NSW Robbed of victory by pathetic video ref

[KFC]

If anyone here can honestly tell me that Billy Slater was on side from Locker's kick I will go hopping to hell.

The video ref's decision was a disgrace.

Don't get me wrong it was a fabulous game but the officials involved had an influence on the out come.

And if Sean Hamstead is the leagues's best ref.

We are in serious trouble.

In conclusion, congratulations QLD I look forward to the decider.

 

[Red Bear]

They didnt go to the video ref in that try, they should have. Blame Hamstead.

 

[Johns Magic]

They didnt go to the video ref in that try, they should have. Blame Hamstead

I'm pretty sure they did

 

[Hurriflatch]

Yes, they did go to the video ref for that try

they didn't go to the video ref for the Carlaw try in which Slater potentially blocked a NSW player from making a tackle but I thought it was fine tho

 

[Red Bear]

I'm sure they didnt. H ejust walked over and pinted to the spot.

 

[thuganomics]

Which Try, the carlaw try or the Slater try?

 

[That Guy]

They did go to the video ref.

Billy was onside anyway.

 

[ibeme]

They went to the video ref, and zoomed right in. Too close to call for sure. Benefit of the doubt. The decision was correct (and I'm a blue).

 

[Moffo]

He was onside, honestly, go watch it again

At the very WORST, he was on the line. But there is no way they could've called him off

 

[I Bleed Green]

He was in line with Lockyer.

Benefit of the doubt.

It was a try.

 

[Godz Illa]

If anyone here can honestly tell me that Billy Slater was on side from Locker's kick I will go hopping to hell.

Get hopping. I, a Blues supporter, am quite satisfied that Slater was onside.

 

[Red Bear]

I thought you were talking about the Carlaw try. The carlaw try was bullshit, but the slater try was fine.

 

[Parra_Eels]

no it was onside

 

[pcpp]

Sigh.... whinging... and you blamed the few that were whinging after the golden point game.

QLD deserved to win.

 

[PARRA_FAN]

As a NSW fan I found nothing wrong with the Carlaw try, Tahu dropped the ball and Gidley took the wrong option. As for the Slater Im still not certain about it, I thought he was offside.

But you cant blame the loss on dodgy ref decisions.

Bring on Game 3 the decider.

 

[choc_soldier]

Yes, QLD deserved to win.

I need to have another look at the replay. For mine, he looked just slightly off-side, but it may have been the camera angle. I was blowing up at the time though.

 

[KFC]

I've replayed the video twice now and I still believe that Billy was a foot in front of Lockyer. IMO the video Ref got it wrong. But in saying that it doesn't matter a shit. QLD won. The series decider will be played in NSW. You couldn't write a better script.

 

[Red Bear]

Agreed Parra Fan, the decider will be great(good chance i will be their

 

[Raider_69]

ohhh please
slater was onside and if he wasnt it was only by marginal
benifit of the doubt IMO
and nothing, ABSOLUTLY nothing wrong with carlaws try

Some people...
:roll: :roll:

 

[gaterooze]

KFC are you on drugs? I'm a NSWelshman and I agreed with all the try calls 100%.

And I'm not sure what Gus is whinging about, there were a couple of 50/50 calls but they went both ways and none of them were major. I thought the ref did pretty well overall.