eelectroshooting and colonel,
my judgement has not been solely laid at the feet of Witt being released, it has been based over the actions of the club and the coach over the last 3 years.....
prior to that i remained an advocate of Brian Smith and his coaching ability and (I admit) even though i didn't like him when at St. George.....i warmed to his approaches after the first couple of seasons at Parramatta....
but no.....past mistakes cannot or should not be forgiven by the recruitment for next year as i don't believe that BS deserves the right to have the chance with that talent after his indifferent 8 year tenure as Parramatta Head Coach......
8 years is a long time and there is a definite need for change....however, having said that, if BS stays and turns things around i will congratualte him and admit i had him marked wrong......but i don't see it happening, particularly as the direction halves at Parra still seems undetermined and looming as the annual fatal flaw in BS's plans......
and Colonel,
i have never advocated myself as the person to perform the deed as you put it, i am simply airing my opinion and i apologise if i air it to frequently.....but at least i am consistent and don't waver on my opinions.....surely that is worth something???