Most overated players

[Le Rouge]

Top Five are

1. Matt Gidley
2. Brett Kimmoreley
3. Phil Bailey
4. Danny Buderus
5. Steve Simpson

 

[dannyboy]

Who doesn't like the Knights or Sharks then....your selection looks a tad bias

 

[Kaz]

Who doesn't like the Knights or Sharks then....your selection looks a tad bias

I like the sharks.

 

[Moffo]

1. Trent Barrett
2. Mat Gidley
3. Brent Tate
4. Phil Bailey
5. Nathan Blacklock

Cheers,
Moffo

 

[Bring it home Knights]

1. Anasta
2. Tallis
3. Johns Morris [when it comes to knights supporters]
4. Berrigan
5. Kearns

 

[paulquinn49]

Tahu
M Gidley
Marshall (Tigers fans have pretty much put him in the hall of fame)
Peachey
Fletcher

 

[Le Rouge]

no bias to the knights or sharks its just that they are the most overated players i think

 

[Twizzle]

My........isn't Gidley popular, I presume we mean Matt.

I also agree with Phil Bailey.....I don't know how he got the SOO gig let alone a Kangaroo jumper.

 

[Phillips]

1- Trent Barret
2- Robbie Kearns
3- Steve Price
4- Brett Kimmorley
5- Craig Gower
6- Josh Perry
7- Brett Finch
8- Jason Stevens
9- Willie Mason
10- Gordon Tallis

 

[Renowned League Expert]

(no order)

Phil Bailey
Andrew Johns
Jason Stevens
Steve Simpson
Joel Clinton

 

[Canterbury]

1- Trent Barret
2- Robbie Kearns
3- Steve Price
4- Brett Kimmorley
5- Craig Gower
6- Josh Perry
7- Brett Finch
8- Jason Stevens
9- Willie Mason
10- Gordon Tallis

price is not overrated.

he was one of the best forwards this year and has been rated that by all parts of the media - and most fans.

its funny when people do these.. no one can except players from the team that they support as being over-rated.

i'll accept willie and to a lesser degree anasta.. but are you willing to accept your players :roll:

 

[Kasper]

1.Gidley
2.Minichello
3.Finch
4.Hodgson
5.Devere

 

[**DrAgOnS_gUrL**]

1. Trent Barrett
2. Mat Gidley
3. Brent Tate
4. Phil Bailey
5. Nathan Blacklock

Cheers,
Moffo

Blacklock....r u kidding?? I can understand Trent Barrett but not Blacklock.

I reckon most overrated is Phil Bailey

 

[Bring it home Knights]

1. Anasta
2. Tallis
3. Johns Morris [when it comes to knights supporters]
4. Berrigan
5. Kearns

I can't believe I forgot finch, he is one of the most overated in the comp. Stevens is very overated also.

 

[mullet]

phil bailey selection in soo was fair but oz no way and this is comming from a sharks fan.

trent barret # 1 hands down no body else can win and finch closely behind

 

[imasharkie]

How the hell Ricketson gets picked in national teams I'll never know...OVERRATED

 

[Matt23]

Adrian Morley
Brett Kimmorley
Brett Finch
Braith Anasta
Willie Mason
Phil Bailey
Shannon Hegarty

 

[Bobby DIGital]

Ryles
Barrett
Lance Thompson
Fittler- YES I said it. He aint the greatest ever.
Ricketson
Finch
Hegarty
Anasta
Kearns
MASON (NUMERO UNO)
Chris Walker - Actually the entire Roosters backline apart from Mini
Toopi
Tate
Phil Bailey

And any player that gets selected for rep footy because they are Gus or Ando's pet's.

 

[PARRA_FAN]

(no order)

Phil Bailey
Andrew Johns
Jason Stevens
Steve Simpson
Joel Clinton

Joel Clinton???? :? wtf

You obviously didnt watch the Grand Final or the Semi Finals that Penrith played in.

Or even the whole year.

 

[Matt23]

I think he remembers the grand final alright, thats probably why Joel Clinton is on the list