Misanthropes Distraction Mafia Game Thread

[KeepingTheFaith]

As good as your vote is suspicious.

Whether Drew is "melting down" or not his comments on your vote make sense, especially when you've never been shy a Hoppity lynch before.

 

[Drew-Sta]

That's some goooooood meltdown going on there.

:lol: No, just can't believe you focus more on how its said than what is said. Seriously, did you read what I posted? Your voting logic is flawed.

 

[Drew-Sta]

No, Drew, no I don't vote for you.

Retract that comment this instant!

I recanted

 

[Jason Maher]

Well, well, well... any real scum would just up say "I'm scum", wouldn't they? Please Drew.

 

[Drew-Sta]

As good as your vote is suspicious.

Whether Drew is "melting down" or not his comments on your vote make sense, especially when you've never been shy a Hoppity lynch before.

 

[Drew-Sta]

Well, well, well... any real scum would just up say "I'm scum", wouldn't they? Please Drew.

... which says to me you've read none of what I've said.

Look, I agree that Apey's post looks convincing. But the lynch train after it is not, and most of his comments are explainable.

I'm also role claiming. If you accept WP's role claim, but not mine, thats a fault in your logic right there.

 

[Apey]

Tards, the f**king lot of you. f**k!

Goose! Hogg did vote for micky you idiot! Go read the write up! I am on my phone so can't respond properly suffice to say the OMGUS vote was a silly jab at you simply because. I knew you'd get it. 9701 said in a game in the past he doesn't meta BM so wrong again and my flip flop was based on BM logic whic I quickly saw was useless and recanted.

Lynch me if you want but I am the guy I accused of bein mafia last day who got killed and he aint mafia.

You dumbass HipphoppHoppity. You charge at people for no logic then jump on this shit? You sheep.

The name-calling doesn't really help your cause, especially seeing as two of them were directed at me despite me being 100% correct in that instance, lol. Yes, I know you've realised your error now.

Not going to go through all this post, partly because I may not have the time but also because a lot of it is fairly irrelevant (the original point as well as your response) and unimportant compared to other things.

I'm role claiming. Does that count for me?

Assuming 9701 made the cut, sure.

Mafia have a significant advantage as most of town is vanilla. Night favours them. Does it not? How is my claim false?

It is the principle of mafia that coordinated attack by a minority has an advantage over a scattered defence by the ignorant majority.

That is the advantage they have. Am I wrong?

I'd say in a game where we outnumber them 4:1 with 11 powers between us, plus some of us have passives, and assuming soc hasn't gone crazy with a strong protection chain, that nobody has any overall advantage over the other.

I'm genuinely trying to work it out. I'm going to make mistakes (9701 is clearly one). But I'm blue.

Of course, we all are going to make errors, as I tried to make clear my reasoning wasn't about who you voted for but why you voted for them.

And yet tis is EXACTLY what has happened.

And this is EXACTLY what has not happened.

Funny isn't it, considering my vote doesn't even count. But I meant what I said. It really was aimed to 'get the ball rolling' and generate more evidence to interpret so to speak.

 

[HowHigh]

Change vote: BM

 

[Apey]

I am going out for most of the day, unsure how much I'll be able to check this. I was about to say I'll change my vote to a no vote so as not to contribute to a lynch that may lose traction in my absence, but then I remembered... :<

Oh well. Symbolism and all that.

change vote: no vote

 

[Hoggmaster]

As I said in a previous post, you are right and Hogg didn't vote. He also didn't orchestrate the lynch, but he also was very wishy washy. His jumping on WP was, to me, a case of 'joining' a lynch train on very little. Which is usually what mafia do.

I didnt 'join' the WP lynch train I laid out the night before why I thought WP was suspect (killing a town memebr is pretty sus) then when it was day voted for the person I felt was suspect. I also believe I was the 2nd or 3rd vote in that... not exactly jumping on a speeding locomotive

 

[Drew-Sta]

The name-calling doesn't really help your cause, especially seeing as two of them were directed at me despite me being 100% correct in that instance, lol. Yes, I know you've realised your error now.

I was going for a meltdown. I've never done one and wanted to try it out. The name calling was really a formality rather than personal ;-)

Not going to go through all this post, partly because I may not have the time but also because a lot of it is fairly irrelevant (the original point as well as your response) and unimportant compared to other things.

? Eh? You go to great lengths to point out in great detail things I take the time to refute, then claim its unimportant compared to other things?

Assuming 9701 made the cut, sure.

It would be dangerous to role claim without knowing if it is in or not. And without knowing if someone had it should I be making it up.

Besides, how do we know Derp-Sta made it? Yet we're happy to accept WP's word?

I'd say in a game where we outnumber them 4:1 with 11 powers between us, plus some of us have passives, and assuming soc hasn't gone crazy with a strong protection chain, that nobody has any overall advantage over the other.

I'd still argue mafia have the advantage right now. Also why are you downplaying the mafia's position? Seems awful interesting. The greatest lie the devil did tell was that he didn't exist. The second was that he wasn't dangerous.

Of course, we all are going to make errors, as I tried to make clear my reasoning wasn't about who you voted for but why you voted for them.

And I've tried to straighten that out. My logic on 9701 was sound; it was just wrong. The WP flip flop was my own sillyness. I regret that.

But yes - the way I framed my argument on 9701 was, in my opinion, well done and had good reason. You picked it apart to find an issue.

Also, I'm finding it strange that you do this to me, but don't do it to Hoppity or WP. Why me? What made you think of that? Your post was a good distraction; a tactic commonly employed by mafia. This perks my curiosity.

Funny isn't it, considering my vote doesn't even count. But I meant what I said. It really was aimed to 'get the ball rolling' and generate more evidence to interpret so to speak.

And it did. And it distracted. And now, this day phase, we're choosing between Hopalong and I.

You've got my attention, rApey.

 

[Apey]

Going out, can't respond in full, so I'm going to (seemingly, don't have time to explain sorry!) do some flip-flopping of my own.

change vote: Drew-Sta.

 

[Drew-Sta]

lol. Sure.

If it isn't as obvious as dogs balls, then town are going to be lined up for another reaming.

 

[Bazal]

Drew is convincing. BM has offered no argument except to accuse those voting for him. Change Vote BM

 

[Hoggmaster]

Can we get a vote update? Also the last few lists have included my vote twice (one for WP and one for Drew) Is this some unknown power that you've given me in the face of Drews bullying :'-( ?

 

[Drew-Sta]

I'm not bullying. I'm hunting Marcia.

 

[BunniesMan]

Drew says apey is convincing. Then says people that are convinced by apeys convincing argument are suspicious...

And you said Apeys post hasn't generated discussion. WTF are you on. It's generated a hundred posts of discussing.

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

Only generated discussion after the initial burst of voting. If the rest of us had done likewise the vote would be long over.

Drew was offline from about 6:30pm to 9:30pm. The lynch could easily have happened before then.

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

Can we get a vote update? Also the last few lists have included my vote twice (one for WP and one for Drew) Is this some unknown power that you've given me in the face of Drews bullying :'-( ?

I believe Hoppity is on 7 and Drew down to 5 with WP on 6.

This is assuming Apey's vote doesn't count and I can count (which is probably also wrong). It also depends on whether Soc has you counted twice.

 

[BunniesMan]

I'm very confident both Drew and WP are Mafia.

My next tier of suspects are Baz and Mis.

KTF is sliding down. Seems less suspicious today. I should remember to excuse his temporary psychosis in future.