Most impressive rookie after three rounds?

[gorilla with a shotgun]

Mick Dobson... Played very good against the storm

 

[Harold Bishop]

Matt Ballin. A very clever Hooker.

 

[Bicey_18]

James McManus played a good game against the Dragons, both in attack and defence

 

[Morenito]

Falau for mine.... considering he is 17 as well. Interesting to see what happens when Turner returns from injury.

Is Feleti Mateo still considered a rookie? I know he played one game 2 years ago i think

 

[Pistol]

gotta be Folau

only 17 and is keeping Steve Turner who so bitterly fought to stay in Melb in the Brisbane Norths side

 

[Hutty1986]

James McManus played a good game against the Dragons, both in attack and defence

He looks a very good prospect. Folau and Ballin have been tremendous as well.

4 tries to Williams but he's looked a passenger at times imo

 

[Pistol]

He looks a very good prospect. Folau and Ballin have been tremendous as well.

4 tries to Williams but he's looked a passenger at times imo

ur right about williams

however he isnt playing well enough to keep his spot once Hornby and Head are both fit

 

[fourplay]

Feleti Mateo has massive amounts of natural talent

 

[Pistol]

mateo does ham it up a bit when he is in a tackle but has bags of talent to play footy

 

[Pumba]

Israel Folau & James McManus Great Prospects!

 

[Pumba]

Feleti Mateo has massive amounts of natural talent

To milk penalties...... CORRECT

 

[Hallatia]

Israel Falou for mine, but I was impressed with what I saw of Morris too
talented bunch of kids we got coming through

 

[JJ]

my vote's for Ballin, handled a difficult position with a lot of class and maturity.

 

[simon says]

Everoyone is raving about Falaou......but I havent seen that much from him really.

I could have scored the tries he did.....except for one bomb he caught,all he has done is caught the ball in space and cross the line.

Hardly rookie of the year stuff IMO.

 

[RainMan]

Feleti Mateo has massive amounts of natural talent

Played a game of 1st grade in 2005? Would not be eligible.

 

[simon says]

To milk penalties...... CORRECT

Yessssssss.

But how stupid are certain refs for letting players like this get away with it.

Milking should earn the opposition a penalty.

But home town Clarkieeeeee.

 

[Hallatia]

Played a game of 1st grade in 2005? Would not be eligible.

that does not make him inelligableplaying one game in the year does not make him inelligable for rookie of the year, some players had more and were still elligable in a different

 

[Pistol]

that does not make him inelligableplaying one game in the year does not make him inelligable for rookie of the year, some players had more and were still elligable in a different

and that would mean.....

 

[Hallatia]

that Faleti would be eligable

 

[Pistol]

that Faleti would be eligable

took you a while to get the point across