What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

NRL All Stars Stage 2 is Open

Sonic Star

Juniors
Messages
1,469
1. Billy Slater – Storm.
2. Josh Morris – Bulldogs.
3. Joel Monaghan – Raiders.
4. Israel Folau – Broncos.
5. Manu Vatuvei – Warriors.
6. Darren Lockyer – pre-selected player.
7. Benji Marshall – pre-selected player.
8. Adam Blair – pre-selected player.
9. Cameron Smith – pre-selected player.
10. Jason Ryles – Roosters.
11. Luke O’Donnell – Cowboys.
12. Anthony Watmough – Sea-Eagles.
13. Ashley Harrison – Titans.

14. Kurt Gidley – Knights (Utility 1)
15. Luke Lewis – Panthers (Utility 2)
16. Dave Taylor – Rabbitohs (edge forward)
17. Jeremy Smith – Dragons (tight forward 1)
18. Fuifui Moimoi – Eels (tight forward 2)
19. Trent Barrett – Sharks (inside back)
20. Chris Lawrence – Tigers (outside back)



Going by that criteria and list of players:
  • Pick a player from every team
  • Must have lockyer, Blair, Smith and Marshall
  • Bench criteria of two Tight Forwards, two Utilities, one Edge Forward, one Inside Back and one Outside Back
 

Sonic Star

Juniors
Messages
1,469
List of players you have to choose from and rules of selection:


The coach has divided the backs into three groups:

Fullback - Specialist role

Outside Back – Includes centres and wings
Inside Back – A player who can play five-eighth or halfback

Forwards are also divided into three categories:

Tight Forwards – A player who plays front-row and also second-row
Edge Forwards – A second-rower or lock that can play on both the right and left side edge of a team’s attack and defence.
Hooker – Specialist role

The coach wants at least three tight forwards in the starting line-up

The Coach’s remaining notes are:

Players marked as utility players have been designated on the basis of their ability to cover multiple positions.
The seven man bench will require:

- two Tight Forwards
- one Edge Forward
- one Inside Back
- one Outside Back
- two Utilities

Wayne Bennett’s nominated positions for the 64-shortlisted NRL All Stars contenders are:

Rabbitohs:
David Taylor (Edge Forward)
Issac Luke (Hooker)
Fetuli Talanoa (Outside Back)
Colin Best (Outside Back)


Broncos:
Corey Parker (Edge Forward)
Nick Kenny (Tight Forward)
Israel Folau (Outside Back)
Peter Wallace (Inside Back)

Bulldogs:
Michael Ennis (Hooker)
David Stagg (Edge Forward)
Josh Morris (Outside Back)
Luke Patten (Fullback)

Cowboys:
Luke O’Donnell (Edge Forward)
Antonio Kaufusi (Tight Forward)
Ashley Graham (Outside Back)
John Williams (Outside Back)

Eels:
Fuifui Moimoi (Tight Forward)
Nathan Hindmarsh (Edge Forward, Tight Forward)
Jarryd Hayne (Outside Back, Fullback)
Feleti Mateo (Inside Back, Utility)

Knights:
Ben Cross (Tight Forward)
Chris Houston (Edge Forward)
Kurt Gidley (Fullback, Utility)
Jarrod Mullen (Inside Back)

Warriors:
Micheal Luck (Edge Forward)
Sam Rapira (Tight Forward)
Manu Vatuvei (Outside Back)
Simon Mannering (Edge Forward)

Panthers:
Petero Civoniceva (Tight Forward)
Frank Pritchard (Edge Forward)
Michael Jennings (Outside Back)
Luke Lewis (Edge Forward. Utility)

Raiders:
Alan Tongue (Edge Forward, Utility)
David Shillington (Tight Forward)
Terry Campese (Inside Back)
Joel Monaghan (Outside Back)

Roosters:
Nate Myles (Tight Forward)
Jason Ryles (Tight Forward)
Anthony Minichiello (Fullback)
Mitchell Pearce (Inside Back)

Sea Eagles:
Anthony Watmough (Edge Forward)
Glenn Stewart (Edge Forward)
Michael Robertson (Outside Back)
Kieran Foran (Inside Back, Utility)

Sharks:
Anthony Tupou (Edge Forward)
Luke Douglas (Tight Forward)
Trent Barrett (Inside Back)
Luke Covell (Outside Back)

Storm:
Ryan Hoffman (Edge Forward)
Aiden Tolman (Tight Forward)
Billy Slater (Fullback)
Brett Finch (Inside Back)

Titans:
Anthony Laffranchi (Edge Forward)
Luke Bailey (Tight Forward)
Mat Rogers (Utility, Inside Back)
Ashley Harrison (Edge Forward)

Tigers:
Gareth Ellis (Edge Forward)
Robbie Farah (Hooker)
Chris Lawrence (Outside Back)
Tim Moltzen (Fullback, Utility)

Dragons:
Ben Creagh (Edge Forward)
Jeremy Smith (Tight Forward, Edge Forward)
Matt Cooper (Outside Back)
Darius Boyd (Outside Back, Fullback)
 

Crippler

Juniors
Messages
743
Slater
Vatuvei
Jennings
Morris
Falou
Lockyer
Marshall
Blair
Smith
MOi Moi
Ellis
Creagh
Watmough

I Luke
Gidley
Myles
Douglas
Tongue
Rogers
 

snickers007

Juniors
Messages
1,483
List of players you have to choose from and rules of selection:


The coach has divided the backs into three groups:

Fullback - Specialist role
Outside Back – Includes centres and wings
Inside Back – A player who can play five-eighth or halfback

Forwards are also divided into three categories:

Tight Forwards – A player who plays front-row and also second-row
Edge Forwards – A second-rower or lock that can play on both the right and left side edge of a team’s attack and defence.
Hooker – Specialist role

The coach wants at least three tight forwards in the starting line-up

The Coach’s remaining notes are:

Players marked as utility players have been designated on the basis of their ability to cover multiple positions.
The seven man bench will require:

- two Tight Forwards
- one Edge Forward
- one Inside Back
- one Outside Back
- two Utilities




So going by Bennetts instructions, there will only be 1 Hooker playing the game, and that is the automatic selection of Cam Smith.

