I can agree with you, but unfortunately it's not running from dummy half I said he is deficient, as you say he is good at that. But he has no ball playing skills and darting from dummy half isn't the same as competently steering the team through a set of six. I will accept he will never be Cam Smith not Nathan Brown who guided their teams attack without making long breaks nor big metres nor scoring many tries. The metres and the darts/tries scored are great extras, but Smith and Brown are the type of hookers who will play in top 4 teams and win GF's coz they allow the forwards to run/charge and offload all day by not leading them into a bashing set after set after set. Damian Cook was prefered to McInness at South's coz they saw the light so why can't we.
Fair argument. Sorry I misunderstood. .
I actually think it’s just another symptom of the same issue. Our halves are suffering from it too.
We have no shape. We have no structure. Good playmakers make good decisions about which player to hit. But they need options. We generally have 1 option of who is going to get the ball, too often there are no options and the playmaker is forced to run themselves. On the rare occasion that we have two options, the plays aren’t run enough to create doubt in the defence.
I’d like to see McInnes improve too, but I think he needs to also have players pushing up. As well as their forward options, Smith has Croft and Munster pushing up with him on either side of the ruck. And Cook has options from his forwards plus Walker who reads Cook’s game magnificently.
The best that McInnes ever has is two props running in tandem, or a forward running as a decoy with a half running an out line out the back. It’s just not enough to disrupt a modern defence.