NRL.COM top 50 players

[Someguy]

http://m.nrl.com/top-50-players-in-the-nrl-10-1/tabid/10874/newsid/111927/default.aspx

Predictable and pretty difficult to argue the top 2 but Cronk at 3 is debatable and imo there is no way Radradra is not in the NRL's top 50 players

 

[carcharias]

Sam burgess is way to high

 

[MilkShark]

DCE in the top 10?

Okkkkkkkkk

 

[simmo05]

Credible list, Inglis played 5 minutes this year and is in the top 20.

 

[Vic Mackey]

been picked on reputation. paul gallen in the top 10 and shaun johnson number 15 is pretty laughable

 

[Mr Angry]

The full top 50 list
50. Nathan Cleary
49. Josh McGuire
48. Will Chambers
47. David Klemmer
46. Angus Crichton
45. Martin Taupau
44. Josh Dugan
43. Paul Vaughan
42. Valentine Holmes
41. Clint Gutherson
40. Corey Norman
39. Andrew McCullough
38. Josh Jackson
37. Aaron Woods
36. Dane Gagai
35. Simon Mannering
34. Josh Hodgson
33. Matt Moylan
32. Roger Tuivasa-Sheck
31. Jordan Rapana
30. Gareth Widdop
29. Josh Papalii
28. Tyson Frizell
27. Jesse Bromwich
26. Mitchell Pearce
25. Jake Friend
24. Tom Trbojevic
23. Cameron Munster
22. Anthony Milford
21. Wade Graham
20. James Graham
19. Jake Trbojevic
18. James Maloney
17. Michael Morgan
16. Boyd Cordner
15. Shaun Johnson
14. Greg Inglis
13. Matt Scott
12. Andrew Fifita
11. Matt Gillett
10. Sam Burgess
9. Paul Gallen
8. Daly Cherry-Evans
7. James Tedesco
6. Darius Boyd
5. Billy Slater
4. Jason Taumalolo
3. Cooper Cronk
2. Johnathan Thurston
1. Cameron Smith

 

[Incorrect]

Credible list, Inglis played 5 minutes this year and is in the top 20.

been picked on reputation. paul gallen in the top 10 and shaun johnson number 15 is pretty laughable

They have this disclaimer at the beginning of the article - "Once again, our list simply ranks the best players in the game – not the best players of the 2017 season."

I don't know WTF that is supposed to mean.... Presumably Peta Hiku could be on the list now that he is coming back to play for the Warriors.... if it's "not the best players of 2017" then how is Nathan Clearly at #50? He wasn't in the top 50 players in 2016.... So obviously it IS taking 2017 form in to account.... Stupid concept

 

[Tommy Smith]

Not to denegrate Cooper Cronk but you'd surely have to snort enough coke until your nose drops off to think that he's a better footy player than Taumalolo.

That's just typical 'spine favouritism'.

Cronk has engineered himself into a great halfback. Where as Lolo is a once in a generation genetic freak with gifts we've never seen before.

The likes of DCE and Gallen in the top 10 are also lolworthy. Both ahead of Surgess just to name 1? Give over.

Not to mention Milford at no.22 and the man who gave him one of the great baths on Friday in Luke Keary, who has also had a much better season, not even on the list.

But yes, these things are subjective and you'll never please everyone.

 

[veggiepatch1959]

Must have been compiled by a Queenslander.

Five of the Top 10 are Maroons while three of the other five are either ineligible or weren't picked.

Shocking list with Inglis at 14. Ha f**king ha. Nate Myles should be above him because at least he played one SOO.

If 2017 form is the yardstick for this list, Angus Crichton should be in Top 25.

 

[Vic Mackey]

36. Dane Gagai

Im assuming thats Queensland Dane Gagai as opposed to the one who trots out for Newcastle

I also cant imagine theres a single person in the world, apart from the person who wrote this article, who would prefer Shaun Johnson in their side over Michael Morgan

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Lol, paul gallen @ 9.

 

[Tommy Smith]

Aaron Woods higher than Klemmer.

JWH, Taukeiaho, de Belin and Nathan Brown not even listed.

The hilarity goes on and on.

 

[isaiah]

Must have been compiled by a Queenslander.

Five of the Top 10 are Maroons while three of the other five are either ineligible or weren't picked.

Shocking list with Inglis at 14. Ha f**king ha. Nate Myles should be above him because at least he played one SOO.

If 2017 form is the yardstick for this list, Angus Crichton should be in Top 25.

Have we won 10 of the last 11 series? Origin as the showpiece of the game deserves the weighting.

 

[Lemon Squash]

Dawwwwwwius number #6

Ohhhh my ribs!!!

 

[The Beaver]

Aaron Woods higher than Klemmer.

JWH, Taukeiaho, de Belin and Nathan Brown not even listed.

The hilarity goes on and on.

Sure does, Jake Friend at 25? Should be 125.

Cordner 16? 25-30 at best.

James Graham at 20? Is this the 2014 top 50?

 

[Tommy Smith]

Sure does, Jake Friend at 25? Should be 125.

Cordner 16? 25-30 at best.

James Graham at 20? Is this the 2014 top 50?

Yes yes, Pearce is overrated. Friend and Cordner are overrated. And they're our only 3 in the top 50.

And in your next sentence you'll accuse us of being over the cap because of how many stars we have.

 

[RazorRam0n]

mitchell moses top 10 with a bullet

 

[WaznTheGreat]

Worst list ever

 

[WaznTheGreat]

Correct top 50 list

1 Mitchell Moses
2-49 Lesbians
50 Jarryd Hayne

 

[Liddell]

Assuming this list was done before Gallen dropped the semi yesterday?

Also Jackson hasn't done anything of note since origin last year, not sure how he gets in there at all.