So why then do we have these players nominated:
Issac Luke (Hooker)
Michael Ennis (Hooker)
Robbie Farah (Hooker)
 

gull10

Juniors
Messages
20
1. Jarryd Hayne - Parramatta Eels
2. Darius Boyd - Saint George Illawarra Dragons
3. Israel Folau - Brisbane Broncos
4. Michael Jennings - Penrith Panthers
5. Manu Vatuvei - New Zealand Warriors
6. Darren Lockyer
7. Benji Marshall
8. Aiden Tolman - Melbourne Storm
9. Cameron Smith
10. Adam Blair
11. Dave Taylor - South Sydney Rabbitohs
12. Ashley Harrison - Gold Coast Titans
13. Luke O'Donnell - North Queensland Cowboys
14. Anthony Tupou - Cronella Sutherland Sharks
15. Michael Ennis - Canterbery Bankstown Bulldogs
16. Anthony Watmough - Manly Warringah Sea Eagles
17. Jarred Mullen - Newcastle Knights
18. Tim Moltzen - West Tigers
19. Nate Myles - Sydney City Roosters
20. Dave Shillington - Canberra Raiders
 
Messages
14,232
Billy Slater
Israel Folau
Michael Jennings
Josh Morris
Manu Vatuvei
Darren Lockyer
Benji Marshall
Adam Blair
Cam Smith
Fuifui Moimoi
Ben Creagh
Gaz Ellis
Anthony Watmough

Nate Myles
Luke O'Donnell
Luke Douglas
Alan Tongue
Jarrod Mullen
Luke Bailey
Dave Taylor
 

Tiger_Tim

Juniors
Messages
472
So going by Bennetts instructions, there will only be 1 Hooker playing the game, and that is the automatic selection of Cam Smith.

So why then do we have these players nominated:
Issac Luke (Hooker)
Michael Ennis (Hooker)
Robbie Farah (Hooker)

Because we're the selectors, and we can choose to ignore Bennett if we so wish?
 

legend_ss

Juniors
Messages
84
1. Billy Slater (Storm)
2. Manu Vatuvei (Warriors)
3. Josh Morris (Bulldogs)
4. Matt Cooper (Dragons)
5. Israel Folau (Broncos)
6. Darren Lockyer
7. Benji Marshall
8. Adam Blair
9. Cameron Smith
10. Dave Taylor (Rabbitohs)
11. Gareth Ellis (Tigers)
12. Anthony Watmough (Sea Eagles)
13. Luke O'Donnell (Cowboys)

14. Jason Ryles (Roosters)
15. Luke Bailey (Titans)
16. Nathan Hindmarsh (Eels)
17. Trent Barrett (Sharks)
18. Michael Jennings (Panthers)
19. Kurt Gidley (Knights)
20. Alan Tongue (Raiders)
 

Big Time

Juniors
Messages
602
Parra is the hardest one. Although Hayne is currently rated as best player in NRL, I suspect Hindmarsh will get in due to his popularity amongst fans. I agree with Bennett on Matt Cooper, as a Dragons fan I would like to see him playing this game. Would also be good to see Mini get in for the Roosters. Everyone saying Ryles but he has not even played a game for them yet.
 

legend_ss

Juniors
Messages
84
Parra is the hardest one. Although Hayne is currently rated as best player in NRL, I suspect Hindmarsh will get in due to his popularity amongst fans. I agree with Bennett on Matt Cooper, as a Dragons fan I would like to see him playing this game. Would also be good to see Mini get in for the Roosters. Everyone saying Ryles but he has not even played a game for them yet.

its true what you say about Ryles but Mini is injury prone while Myles will give everyone the sh*ts.
 

leaguerules

Juniors
Messages
352
1. slater (storm)
2. falou (broncos)
3. Monaghan (raiders)
4. Lewis (panthers)
5. Vatuvai (warriors)
6. Lockyer
7. Marshall
8. Blair
9. Smith
10. Moi Moi (eels)
11. watmough (sea eagles)
12. Ellis (tigers)
13. stagg (bulldogs)
14. odonnell (cowboys)
15.Issac luke (rabbitohs)
16. j.smith (dragons)
17. j.ryles (roosters)
18.douglas (sharks)
19.laffranchi (titans)
20. gidley (knights)


 
Messages
17,822
1. Slater
2. Hayne
3. Folau
4. Jennings
5. Vatuvei
6. Lockyer
7. Marshall
8. Blair
9. Smith
10.Cross
11. J Smith
12. O'Donnell
13. Stagg

14. Campese
15. Luke
16. Bailey
17. Ellis
18. Minichello
19. Watmough
20. Barrett
 

Latest posts

Top