Mergers and Premiership Tallies

[SoftSydney]

Regardless softy.....do you agree that the statement "Dragons have won 16 premierships" is correct?

15 to St George Dragons and 1 to St George Illawarra Dragons. Even though they may be different teams to you, Dragons have won 16 premierships?

No I dont mate, I see it the way the league has, you can only credit one team or club a premiership. So how can we add to STG tally and STGI tally, we cant! it can only be added to one.
The whole thing is a brothel, I can see why STG fans claim 16 its a mess. Its a shame they merged, STG should have let them fold and taken over their juniors.

 

[SoftSydney]

I am off for NYE, have a good one guys dont drink and drive...see you all next year... well at least till the trials start.

Go the red V

 

[Willow]

Not at all mate I decided a couple of days ago based on your suggestion and even changed my avatar.

I just assumed you copied my avatar because I got under your skin.

You're not a Saints supporter softy, never will be.

I can only wonder why you refuse to declare your team on a RL forum. It's like you've got something to hide.

But hey, that's your choice kid. Nevertheless it's obvious that the idea of giving up any ground, no matter how small, has rattled you.

 

[Ulysseus]

I can't help but notice my questions were danced around once again.
Whatever.

Have a good NYE guys.

 

[backdoor]

In just a few hours, it will be a new year and we shall still be Premiers celebrating the 16th premiership win for the team in the Red V.

Enjoy a drink but don't drive.

 

[El Chivato]

It seems like the view of the forum is:
anyone who has gone for St.George= 16 prems
anyone who went for Illawarra=1 prem
anyone who has only ever gone for St.George/Illawarra Dragons=1

now the poll says 58.04% in favour of St.George/Illawarra= 1 prem
to 41.96% to St.George/Illawarra=16 prems

I need to ask:
Does this mean the St.George/Illawarra supporters posting in this topic disagree with the australian way of life, ie:
majority rules
??

 

[Jason Maher]

It seems like the view of the forum is:
anyone who has gone for St.George= 16 prems
anyone who went for Illawarra=1 prem
anyone who has only ever gone for St.George/Illawarra Dragons=1

now the poll says 58.04% in favour of St.George/Illawarra= 1 prem
to 41.96% to St.George/Illawarra=16 prems

I need to ask:
Does this mean the St.George/Illawarra supporters posting in this topic disagree with the australian way of life, ie:
majority rules
??

Actually, the two Illawarra supporters (myself and muzby) have been arguing quite strongly for 16. ;-)

And your last point is such obvious bait, and such illogical nonsense, that I'll leave it at "no comment".

 

[Willow]

now the poll says 58.04% in favour of St.George/Illawarra= 1 prem
to 41.96% to St.George/Illawarra=16 prems

:lol: Stand aside Newspoll.

Of course the poll asks no such question. I don't think the author was honourable enough to be so straight forward.

I need to ask:
Does this mean the St.George/Illawarra supporters posting in this topic disagree with the australian way of life, ie:
majority rules
??

lol. Nice bait. I have to say, this thread attracts a whole range of oddball blow-ins.

Yeah you're right Billy. It's now un-Australian to disregard internet forum polls.

Hey, shouldn't you be in the sharks forum warning people about what they post? Fifth columnists in our midst? Conspiracy theories?

 

[SoftSydney]

I just assumed you copied my avatar because I got under your skin.

You're not a Saints supporter softy, never will be.

I can only wonder why you refuse to declare your team on a RL forum. It's like you've got something to hide.

But hey, that's your choice kid. Nevertheless it's obvious that the idea of giving up any ground, no matter how small, has rattled you.

I am feeling it mate and I look good in red

 

[El Chivato]

And your last point is such obvious bait, and such illogical nonsense, that I'll leave it at "no comment".

and yet you did

:lol: Stand aside Newspoll.

Of course the poll asks no such question. I don't think the author was honourable enough to be so straight forward.
lol. Nice bait. I have to say, this thread attracts a whole range of oddball blow-ins.

Yeah you're right Billy. It's now un-Australian to disregard internet forum polls.

Hey, shouldn't you be in the sharks forum warning people about what they post? Fifth columnists in our midst? Conspiracy theories?

Willow, with your self-gradulation and mimicry of intelligenceiwould have thought that you'd pick up that I was having a joke, just to get involved in this wonderous topic.
Willow's keyboard work:
"El Chivato----google--- finds Billy the Kid"
"El Chivato----search----cronulla sharks forum"

I know many things, even about you, Old Man,
but for now I am Roger Kint, and I bid you farewell with a big sloppy *kiss*.
Willow's next move:"Roger Kint--------google"

 

[Willow]

I know many things, even about you

:lol:

Ooooh.

El Chivato's next move: ...ask for directions.

 

[muzby]

now the poll says 58.04% in favour of St.George/Illawarra= 1 prem
to 41.96% to St.George/Illawarra=16 prems

I need to ask:
Does this mean the St.George/Illawarra supporters posting in this topic disagree with the australian way of life, ie:
majority rules
??

actually, we are living in a country where the ruling government was not elected by the majority, so you may wnat to hold on to your point there for about 3 years...



**muzby smacks himself for re-igniting this thread after 5 days**
**muzby double smacks himself for talking in the 3rd person**

 

[SoftSydney]

LOL you guys love this thread, now that I am a STGI fan I still say 1

 

[muzby]

if you're a dragons fan now, i'm off to support the bulldogs.. i'd rank every one of their supporters ahead of you..

 

[SoftSydney]

if you're a dragons fan now, i'm off to support the bulldogs.. i'd rank every one of their supporters ahead of you..

As Wendell says the red v is a part of me

 

[muzby]

and as shaq says, you're an idiot..

 

[Hutty1986]

I still don't know how Shazam didn't win an Oscar. Truly wonderous cinematography.

 

[InThatNumber]

Thread finished yet? Yes? Good. So we all agree then. 16 it is. And Shaq was great in Blue Chips.

 

[SoftSydney]

Thread finished yet? Yes? Good. So we all agree then. 16 it is. And Shaq was great in Blue Chips.

Not until we get to 3000 and willow has the last word, so far we are still at one mate!

 

[dgsfan]

1 premiership. Hahaha!