Mergers and Premiership Tallies

[Willow]

Poor softy has bought the baroness's line - hook and sinker attached.

Softy, please try hard to read, and keep an open mind.

16 premierships overall is a perfectly legitimate way to recognise the TOTAL tally. I'm happy to accept the view that it is the first NRL grand final win for the JV and the 16th Dragons' premiership in TOTAL.

St George are part of the JV and were represented on October 3rd, 2010... whether you like it or not.

It can only be said in so many ways. And I've lost count of the amount of times this has been explained to you.

You either refuse to find common ground or the whole subject matter is just too much for you to fathom. It is becoming increasingly evident that the latter is closer to the mark.

the Tally is 15 AND 1 NOT 16 total as STGI is a new different team, this is the stance of STGI and the NRL.

It is not the stance of St George Illawarra. The St George Illawarra journal has TOTAL 16.

How many times have you been told this? When is the penny going to drop?

Try and look past your limited knowledge on the matter and try going beyond google when researching.

Learn about verification. Check the information, ask questions, keep an open mind, and be prepared to adjust when new facts come to hand. It might take you some time, but that won't be a problem if you really are genuine about research.

Hope this helps, but personally I doubt you know what I'm talking about.

 

[SoftSydney]

Poor softy has bought the baroness's line - hook and sinker attached.

Softy, please try hard to read, and keep an open mind.

16 premierships overall is a perfectly legitimate way to recognise the TOTAL tally. I'm happy to accept the view that it is the first NRL grand final win for the JV and the 16th Dragons' premiership in TOTAL.

St George are part of the JV and were represented on October 3rd, 2010... whether you like it or not.

It can only be said in so many ways. And I've lost count of the amount of times this has been explained to you.

You either refuse to find common ground or the whole subject matter is just too much for you to fathom. It is becoming increasingly evident that the latter is closer to the mark.

It is not the stance of St George Illawarra. The St George Illawarra journal has TOTAL 16.

How many times have you been told this? When is the penny going to drop?

Try and look past your limited knowledge on the matter and try going beyond google when researching.

Learn about verification. Check the information, ask questions, keep an open mind, and be prepared to adjust when new facts come to hand. It might take you some time, but that won't be a problem if you really are genuine about research.

Hope this helps, but personally I doubt you know what I'm talking about.

OK so how does the offcial tally work? Only one team can claim a premiership.

 

[Fingerbang]

OK so how does the offcial tally work? Only one team can claim a premiership.

And only one team did....STGI the JV. Just so happens that the JV team credited with the title consists of St George Dragons and Illawarra Steelers. We are not claiming 3 titles....one for each member of the JV and one for the JV. All we are saying is that it is 1 title for the JV, which also means it is the 16th title for Dragons and 1st for Steelers. That 3 titles in one year crap is von amanda's pisstake to keep this going. Either that, or he/she really is a moron.

Please....a spare vice someone!!!

 

[Jason Maher]

Baroness is a troll, pure and simple, and we all got trolled. Unfortunately, so did Softy, who bought Baroness' opinions as serious.

 

[SoftSydney]

And only one team did....STGI the JV. Just so happens that the JV team credited with the title consists of St George Dragons and Illawarra Steelers. We are not claiming 3 titles....one for each member of the JV and one for the JV. All we are saying is that it is 1 title for the JV, which also means it is the 16th title for Dragons and 1st for Steelers. That 3 titles in one year crap is von amanda's pisstake to keep this going. Either that, or he/she really is a moron.

Please....a spare vice someone!!!

How is that not claiming 3 titles? You mention 3 teams and 3 credits!!!
Only one team can receive the credit on the official tally, if you have one apple and you cut it in three and hand it out how can each holder claim a whole apple.... seriously mate what you are saying is delusional wishful thinking.

 

[Fingerbang]

Well....can see there is no point going on with you about this. It is obvious you are slower than a Rabbitoh's season. And nowhere did I say 3 titles were handed out, but if you see it that way...c'est la vie.

