Musical Judge and Jury

[SP]

havent heard it

but for Last Kiss... not guilty

 

[j_tig]

on the last two i have to say not guilty, due to insufficient evidence
i dont know them

 

[greentooth]

Limp Bizkit's cover of Behind blue eyes originally done by The Who. I bet a lot of younger folks didn't even know it was a cover.

 

[SP]

although i never have liked any of the band's stuff, but i like Limp Bizkit's version of Behind Blue Eyes, so im going to say not guilty

(i have heard the original aswell)

 

[brook]

I haven't heard it but Guilty - because anything durst does is evil so this would be no exception

 

[j_tig]

not guilty, i havent heard the original but i like this song

spiderbaits black betty
not guilty

 

[dimitri]

NOT GUILTY

COSIMA HAS DONE A GREAT JOB

 

[poojar]

Last kiss = not guilty, That makes 4

Behind Blue Eyes = not guilty, both versions are crap, that makes 3 Innocent and 1 guilty

 

[brook]

spiderbaits black betty
not guilty

not guilty - love the origional but its a good cover

 

[frank]

This is the thread where 'musicians' are put on trial for murdering songs made famous by more illustrious artists that have gone before them.

All that is required is the verdict of seven jurors - the first seven to reply to each trial - and a majority verdict will suffice.

Anybody can join in but please do not start a new trial until the current one has concluded. Once four 'guilties' or 'not-guilties' have been recorded, jump straight in.

The first trial, your honour.....

COSIMA DE VITO, you have been charged of murdering 'When The War Is Over', originally sung by COLD CHISEL

What is the verdict of the jury?

That song was brutally murdered by John Farnham long before Cosima got hold of it.
You can't kill that which is already dead, therefore not guilty.

 

[Matt23]

John Farnham, eh
John Farnham for his piss poor cover of Help.