What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Non Footy Chat Thread II

strider

Post Whore
Messages
79,026
The lawyer acting for the government, Christopher Tan, told the court a short time ago that the Minister for Immigration will now consider whether to exercise his “personal power of cancellation” even though Judge Anthony Kelly overturned the Minister for Home Affairs’ decision to cancel the visa in the first place.
ie they f**ked up and made a mess of it all, and now they are considering throwing their toys out of the cot

 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,938
ie they f**ked up and made a mess of it all, and now they are considering throwing their toys out of the cot

It’s a conundrum for the Minister for Home Affairs now. Election around the corner. Will she make a strong borders decision or will she cave on the basis of compromise and allow the guy to remain because it’s just 3 weeks ?

The Feds will also consider the law of precedent. If they let this one go and not fight for their right to control borders, what happens with the next person who crosses the border without complying with rules?

I suspect that the judge felt that it was equitable to take the stance that “you emailed him and said his visa was approved. Let him play tennis FFS.” However there are deeper immigration and biosecurity issues at stake here.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
63,284
It’s a conundrum for the Minister for Home Affairs now. Election around the corner. Will she make a strong borders decision or will she cave on the basis of compromise and allow the guy to remain because it’s just 3 weeks ?

The Feds will also consider the law of precedent. If they let this one go and not fight for their right to control borders, what happens with the next person who crosses the border without complying with rules?

I suspect that the judge felt that it was equitable to take the stance that “you emailed him and said his visa was approved. Let him play tennis FFS.” However there are deeper immigration and biosecurity issues at stake here.

I doubt your general immigrant has the money or English skills to take this to court and fight their case.
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
79,026
I read that if they go down the path of just kicking him out "because", they will have to ban him from aust for 3 years ... unsure if true, but thatd be quite a big call
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,938
I doubt your general immigrant has the money or English skills to take this to court and fight their case.
Absolutely. It reinforces the notion that different laws apply to the rich. Your average backpacker on Border Security gets a kick up the arse and sent back on the next plane.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,938
I read that if they go down the path of just kicking him out "because", they will have to ban him from aust for 3 years ... unsure if true, but thatd be quite a big call
I don’t envy that bloke who doesn’t hold the hose.

The best scenario for Scotty now is to let the minister do her job and if it gets messy, make her resign.
 
Messages
11,976
I think the only Djoker in all this was the clown of a PM, who thought he'd get his Border Force to score some cheap popularity points for him.... but Scomo's vanity project has all backfired, and now taxpayers will have to foot the cost :mad:.

How anyone could ever vote for Smuggo "I don't hold a hose mate" Morrision or his party again after all the f**k-ups of the past three years, I simply do not understand.
 
Messages
42,876
Absolutely. It reinforces the notion that different laws apply to the rich. Your average backpacker on Border Security gets a kick up the arse and sent back on the next plane.
Well maybe we should rework the system so so that those who aren't being treated justly now, can in the future. Instead of treating everyone unjustly so the less well off don't arc up.
 

Latest posts

Top