What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

NRLW

mozza91

Coach
Messages
16,216
Is she really going? Don't blame her to be honest. She can go on to win 10 Premierships in a row and leave the game as their first immortal. Can't do it from Newy.
Why? We’ve won 2 of the last 3 titles. Brisbane haven’t won it since its been properly competitive.
 

Yosh

Coach
Messages
12,788
Why? We’ve won 2 of the last 3 titles. Brisbane haven’t won it since its been properly competitive.
Yeah but by the looks of it we ain't going to be winning one anytime soon if Brisbane and Roosters get to keep buying up all the talent.
 

HarVeeGee

Juniors
Messages
858
I think this team is closer than they look, I know that Brisbane game was bad & got away from them, but if they can unearth a top 5 prop and get a bit more strike into the backline that would elevate the foundation of what’s there a lot. There are a lot of players in this team where you’re very happy if they’re about the 2nd/3rd best middle or outside back - everyone’s job gets way easier if the best middle is a Millie Boyle rather than Tiana Davison.

And Finau just had a debut game as a 19 year old where she switched from back row to centre 25 mins in - 114 metres, 7 tackle busts and a line break/try. She looks like that strike outside back we need. Should only get better and better.
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
29,842
I think we're comfortably team #3, on paper at least. That's where we will probably finish too if favourites win next week.

One thing we really need to do is go back to creating some plays though. I know the crash play is in vogue in NRLW where you have some gigantic props that can barge their way over, but we're overusing it.

Put some plays on, we've got the players.
 

Haffa

Guest
Messages
17,200
Missed the game yesterday. Looking at the stats Prop rotation was hilarious again. Tinao backed up her 18 minute 2 runs for 19m (9 Tackles) with a 12 minute stint of 1 run for 11m (7 Tackles). This week we were saved by Karpani coming on to make somewhat of an impact in her 20 minutes.
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
29,842
Lol yeah, that's why I wasn't stressing too much over some of the lost games even though they were disappointing. I saw the two teams directly above us still had to play Roosters and Broncos and thought yep we will probably still finish 3rd.
 

MakeItStop85

Juniors
Messages
114
Can you imagine the media uproar if the 2 golden teams don’t play in the GF or even worse…. an outsider actually wins it all! Unlikely, I know but would be hilarious if it happened!
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
29,842
Bit of an upset in the NRLW with the Broncos winning 50 - 4 against the 3rd placed Cowboys. Upset Cowboy fans anyway. Win our game tomorrow we finish 3rd.
 

PhilGould

Bench
Messages
3,547
Not great when a full-strength 2nd vs 3rd game a week before the finals looks like a training run, but doubt the NRL will care. Not like crowds are big enough to make a difference if they get even lower. Roosters & Broncos being dominant is probably legitimately best for business from their perspective.

More disappointing is the fact the Knights own mismanagment is what took us out of that conversation. The NRL didn't force them to replace Griffiths with a coach who put himself offside with the whole squad in his first season due to overworking the players. Didn't force the Knights into an untenable situation with Upton, nor force them to allow her to leave for nothing. Didn't force Johnston or Southwell to leave - both to teams in similar or worse situations, not the big dogs.

Put Upton & CJ back in the team and the Knights are probably still premiership favourites. They cost themselves that.
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
29,842
Not convinced it was anything we did that sent Upton packing. A lot of rumour around why she left but even back in 2023 in interviews she would regularly talk about missing QLD. And as far as I know we wouldn't have lost CJ if we knew were Upton was going to reneg. Is there anything more to that than hindsight? Only point I agree on there is letting her go for nothing in return.

The mismanagement point definitely rings true for the coaching though. We move Griffiths to NSW Cup coach seemingly against his wishes and first chance he gets he moves back to coaching to NRLW, just not with us.

Letting Hannah go was the right call.
 

HarVeeGee

Juniors
Messages
858
Didn't force the Knights into an untenable situation with Upton, nor force them to allow her to leave for nothing. Didn't force Johnston or Southwell to leave - both to teams in similar or worse situations, not the big dogs.

Put Upton & CJ back in the team and the Knights are probably still premiership favourites. They cost themselves that.
You wanna elaborate on that? (Bolded)

Also CJ has been a non-factor this year with the baby and all…
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
29,842
You wanna elaborate on that? (Bolded)

Also CJ has been a non-factor this year with the baby and all…
Something I haven't seen mentioned much is the Roosters are also missing the best prop in the game this year for the same reason, and will still possibly go through the whole year undefeated. Heh.
 

PhilGould

Bench
Messages
3,547
You wanna elaborate on that? (Bolded)

Also CJ has been a non-factor this year with the baby and all…
Upton requested a release from the Knights and the Knights granted it. Whether it was the official reason (family) or one of the rumoured reasons her staying at the Knights was evidently untenable. Wasn't the NRL forcing us to hand her over to the Broncos as was the point of my post.

Fair call on Johnston, more so talking about overall than this season specifically.
 

Seage

Juniors
Messages
1,162
How very dreadful. How very Knights.

Just too many players not good enough for this level who handbrake the ones that are.
 

MakeItStop85

Juniors
Messages
114
F*cking useless this team is!!

So much to play for and getting smashed at home by a team who aren’t even playing for finals.

This club has become an absolute embarrassment to the game and its region.
 

Latest posts

Top