 

[Willow]

OK so how does the offcial tally work? Only one team can claim a premiership.

Seriously, are you unable to read?

I mean no disrespect but some people do suffer from dyslexia while others are just thick. Which category do you place yourself in?

 

[SoftSydney]

Well....can see there is no point going on with you about this. It is obvious you are slower than a Rabbitoh's season. And nowhere did I say 3 titles were handed out, but if you see it that way...c'est la vie.

What you fail to understand OR accept is that you can not cut an apple in three and have three different people claim a whole. You can not share a premiership, you can not divide it up or have different parties claiming a piece of it. STGI won it and they are the only ones that can claim it on thier tally.

It all goes back to the officially tally and record for 2010, do you propose *2010 STG 16 Steelers 1 STGI 1. The NRL has it right 2010 STGI 1.

 

[SoftSydney]

Seriously, are you unable to read?

I mean no disrespect but some people do suffer from dyslexia while others are just thick. Which category do you place yourself in?

since you are the clever beaver willow why dont you tell me how the tally should be reflected for 2010 on record?

 

[Willow]

Already posted that Einstein. Read it for yourself.

Hang in there Softy. I'm sure someone will come along to help you reinforce your faith.

 

[SoftSydney]

Already posted that Einstein. Read it for yourself.

Hang in there Softy. I'm sure someone will come along to help you reinforce your faith.

another one that wants to split an apple in 3 and claim a whole :lol:

 

[Fingerbang]

What you fail to understand OR accept is that you can not cut an apple in three and have three different people claim a whole. You can not share a premiership, you can not divide it up or have different parties claiming a piece of it. STGI won it and they are the only ones that can claim it on thier tally.

It all goes back to the officially tally and record for 2010, do you propose *2010 STG 16 Steelers 1 STGI 1. The NRL has it right 2010 STGI 1.

What the f*ck does apples have to do with it? If both you and the Baroness got your period at the same time and you only had one tampon between you.....you cut it and insert half each, and both have success in stopping your flow.

And by your reckoning....if the JV fell apart and both teams again become standalone entities in the NRL, you going to say the people of Illawarra are gonna have to go back to 0 premierships. Not likely.

 

[Willow]

Give the kid his apple? lol

The bandwagoner wants the last word.

He knows he's painted himself into a corner. Or maybe I'm giving him too much credit.

 

[SoftSydney]

What the f*ck does apples have to do with it? If both you and the Baroness got your period at the same time and you only had one tampon between you.....you cut it and insert half each, and both have success in stopping your flow.

And by your reckoning....if the JV fell apart and both teams again become standalone entities in the NRL, you going to say the people of Illawarra are gonna have to go back to 0 premierships. Not likely.

of course they go back to 0, the premiership is credited to STGI... which is reflected in the current record keeping of the league. what you guys are posting is wet dreams.

 

[SoftSydney]

Give the kid his apple? lol

The bandwagoner wants the last word.

He knows he's painted himself into a corner. Or maybe I'm giving him too much credit.

As far as I can see my view is reflected by the NRL's stance on the topic, last time I checked it was still 1.

 

[Willow]

Softy,

It's obvious you're new to this. Tell me which club you support and we'll try to find some common ground.

Cheers.

 

[SoftSydney]

Softy,

It's obvious you're new to this. Tell me which club you support and we'll try to find some common ground.

Cheers.

I took your advice mate and I am now on board as a STGI man, I am considering joining your secret squirrel club Jubilee ave!

 

[Willow]

I sense a lot of resentment.

It was just a question softy. Have you ever supported a team?

Cheers.

 

[SoftSydney]

I sense a lot of resentment.

It was just a question softy. Have you ever supported a team?

Cheers.

Not at all mate I decided a couple of days ago based on your suggestion and even changed my avatar. The red v its a part of me as big dell says!

 

[Fingerbang]

Regardless softy.....do you agree that the statement "Dragons have won 16 premierships" is correct?

15 to St George Dragons and 1 to St George Illawarra Dragons. Even though they may be different teams to you, Dragons have won 16 premierships?