Scapegoat claims foreshadow release of report into Essendon's supplements
Australian Broadcasting Corporation
Broadcast: 08/08/2013
Reporter: Louise Milligan
With rumour and denial surrounding the contents of the report in to the alleged use of illegal supplements by AFL team Essendon, a VFL player accuses authorities of having double standards.
Transcript
LEIGH SALES, PRESENTER: The biggest story in Australian sport continues to build as the Essendon Football Club waits to learn its fate in the performance enhancing supplement saga, and if so, what penalties it may attract.
There's speculation that individual players won't be punished, but that instead Essendon may be stripped of crucial points. That could cost it a place in the finals.
There's also mounting criticism of the anti-doping authority ASADA and its handling of the case.
Among other things, ASADA and the AFL are accused of letting high-flyers off the hook while penalising more junior athletes found guilty of minor offences.
Louise Milligan reports.
LOUISE MILLIGAN, REPORTER: Even on the soggiest of Melbourne winter nights, Matthew Clarke is training.
MATTHEW CLARKE, BANNED FOOTBALLER: Ever since my mum passed away, I kinda made a promise to her that I'd make it my goal again to make AFL and try me hardest, so that's what I'm doing at the moment. Hopefully I achieve it.
LOUISE MILLIGAN: Matthew Clarke's mother Jan died eight weeks ago. Jan Clarke was on the sidelines each week as her son blossomed from a footy-mad five-year-old to a plucky rover for local VFL side, the Frankston Dolphins. She was also there for Clarke when he was told in February this year that he was banned for two years for drinking an energy drink which turned out to contain a banned substance.
MATTHEW CLARKE: I was actually at work and I started crying. Like, I rang me mum and dad, just to let them know what happened. I told me boss I had to take the rest of the day off. I just came back and spoke to me parents and we just kinda weighed up my options from there, which wasn't much, really.
LOUISE MILLIGAN: Matthew Clarke's life changed after this game two years ago in the VFL, Victoria's second-tier competition. Clarke was in fine form.
Clarke drank an energy drink, Hemo-Rage, earlier that day in full knowledge that the Australian Sports Anti-Doping Authority would be testing him for banned substances after the match.
MATTHEW CLARKE: I actually - I didn't really think about it at all 'cause my teammates, I think there was about 15 of them, had been taking it the whole year, so I gave it a shot and it came back positive.
JASON CLARE, HOME AFFAIRS MINISTER (Feb. 7): The findings are shocking and they'll disgust Australian sports fans.
LOUISE MILLIGAN: The day after it was revealed that ASADA was investigating 12 Essendon players for possible drug cheating, Clarke was told he'd been banned for two years.
MATTHEW CLARKE: Felt to me like I was used as a bit of a scapegoat by the AFL just to kinda set the precedents.
LOUISE MILLIGAN: So Matthew Clarke is watching with great interest now that ASADA's report has been delivered. The report's igniting feverish discussion in Melbourne, a city that worships at the altar of football.
Only the AFL, ASADA, Essendon and coach James Hird's lawyers have the report. Twitter has been alight with speculation that Hird, a legendary player and Essendon's favourite son, might stand down, a rumour both he and the club deny.
JOURNALIST: Are you gonna be staying on or standing down?
JAMES HIRD, ESSENDON COACH: Ahh, staying on. Sorry, guys.
JOURNALIST: And how are you coping with the pressure?
JAMES HIRD: Good. Yeah, very well.
LOUISE MILLIGAN: But there have been strategic leaks suggesting that no players will be charged with infractions because there is insufficient evidence. But Essendon or its officials may be charged with the AFL with bringing the game into disrepute.
DAVID GALBALLY, LAWYER: If Essendon are going to be dealt with, we all know in the public what it is they're being dealt with for, what the evidence is that is against them and it's not to be dealt with behind closed doors.
GERARD WHATELEY, ABC SPORT: I don't think this report has any prospect of ever becoming public under ASADA's own legislation. The fact that its interim is a starting point. The fact that there are privacy provisions which govern all of this enshrined in legislation. The rights of the individuals are actually paramount.
LOUISE MILLIGAN: James Hird has always maintained that he insisted the supplements program be strictly legal, but concerns have been raised Essendon players were given substances on the World Anti-Doping Authority's banned list.
Three heads have already hit Essendon's chopping block over the injectables saga: CEO Ian Robson, chairman David Evans and high-performance manager Dean Robinson, AKA "The Weapon". Robinson complained bitterly of his sacking in a paid interview with Channel Seven.
DEAN ROBINSON, ESSENDON HIGH PERFORMANCE MANAGER: I've got no issue with James Hird being innocent until proven guilty, but what Essendon choose to do to one person, they should do to all. They should give natural justice. They say they should give natural justice to James Hird. Where was mine? What did I do, except follow his instructions?
LOUISE MILLIGAN: Now Robinson's lawyer is on the warpath. David Galbally QC wants to know why James Hird's solicitors have been granted access to the interim report, but his client hasn't been given that courtesy.
DAVID GALBALLY: I find it extraordinary that they receive a copy of the report and they know that Dean Robinson was the prime target right at the beginning, and they know that irrespective of what the findings are, irrespective of what the evidence is ... he's taken the full brunt of the criticism from day one and it's grossly unfair that he's not been given a copy of it.
LOUISE MILLIGAN: 7.30 understands that some Essendon players and their families are dismayed that they haven't been granted access to the interim report either. All eyes are now on the AFL and all it would say today was "Watch this space."
There's much speculation the Bombers could be grounded, stripped of their Premiership points and denied a place in next month's finals.
GERARD WHATELEY: It's possible that individuals from Essendon would be charged for their failure in duty of care towards their players and their failures on the issues of procedure and governance. ... All along the feeling has been there will be overall charges against Essendon. Precisely what they are, well that's the dispute.
MATTHEW CLARKE: When someone's sticking a needle in ya, you've gotta be pretty suss straightaway that there's something wrong it. Mine was only a powder that I mixed with water. They're actually puttin' needles in their arm.
LOUISE MILLIGAN: Matthew Clarke is amazed at what he suspects will be a double standard for the stars of Windy Hill's Bombers and a VFL rover paid $300 a week.
MATTHEW CLARKE: I guess it's disappointing to know that they would suspend me, like, a kid from Frankston who's playing VFL footy, and then a multimillion-dollar club like Essendon, are just gonna - like, pretty much just walk free.
LEIGH SALES: Louise MillIgan reporting.