What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Matthew Lodge Arrested in New York

Iafeta

Referee
Messages
24,357
Toddles will tell us that we should have seen how contrite he was as he licked his lips as Wayne, his son Scott, his other boy Darius who was sitting by the bedside table, and Toddles himself presented with much glee disLodge with his new contract. Mick Ennis was urging them on as he casually interrupted another commentator mid sentence from completing an opinion "boys he will play Origin"
 

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
So going by Greenbergs above statement, I expect the NRL to approve Carneys NQ contract.

You can’t say this about Lodge-

“He made some really grave errors but he gets an opportunity to rebuild hislife and what I saw is that he is desperately trying to do that and I think rugby league has a part to play in that.”

And then turn around and tell Carney he isn’t welcome in the game. The media will have a field day with him if it turns out that way.

Carney is a complete genius but his later indiscretions are nothing compared to Packer and Lodge’s antics. Unless there is something that happened in the UK that hasn’t been publicly revealed yet that Todd got up to over there in his 3 year holiday.

People need to forget about comparing the severity of their offenses. Greenberg said they assess all of these things by the same standard.

1. What have they been doing since the indiscretion. Counseling etc.
2. Has to be long term progress. Years not months.
3. What are they doing going forward. Has to be some plan in place.

He said if Carney meets the criteria he'll be approved.
 

Eion

First Grade
Messages
8,034
People need to forget about comparing the severity of their offenses. Greenberg said they assess all of these things by the same standard.

1. What have they been doing since the indiscretion. Counseling etc.
2. Has to be long term progress. Years not months.
3. What are they doing going forward. Has to be some plan in place.

He said if Carney meets the criteria he'll be approved.
Great, can’t wait for a reformed pedo to join the nrl.
 

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
Great, can’t wait for a reformed pedo to join the nrl.

They have to have a set of rules to judge this stuff on and not allowing people into the game because the media can stir up some outrage isn't it. I prefer that the NRL are working with professional psychologist etc. and making sure the player meets certaun criteria and they do all the right things going forward.

One foot out of line and the NRL will crucify him.

Also funny how everyone keeps bringing up the women thing when the poor bloke who actually got attacked gets forgotten.
 

Eion

First Grade
Messages
8,034
They have to have a set of rules to judge this stuff on and not allowing people into the game because the media can stir up some outrage isn't it. I prefer that the NRL are working with professional psychologist etc. and making sure the player meets certaun criteria and they do all the right things going forward.

One foot out of line and the NRL will crucify him.

Also funny how everyone keeps bringing up the women thing when the poor bloke who actually got attacked gets forgotten.
The woman references may be about the first slapping he dished out. Who knows, we’re spoilt for choice.

The point is, there are some offences that even a one off should see expelled from the game. For me, Packer and Lodge are in that boat.

Even if I can cop him playing, I find it very difficult to accept the nrl didn’t make it a condition of playing that a portion of his wage is set aside to pay his victims.
 

Canard

Immortal
Messages
35,620
People need to forget about comparing the severity of their offenses. Greenberg said they assess all of these things by the same standard.

1. What have they been doing since the indiscretion. Counseling etc.
2. Has to be long term progress. Years not months.
3. What are they doing going forward. Has to be some plan in place.

He said if Carney meets the criteria he'll be approved.

Every offence is judged at the same standard.

f**k that. And completing a few weeks of "rehabiltion" in 3 years is lip service at best.

The guy hasn't even taken responsibility for his actions "it was the booze and the trainers fault"
 

Latest posts

Top