What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

NRL 360 + other footy shows

Gazzamatta

Coach
Messages
15,694
I think people are being harsh on Vonny. And only because she is not Ben.
She was hired/chosen to be the host of the show, not to offer critical discussion and opinions. That is what the rest of the boofheads are supposed to do.
I think she has done well to keep the show flowing and let the blokes be the critical analyzers.
She has done her job admirably so far.

The programme was always going to change somewhat with a different host with a different personality at the helm. For those of you expecting it to stay the same with a Ben Ikin clone, well, you are all just as dumb as the "experts" on the show offering their "expert" opinions.
In your opinion. Mine, however, differs greatly but that's the thing about opinions. Dumb? Really?
 

Gary Gutful

Post Whore
Messages
53,133
I think people are being harsh on Vonny. And only because she is not Ben.
She was hired/chosen to be the host of the show, not to offer critical discussion and opinions. That is what the rest of the boofheads are supposed to do.
I think she has done well to keep the show flowing and let the blokes be the critical analyzers.
She has done her job admirably so far.

The programme was always going to change somewhat with a different host with a different personality at the helm. For those of you expecting it to stay the same with a Ben Ikin clone, well, you are all just as dumb as the "experts" on the show offering their "expert" opinions.
Agree with this. People expecting her to be opinionated are missing the point completely.
 

Suitman

Post Whore
Messages
56,091
In your opinion. Mine, however, differs greatly but that's the thing about opinions. Dumb? Really?

Yes.
What did you honestly expect?
The show to remain exactly the same?
It was always going to be different, but IMO, it isn't as different as some have suggested.
And to those that criticize her for her weight gain over the years, shame on you.
 

T.S Quint

Coach
Messages
14,702
I’ve never really been a big fan of Vonny. Not that I disliked her or anything, I just didn’t see why she was regarded as such a great League personality. She’s rather boring to me.

There really isn’t a lot of great on-air talent when it comes to footy commentary these days, either on Fox or Nine. The good ones are few and far between. So it seems strange to me when you have someone as great as Lara but she gets pushed to the side. Even Voss (who can be hard to take at times, but he certainly loves his footy and knows what he’s talking about) would have been a good panelist for the show. Better than Vonny, Hadley, Hooper or the other dipshits they get on there.

Even the ‘legends’ they put on there are hard to watch. Toovey can hardly get through a sentence without stammering and Carroll probably has CTE.
 

Suitman

Post Whore
Messages
56,091
I’ve never really been a big fan of Vonny. Not that I disliked her or anything, I just didn’t see why she was regarded as such a great League personality. She’s rather boring to me.

There really isn’t a lot of great on-air talent when it comes to footy commentary these days, either on Fox or Nine. The good ones are few and far between. So it seems strange to me when you have someone as great as Lara but she gets pushed to the side. Even Voss (who can be hard to take at times, but he certainly loves his footy and knows what he’s talking about) would have been a good panelist for the show. Better than Vonny, Hadley, Hooper or the other dipshits they get on there.

Even the ‘legends’ they put on there are hard to watch. Toovey can hardly get through a sentence without stammering and Carroll probably has CTE.

Agree with most of that.
Voss I like.
But we are talking about a host here and I don't think he would have suited the show. He has too much to say and that is not what the show is about.

The guy I thought would get the gig was Dan Ginane. I understand that not everyone likes him, but I think he was best suited to replace Ikin. He's a good presenter/host as well.
Anyhow, as I said, I think Vonny is going ok. She let's the show flow and let's the others do their thing, which Ben Ikin always did.
 

T.S Quint

Coach
Messages
14,702
Agree with most of that.
Voss I like.
But we are talking about a host here and I don't think he would have suited the show. He has too much to say and that is not what the show is about.

The guy I thought would get the gig was Dan Ginane. I understand that not everyone likes him, but I think he was best suited to replace Ikin. He's a good presenter/host as well.
Anyhow, as I said, I think Vonny is going ok. She let's the show flow and let's the others do their thing, which Ben Ikin always did.

What I liked about Ikin was that he brought the opinion of someone who had been there and done it - played first grade footy from a young age, played Origin and for Australia - whilst also understanding some of the stuff that happens in the background at clubs. He was a ‘host’ but also brought something else to the table.

