What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Off Season 2024/25

JJ

Immortal
Messages
32,812
Has any deal of that length ever worked well for the club?

Wonder who the other club with an offer is, full genius from the Knights imo... in all seriousness, probably the Roosters, but I seriously wonder if it could be the Warriors - have available space, he's a Kiwi etc... not sure how I'd feel about that - the big things with these are aging and injury - got to be successful in front end of the contract - presumably they're backloaded
 
Last edited:
Messages
10,118
Has any deal of that length ever worked well for the club?

Wonder who the other club with an offer is, full genius from the Knights imo... in all seriousness, probably the Roosters, but I seriously wonder if it could be the Warriors - have available space, he's a Kiwi etc... not sure how I'd feel about that - the big things with these are aging and injury - got to be successful in front end of the contract - presumably they're backloaded
Nearing the end of his deal now, can probably give the DCE one a pass mark, even though it hasn’t delivered a grand final. Taumalolo seemed to be a decent deal before Payten got there and started fiddling

If we use those 2 examples, DCE had a GF win, Clive Churchill Medal, Rep Footy etc on his resume, JT had a GF win, another GF run and. Dally M to his name. Brown has stuff all
 

JJ

Immortal
Messages
32,812
Nearing the end of his deal now, can probably give the DCE one a pass mark, even though it hasn’t delivered a grand final. Taumalolo seemed to be a decent deal before Payten got there and started fiddling

If we use those 2 examples, DCE had a GF win, Clive Churchill Medal, Rep Footy etc on his resume, JT had a GF win, another GF run and. Dally M to his name. Brown has stuff all
yeah, I was thinking should an NRL club be stupid enough to let me be CEO, who would I commit that money or time to - the only one I can think of tbh is Cleary, probably a little shorter and hoping he can age like DCE *which I reckon is a good bet as long as he retains the motivation to be smashed week in week out), but that'd be a win now pay later scenario. I guess with likely expansion etc top level halves (of course Brown looks strictly a 6 imo) are going to be rare - but even as a 6 he's behind quite a few without even thinking hard - Munster, Luai, Burton easily, Walker (prob both) and Mamm too, and then from there I guess people could debate but atm even veterans like Hunt and Brooks on short term deals are more appealing, and Hynes is really a 6 imo and a much more accomplished player - it's not a knock on Brown, he's obviously a talent, but Moses is the guy there, and it's a big gamble on potential compared to the likes of Luai
 
Last edited:
Messages
10,118
Sam Walker would potentially be one you could look at, could be worried about his size long term but he has some runs on the board at a very young age. Taking Cleary out of those deals at the moment you’d have to be gambling on potential from someone 22-25 years old

One of the standout failures I can remember was Terry Campese who had 1 amazing season so they gave him 5-6 years and he didn’t produce again
 
  • Like
Reactions: JJ

Latest posts

Top