Mergers and Premiership Tallies

[Gaba]

im surprise 20knights10 and baron haven't complained about 2 teams winning the grand final in 2002

eastern suburbs and sydney roosters


what about that one should the sydney roosters be given the grand final or should eastern suburbs be given the grand final

 

[20knights10]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_NSWRL/ARL/SL/NRL_records#Premierships

LMAO... the link shown in the wikipedia link shows something else entirely....

Premierships
For a full list of NSWRL/ARL/SL/NRL premiers, see Australian rugby league premiers.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_rugby_league_premiers

 

[muzby]

given your record in here that means less than nothing...

ahh... rattling you even further.. i like that turncoat... now, by "here" do you mean this thread? if that's the case, i'm sad & i'll have to change my name so that i can start afresh.. that's how it goes, yeah?

Illawarra Steelers are not dead, they form a joint venture with the St George Dragons to create a new team... they also have a leagues club and 2 teams in junior competitions..

really? going off the arguments against the dragons in here, the steelers and the st george dragons are dead, finished in 1998 (well, so t-bag's signature tells me..)

so what is it? are the old teams still going or are they dead??

Wayne Bennett has coached 2 teams to a total of 7 premierships, this is in no way comparable to one team winning 15 premierships and another team made up from 2 former teams winning another not ammounting to a total of 16 for the newly formed team.....

why not then? you can't have your cake & eat it too.. you are counting 7 premierships for one man over two different clubs and including a separate comp - superleague (but hey, if we get really technical, he's won comps in 4 different leagues.. 5 if you include QLD cup..)

using that approach (which is sound btw, not faulting anyone on that..) how can the dragons have not won 16 premerships then?

Prior to 1999 you claim to have supported a team that had won 0 premierships, but now you claim that your team has won 16 after only 1 victory....

just as someone who used to support the dragons (who at that stage had 15 premierships) and starts supporting a new team, say the knights, can claim that their team has 2... and if you decided that GI will make a difference at souffs, when you start supporting south sydney next year can claim you support a team who has won 20 premierships...

You're not too bright.... any attempt from you to criticise will be considered a compliment...

so if that's how the game is played, i should call you full of integrity and making a lot of sense...

 

[20knights10]

im surprise 20knights10 and baron haven't complained about 2 teams winning the grand final in 2002

eastern suburbs and sydney roosters


what about that one should the sydney roosters be given the grand final or should eastern suburbs be given the grand final

A name change is hardly the formation of a new team made up from 2 seperate entities... that's pretty desperate mate....

 

[20knights10]

i should call you full of integrity and making a lot of sense...

You should, but you're too stupid to see it......

 

[muzby]

A name change is hardly the formation of a new team made up from 2 seperate entities... that's pretty desperate mate....

desperate is a 47 year old man arguing on the internet against people he doesn't know over a club that he used to support but is now bitter that they have finally won..



but hey, i prefer to call you turncoat..

 

[Y2Eel]

desperate is a 47 year old man arguing on the internet against people he doesn't know over a club that he used to support but is now bitter that they have finally won..



but hey, i prefer to call you turncoat..

You sure desperate is the word you are looking for?:?

 

[Gaba]

A name change is hardly the formation of a new team made up from 2 seperate entities... that's pretty desperate mate....

Actually different locations , the eastern suburbs represent the eastern suburbs where the sydney roosters represented different area away from just the eastern suburbs hence the name change.

The dragons and illawarra havent changed the areas on who they represent


so you are contradicting yourself , if you claim the eastern suburbs and Sydney roosters should be entitled to both be awarded a premiership

and stgeorge dragons and illawarra arent

 

[Y2Eel]

Actually different locations , the eastern suburbs represent the eastern suburbs where the sydney roosters represented different area away from just the eastern suburbs hence the name change.

The dragons and illawarra havent changed the areas on who they represent


so you are contradicting yourself , if you claim the eastern suburbs and Sydney roosters should be entitled to both be awarded a premiership

and stgeorge dragons and illawarra arent

What about the Sydney Bulldogs in 1995?

 

[Y2Eel]

Actually different locations , the eastern suburbs represent the eastern suburbs where the sydney roosters represented different area away from just the eastern suburbs hence the name change.

The dragons and illawarra havent changed the areas on who they represent


so you are contradicting yourself , if you claim the eastern suburbs and Sydney roosters should be entitled to both be awarded a premiership

and stgeorge dragons and illawarra arent

Either I am getting Smarter or the people that use these forums are becoming alot god damn hell of alot dumber...

And there is no way i am becoming smarter so it mast be the latter......

 

[Gaba]

What about the Sydney Bulldogs in 1995?

Thats another debate for those who are arguing , what is the difference why arent people questioning should canterbury be awarded the premiership count.


Stgeorge and illawarra are entitled to be awarded premierships .


if teams like the sydney bulldogs and roosters are merging with canterbury and eastern suburbs premierships when in fact they arent representing the same areas.


Dragons are representing the same area

 

[Y2Eel]

Thats another debate for those who are arguing , what is the difference why arent people questioning should canterbury be awarded the premiership count.


The dragons and illawarra are entitled to be awarded premierships .


if teams like the sydney bulldogs and roosters are merging with cantberbury and eastern suburbs premierships when in fact they arent representing the same areas.


Dragons are representing the same area

oh boy! I need a

 

[Gaba]

oh boy! I need a

tell me the difference

hasnt sydney bulldogs formed a joint venture with canterbury/bankstown

and Sydney roosters with eastern suburbs

so basically according to those who arguing about the dragons

its a similar scenario

if people are ok with sydney bulldogs and roosters being merged with canterbury and eastern suburbs

and arguing its not the dragons 16th you have lost the debate

 

[muzby]

oh boy! I need a

i recommend you go here...

 

[Y2Eel]

i recommend you go here...

Nice place food aint too bad either...

 

[Gaba]

trying to get this debate to stop repeating and going in circles

hence another thing for people to think about

 

[20knights10]

desperate is a 47 year old man arguing on the internet against people he doesn't know over a club that he used to support but is now bitter that they have finally won..



but hey, i prefer to call you turncoat..

 

[Y2Eel]

tell me the difference

hasnt sydney bulldogs formed a joint venture with canterbury/bankstown

and Sydney roosters with eastern suburbs

so basically according to those who arguing about the dragons

its a similar scenario

if people are ok with sydney bulldogs and roosters being merged with canterbury and eastern suburbs

and arguing its not the dragons 16th you have lost the debate

What years did eastern Suburbs and Roosters compete by themselves?

Same as the Sydney Bulldogs and Canterbury Bankstown?

Cos Iam fairly sure They only changed names not merged 2 teams together but hey i am contributing to this thread i must be an idiot!

 

[Gaba]

What years did eastern Suburbs and Roosters compete by themselves?

Same as the Sydney Bulldogs and Canterbury Bankstown?

Cos Iam fairly sure They only changed names not merged 2 teams together but hey i am contributing to this thread i must be an idiot!

dragons havent merged 2 teams either , joint venture they only change name, to add illawarra

The balmain tigers and western suburbs merged 2 teams together

 

[Y2Eel]

dragons havent merged 2 teams either , joint venture they only change name, to add illawarra

The balmain tigers and western suburbs merged 2 teams together

Thanks for answering my question no where did i say anything about the Dragons or Tigers...

I dont care how many titles people wanna give there team all that matters is who is the current champions..............

I still stand my my first statement about the stupidity of posters...