my list

[strider]

I actually found this an interesting exercise ... everyone bitches and moans about players and other people's opinion of players - but if you sit down and think about what players bring to the table, it makes you think a bit more.

 

[mickdo]

do ur list and rate him higher then. go for it!

Done

1 Hayne
2 Hindy
3 Fui Fui
4 Mateo
5 Mortimer
6 Cayless
7 Reddy
8 Grothe
9 Kris Keating
10 Kingston
11 Inu
12 Burt
13 Gulavao
14 Robson
15 Mannah
16 Matt Keating
17. Ben Smith
18. Wright
19 Lowrie

 

[Parra Guru]

Just another perspective....

In looks:

1 - Grothe
2 - Hindy
3 - Brod Wright
4 - Hayne
5 - Mateo
6 - Kinga
7 - Ben Smith
8 - Inu
9 - Caylo
10 - D-Morts
11 - Lowrie
12 - Mannah
13 - Moimoi
14 - Burty
15 - Joe G
16 - Matt Keating
17 - Robson
18 - Reddy
19 - Kris Keating

:lol:

 

[JessEel]

PG!!!! Burty at #14?? :shock: DMORTS AT #10!!


[-(

 

[Ron Jeremy]

1 Hayne
2 Hindy
3 Fui Fui
4 Mateo
5 Mortimer
6 Reddy
7 KK
8 Grothe
9 Cayless
10 Kingston
11 Inu
12 Gulavao
13 Burt
14 Mannah
15 Matt Keating
16 Ben Smith
17. Robson
18. Wright
19 Lowrie

 

[Ron Jeremy]

actually, i should swap Mannah and Burt around, Mannah has great potential imo.

 

[Parra Guru]

PG!!!! Burty at #14?? :shock: DMORTS AT #10!!


[-(

You know I'm a forward's girl :lol:

 

[Avenger]

1. Rob Jeffson

that is all

PJ, I must admit your sig makes me laugh everytime I see it. :lol:

 

[Hollywood Jesus]

1 - Hindmarsh
2 - Reddy (very close 2nd)
3 - Fui
4 - Caylo
5 - Morts
6 - KK
7 - Burt
8 - Grothe
9 - HaHa
10 - Kingston
11 - Joey G
12 - Mannah
13 - Mateo
14 - Brod
15 - Lowrie
16 - Ben Smith
17 - MK
18 - Robson
19 - Inu

Based purely on form.

 

[Bigfella]

1 Hayne
2 Hindy
3 Fui Fui
4 Mateo
5 Mortimer
6 Reddy
7 KK
8 Grothe
9 Cayless
10 Kingston
11 Inu
12 Gulavao
13 Burt
14 Mannah
15 Matt Keating
16 Ben Smith
17. Robson
18. Wright
19 Lowrie

And what about your list based on their ability Ron? :lol:

 

[Bigfella]

1 - Hindmarsh
2 - Reddy (very close 2nd)
3 - Fui
4 - Caylo
5 - Morts
6 - KK
7 - Burt
8 - Grothe
9 - HaHa
10 - Kingston
11 - Joey G
12 - Mannah
13 - Mateo
14 - Brod
15 - Lowrie
16 - Ben Smith
17 - MK
18 - Robson
19 - Inu

Based purely on form.

Ignoring the other ridiculous aspect of this list, which I refuse to dignify with a response, does Kris Keating come in 7 places ahead of Mateo based on their comparable form while sitting on the sidelines for several months, or prior to being injured when KK had started about 3 games and lost every one?

And Grothe's 15 plus hit ups and 100 metres plus a game all season puts him two below Kris Keating on form? Was it the sausage rolls and cokes KK has been consuming in the stamds that tipped him that high on current form?

 

[mickdo]

9 - HaHa

Based purely on form.

:lol::lol::lol:

Why not just put him at the bottom of the list and be done with it? ;-)

 

[Bigfella]

1. Hindmarsh
2. Hayne
3. Mateo
4. Moi Moi
5. Reddy
6. Grothe
7. Cayless
8. Mortimer
9. Burt
10. Kingston
11. Gulavao
12. Mannah
13. Robson
14 Matt K
15. Kris K
16 Lowrie
17. Inu
18. Smith B
19 Wright

 

[hineyrulz]

Can't believe he put HAHA so high up the list :lol: He is starting to come around ;-)

 

[Suitman]

1. Hindmarsh
2. Hayne
3. Mateo
4. Moi Moi
5. Reddy
6. Grothe
7. Cayless
8. Mortimer
9. Burt
10. Kingston
11. Gulavao
12. Mannah
13. Robson
14 Matt K
15. Kris K
16 Lowrie
17. Inu
18. Smith B
19 Wright

I'd swap KK and Robson, otherwise, that's pretty good.

Suity

 

[lingard]

I was just sitting here and for some reason wanted to make a list of our current players in order of who I think is best to less-best (how politically correct am I? ;-)) at this very point in time, just to the sake of it .... so i thought i'd post the list just to start some sh*t fights and make people go all :crazy: ... gotta love making lists hey

1 - hayne
2 - hindy
3 - fui
4 - mateo
5 - reddy
6 - grothe
7 - caylo
8 - burt
9 - KK
10 - mortimer
11 - kingston
12 - joey g
13 - mannah
14 - matt keating
15 - inu
16 - ben smith
17 - brod wright
18 - robson
19 - lowrie


now i'm not saying the guys at the bottom are sh*t, just that I think they are kinda less important at this point in time ... fact is I think the last 4 guys on my list are actually very important role players for us at the moment, not afraid to do the hard work instead of being glory boys

I`d rate Mortimer lower: next year he might be second or third, but not yet. I`d rate Matt Keating higher, Robson higher, Fui lower - and I`d rate Reddy third, Burt fourth.

 

[caylo]

On form and importance to our team and I have to take into account past peformances esp for those who are injured

1 Hayne
2 Hindmarsh
3 Cayless
4 Fuifui
5 Mateo
6 Reddy
7 Grothe
8 Burt
9 Inu
10 MK
11 KK
12 Mortimer
13 Kingston
14 Joey. G
15 Robson
16 Mannah
17 Lowrie
18 Smith
19 Wright

 

[caylo]

Can't believe he put HAHA so high up the list :lol: He is starting to come around ;-)

I cant believe he actually made the list

 

[Hollywood Jesus]

does Kris Keating come in 7 places ahead of Mateo based on their comparable form while sitting on the sidelines for several months, or prior to being injured when KK had started about 3 games and lost every one?

That's a very fair call and one I thought about myself before posting. I think it's just that, personally, I saw KK as having a bit of spark wheres Mateo was looking somewhat lacklustre and not really up to the standard we saw at stages last year.

 

[Angry_eel]

Just another perspective....

In looks:

1 - Grothe
2 - Hindy
3 - Brod Wright
4 - Hayne
5 - Mateo
6 - Kinga
7 - Ben Smith
8 - Inu
9 - Caylo
10 - D-Morts
11 - Lowrie
12 - Mannah
13 - Moimoi
14 - Burty
15 - Joe G
16 - Matt Keating
17 - Robson
18 - Reddy
19 - Kris Keating

:lol:

I don't rate guys but is Hindy really that good looking?