What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Never to play origin again

hellteam

First Grade
Messages
6,536
put williams mistakes into perspective

2 drop balls - very ordinary but alot of others in nsw dropped 2/3

kick on first tackle - if you watch replay it was either that or go into touch

pass into wallace that went forward - ankle tapped at last minute

and great try which took alot of effort

Or just run infield and take the tackle....
 

hellteam

First Grade
Messages
6,536
We gotta take Tonearm Terrorists suggestions with a pinch of salt... he did start a thread about Hayne the 'myth'
 

saint-colesy

Juniors
Messages
2,110
I agree with some of your players but FMD, Poore?

He made solid meters, showed a bit of heart with that fight and worked his arse off all game.

Its not his fault we lost.

I'd say:
Farah
Wallace
Kite
Stewart
Lyon

Dont ever deserve to be picked again.
 

Knightmare

Coach
Messages
10,716
Having slept on it, this IMO has been the biggest problem with the NSW selectors these past few years: they are rushing too many 'green' players into the most influential positions on the field- the 1,6,7 and 9.

In these positions, at Origin level, you need players with considerable NRL experience under their belt. To throw a Mitch Pearce or a Peter Wallace in with so little experience and expect them to replicate the control of a Johns or a Langer is completely unfair.

Granted, occasionally you will get a player like Hayne or Inglis who plays to Origin standard the moment they take the field, but by and large younger players you put in the front row, in the centres or on the wing, where they have the more controlling, experienced players around them to guide them.

For the last few years, it concerns me the current NSW selectors have been too busy trying to find the halves of tomorrow, when perhaps they aren't ready to take that job today. Perhaps it would have been better to play guys like Kimmorley (despite his chequered Origin history) in there after all, guys who have played many seasons of 1st grade, guys who have been in several Origin camps and know how to handle it?
 
Messages
124
Having slept on it, this IMO has been the biggest problem with the NSW selectors these past few years: they are rushing too many 'green' players into the most influential positions on the field- the 1,6,7 and 9.

In these positions, at Origin level, you need players with considerable NRL experience under their belt. To throw a Mitch Pearce or a Peter Wallace in with so little experience and expect them to replicate the control of a Johns or a Langer is completely unfair.

Granted, occasionally you will get a player like Hayne or Inglis who plays to Origin standard the moment they take the field, but by and large younger players you put in the front row, in the centres or on the wing, where they have the more controlling, experienced players around them to guide them.

For the last few years, it concerns me the current NSW selectors have been too busy trying to find the halves of tomorrow, when perhaps they aren't ready to take that job today. Perhaps it would have been better to play guys like Kimmorley (despite his chequered Origin history) in there after all, guys who have played many seasons of 1st grade, guys who have been in several Origin camps and know how to handle it?

i agree 100%

In hindsight i have no doubt that noddy would have done a better job than wallace, I think from now on they should pick the best form players with the most experience,
 

Latest posts

Top