Moylan, Maloney or Cronk?

[shaggs]

So has anyone picked up the twitter story - Maloney demands $1m for last 6 months at Sharks?

Got a link??

 

[Card Shark]

If Moylan is carrying on like this at 1 club, I don't want him at my club.

It'll end up repeating itself.

 

[M2D2]

You guys are still delusional. This place hasn't changed.

Good chat though. Don't let facts and the truth get in the way of a decent Slothfield fantasy.

Up Up Cronulla.

Dont let the truth and facts get in the way of a gus smokescreen.

 

[Eion]

A rabble where your star player and captain doesn't want to play for you in a sudden death semi. a toxic culture where gus calls the shots through his puppet of a coach. Massive underachievement on the paddock with a junior nursery at your disposal second to none.

But it's all ok, you can name your ground apparently.

 

[bluefox1968]

Got a link??

Nah - had another look - just another media beat-up - Liam Cox...

 

[Luke Bowden]

Dont let the truth and facts get in the way of a gus smokescreen.

If you say so.

 

[Luke Bowden]

A rabble where your star player and captain doesn't want to play for you in a sudden death semi. a toxic culture where gus calls the shots through his puppet of a coach. Massive underachievement on the paddock with a junior nursery at your disposal second to none.

But it's all ok, you can name your ground apparently.

Rich coming from a Cronulla fan.

- The Moylan story has been misrepresented by the media.

- You are assuming that Hook is a puppet, because you like the sound of it. He was brought to the club because he is particularly good at bringing young players through to 1st grade. He is doing what he is paid too.

-You say that they have "Massively underachieved", I say that they are the youngest, most inexperienced team in the comp, yet, they made the finals. The only reason that they were comp favourites at the start of the year, was punters, with no idea, put money on them.

- We have a crazy good junior nursery and pretty much our squad signed for the next 3 years.

-The club is making so much money that they can afford to sponsor a stadium.

Yeah, real basket case.

 

[Surely]

Rich coming from a Cronulla fan.

- The Moylan story has been misrepresented by the media.

- You are assuming that Hook is a puppet, because you like the sound of it. He was brought to the club because he is particularly good at bringing young players through to 1st grade. He is doing what he is paid too.

-You say that they have "Massively underachieved", I say that they are the youngest, most inexperienced team in the comp, yet, they made the finals. The only reason that they were comp favourites at the start of the year, was punters, with no idea, put money on them.

- We have a crazy good junior nursery and pretty much our squad signed for the next 3 years.

-The club is making so much money that they can afford to sponsor a stadium.

Yeah, real basket case.

I agree ,you have a damn good team and a pretty solid foundation for the future.

 

[Surely]

If you replace Maloney with Moylan, you are upgrading defence, attacking running, ball playing and off the cuff creativity.

You are giving up a kicking game, goal kicking and an influential player.
I am not sure on where I stand.

Moylan is 27, Maloney 31 so a few more years in Moylan.
He hasn't really dominated the NRL. Shocking Fullback, had a game with 20 runs for 114 meters.
Would have to be in the 6.

Would I be disappointed? No. I think it's a sideways move, it doesn't improve us, but it doesn't really hurt us.
We would have to spend money on a goal kicking, and kicking coach.

Dunno. I am on the fence.

Holmes kicks goals alright.

I think Moylan for Maloney would be a downgrade though.

 

[Eion]

Rich coming from a Cronulla fan.

- The Moylan story has been misrepresented by the media.

- You are assuming that Hook is a puppet, because you like the sound of it. He was brought to the club because he is particularly good at bringing young players through to 1st grade. He is doing what he is paid too.

-You say that they have "Massively underachieved", I say that they are the youngest, most inexperienced team in the comp, yet, they made the finals. The only reason that they were comp favourites at the start of the year, was punters, with no idea, put money on them.

- We have a crazy good junior nursery and pretty much our squad signed for the next 3 years.

-The club is making so much money that they can afford to sponsor a stadium.

Yeah, real basket case.

Get rid of gus and you will be alright.

Or don't, and have an ego running unchecked and a coach that is undermined. Doesn't matter how good your juniors are if they sit on the sidelines and sulk.

 

[++ Gregos v.4]

If Moylan is carrying on like this at 1 club, I don't want him at my club.

It'll end up repeating itself.

How is he carrying on? Jesus, did he run over your dog or something.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Get rid of gus and you will be alright.

Or don't, and have an ego running unchecked and a coach that is undermined. Doesn't matter how good your juniors are if they sit on the sidelines and sulk.

That's one player.

Shit happens at every cub, that's what happens when you pay Young blokes, big money and treat them like royalty.

Moylan got a bit ahead of himself and has had a reality check.

I'd rather that, then produce another Todd Carney.

 

[++ Gregos v.4]

That's one player.

Shit happens at every cub, that's what happens when you pay Young blokes, big money and treat them like royalty.

Moylan got a bit ahead of himself and has had a reality check.

I'd rather that, then produce another Todd Carney.

Play the ball not the man, mate. You have been posting well. You know very well we didn't create the Carney mess.

 

[Eion]

Play the ball not the man, mate. You have been posting well. You know very well we didn't create the Carney mess.

That's right, unlike say Cartwright.

 

[++ Gregos v.4]

That's right, unlike say Cartwright.

How did they create Cartwright?

 

[Luke Bowden]

Play the ball not the man, mate. You have been posting well. You know very well we didn't create the Carney mess.

I'm not suggesting Cronulla created Carney!! The Raiders can take most of that credit. My point is, he carried on like a spoilt child and was never pulled into line. By the time he got to the sharks, the damage was done.

I don't want to see Moylan head down the same path.

 

[Luke Bowden]

That's right, unlike say Cartwright.

Please explain how the Panthers created Cartwright? How does his relationship with his ex-missus (may she rest in peace) relate to a footy club?

 

[M2D2]

Please explain how the Panthers created Cartwright? How does his relationship with his ex-missus (may she rest in peace) relate to a footy club?

Going to play off the 'fixer' your club hired with that situation?
f**k off to your own forum sycophant.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Going to play off the 'fixer' your club hired with that situation?
f**k off to your own forum sycophant.

The club hired no one, stop making shit up.

Bryce took matters into his own hands and asked a very old family friend to help out. He hasn't had anything to do with Panthers since the mid nineties.

 

[M2D2]