb - won't play NRL, depth
Latu Finau - bench player so not ideal
DaSilva - bench player, not ideal
??????

 

[Das Hassler]

Or my jokes are pretty shit.

Your delivery's good...I think it's just your material. Try this...." so WHAT'S the deal with the peanuts in the little bag?...you can never get them opened and when you do they spill all ( eye roll here) over the place...."..
If that don't work it's OK....I have others

 

[Tigerm]

AD is a reasonable goal kicker. Who else is there...
Api
Sezer - possibly leaving
Lobb - won't play NRL, depth
Latu Finau - bench player so not ideal
DaSilva - bench player, not ideal
??????

I believe Bird can kick goals?

 

[Nutz]

I believe Bird can kick goals?

If we get Bird I'm going to hand my membership back and demand a refund.