Understandable it would have been hard to find someone to fill those shoes, with the experience he has. We all mention how few ex players there are who can give their opinions on tv without sounding like complete morons, so I’m glad they didn’t go with Anasta, Ennis or one of those blokes. I just don’t think Vonny brings anything to the table apart from bringing up the topics and throwing a laugh in now and again to ease the tension. She has only just begun in the role so there’s every chance she will become more interesting as time goes on, but I don’t imagine that will happen.

Not to worry though. I’m sure others are happy and I’m happy that they’re happy. Can’t please everyone.
 

Suitman

Post Whore
Messages
56,091
What I liked about Ikin was that he brought the opinion of someone who had been there and done it - played first grade footy from a young age, played Origin and for Australia - whilst also understanding some of the stuff that happens in the background at clubs. He was a ‘host’ but also brought something else to the table.

Understandable it would have been hard to find someone to fill those shoes, with the experience he has. We all mention how few ex players there are who can give their opinions on tv without sounding like complete morons, so I’m glad they didn’t go with Anasta, Ennis or one of those blokes. I just don’t think Vonny brings anything to the table apart from bringing up the topics and throwing a laugh in now and again to ease the tension. She has only just begun in the role so there’s every chance she will become more interesting as time goes on, but I don’t imagine that will happen.

Not to worry though. I’m sure others are happy and I’m happy that they’re happy. Can’t please everyone.

Yep, agree with all of that. It's impossible to always keep everyone happy. Vonny was never going to be an Ikin clone. She is what she is.
Also, I agree that Ikin was someone who had been there, done that. Also, he's a very intelligent and literate person, hence why he is now in the high position that he is. It was always going to be impossible to replace him like for like. Fox just don't have anyone similar. Channel 9 does though. Sterlo was the closest person who could have been an Ikin clone.

Anyway, we have what we have, and I will still continue to watch the show for the lol's of Kent, Hooper, Hadley and red face.
Von will just be the glue that keeps it together. I'm fine with that.
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
34,220
I think people are being harsh on Vonny. And only because she is not Ben.
She was hired/chosen to be the host of the show, not to offer critical discussion and opinions. That is what the rest of the boofheads are supposed to do.
I think she has done well to keep the show flowing and let the blokes be the critical analyzers.
She has done her job admirably so far.

The programme was always going to change somewhat with a different host with a different personality at the helm. For those of you expecting it to stay the same with a Ben Ikin clone, well, you are all just as dumb as the "experts" on the show offering their "expert" opinions.
100% agree. People are making out she is the reincarnation of Rebecca Wilson.
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
34,220
Screw vonny n ben .... they replaced Lara with that smarmy little merkin cronk ... f**k their eyes
He has been a terrible disappointment. Comes across as a tool with double standards. The other night he said that he couldn't play with someone like Paul Vaughn yet was happy to play in the Storm system with the greatest salary cap scandal in the history of the game and later with the sombrero at the Roosters.

#f**kwit
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
79,015
He has been a terrible disappointment. Comes across as a tool with double standards. The other night he said that he couldn't play with someone like Paul Vaughn yet was happy to play in the Storm system with the greatest salary cap scandal in the history of the game and later with the sombrero at the Roosters.

#f**kwit
Agree!

Of all the pricks that played for melbourne, i always had respect for cronk ... and thought he would be great on tv. But im pretty f**kin unimpressed tbh
 

Suitman

Post Whore
Messages
56,091
I think Cronk is ok. Say's what he thinks. We are not all here to agree with him,
Far better than those journalists on the show who pretend to know everything.
 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,273
I’ve never really been a big fan of Vonny. Not that I disliked her or anything, I just didn’t see why she was regarded as such a great League personality. She’s rather boring to me.

There really isn’t a lot of great on-air talent when it comes to footy commentary these days, either on Fox or Nine. The good ones are few and far between. So it seems strange to me when you have someone as great as Lara but she gets pushed to the side. Even Voss (who can be hard to take at times, but he certainly loves his footy and knows what he’s talking about) would have been a good panelist for the show. Better than Vonny, Hadley, Hooper or the other dipshits they get on there.

Even the ‘legends’ they put on there are hard to watch. Toovey can hardly get through a sentence without stammering and Carroll probably has CTE.
I love Vossy.

He can be up the nose for some people, but he knows the game, has a sense of humour, and is a great caller, imo
 

T.S Quint

Coach
Messages
14,702
I’ve made plenty of comments about blokes like Feleti Mateo and Dave Taylor turning into blimps.

I don’t feel so bad saying Vonny has put on some kilos as well.
 

Latest posts

Top