What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Origin "farce" keeps Semi from NSW

Son of Minto

Bench
Messages
3,114
Phil Rothfield: Farcical Origin eligibility criteria to keep ‘Aussie’ Semi Radradra out of NSW jersey
Phil Rothfield
The Sunday Telegraph
April 13, 2014 12:00AM

RUGBY league’s State of Origin eligibility rules have been shown up yet again to be a complete farce.

This time the victim is the game’s most dynamic new personality player, Parramatta’s barnstorming winger Semi Radradra.

The NRL has ruled that the Fijian flyer can play for Australia - but, inexplicably, not State of Origin.

This is despite the fact four high profile Fijians have already played Origin football – the great Petero Civoniceva, Jarryd Hayne, Lote Tuqiri and Akuila Uate.

Under new guidelines for rep football, Radradra can nominate to play for Australia once he has lived in the country for three years.

Yet because he wasn’t born in NSW or QLD and didn’t live in either state before the age of 13, he can’t play State of Origin.

The NRL’s general manager of game development, Andrew Hill, insists there is no loophole that would allow the cult hero they call ‘Semi Trailor’ to play for NSW.

“Tightening up the eligibility rules was a move towards ensuring the state versus state, mate versus mate concept was protected,” Hill said.

“The commission was very keen to ensure the concept of the State of Origin remained as a game between NSW and Queensland.”

Yet this is the game that continually allows Macksville born, bred and raised Greg Inglis to play for QLD and any number of Kiwis and Pacific Islanders to play for the Blues or Maroons.

And the same game that sits back and allows superstars Sonny Bill Williams and Sam Burgess to walk out on the code because they are not allowed to play in the game’s showpiece event of the year.

Greg Inglis was born and raised in NSW. Source: News Limited
Radradra is the NRL’s leading try-scorer in 2014, proving virtually unstoppable on Parramatta’s left-side wing, turning the trampling of opponents into an art form.

He averages nearly 120 metres a game, has made 26 tackle busts in five games and brings back memories of legendry Eels winger Eric Grothe.

Radradra comes from the tiny Fijian village of Somosomo and has been in Australia for less than two years.

He was first spotted by the Eels’ recruitment team in a televised rugby union sevens tournament in Dubai.

At the moment he has nominated Fiji as his country of choice but can change at any time because his country is considered a second-tier rugby league

There is no question he is already explosive enough to handle the extra pace and intensity or Origin football, although his positional play understandably still needs some work.

The Origin snubbing has a two-fold effect on this excitement machine.

He loses the opportunity to earn an extra $90,000-a-year in match payments and also cash in on the marketing and sponsorship benefits that come from Origin exposure.

Radradra is under contract to Parramatta until the end of next season but it hasn’t stopped Japanese rugby clubs and rival NRL talent scouts from making enquiries.

http://m.foxsports.com.au/nrl/phil-...rss&utm_medium=twitter&utm_source=twitterfeed

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

This is such a poorly written and shitty article. Funny thing is NSW fans will lap it up. Hypocrisy thy name is Blues supporters.

Imagine the cry this red cheeked mong would be having if Semis first club was Brisbane and this was about Qld hahaha
 

ek999

First Grade
Messages
6,982
Lol it's Rothfield. Who cares.

I don't think any rational NSW fan will complain. He isn't from NSW so he shouldn't play Origin, simple as that
 

ek999

First Grade
Messages
6,982
Also I'm sure Rothfield doesn't realise that of the 4 players he mentioned 3 would still meet the current eligibility criteria and Lote would only just miss out
 

BennyV

Referee
Messages
27,577
OH SHUT UP ROTHFIELD, YOU ARE THE STAIN ON THE PANTS OF THE TEENAGED DWEEB THAT IS CRONULLA SHARKS WHEN THEY WATCH REAL TEAMS PLAY FOOTBALL.

Would be nice to have Semi play SOO but I won't lose any sleep over it, and I'm sure very few NSW supporters will. The rules were made to make sure players born and raised overseas can't play SOO, so all this proves is that they are working!

It pains me as a NSW fan that this one tosspot has stooped to the level of the Courier Fail and makes our whole state look bad.
 

Munky

Coach
Messages
14,545
And the same game that sits back and allows superstars Sonny Bill Williams and Sam Burgess to walk out on the code because they are not allowed to play in the game’s showpiece event of the year.

WTF? Surely if SBW and Burgess were to play Origin we should just change the concept to an all star series with each captain picking their team like in the school yead.
 

oikee

Juniors
Messages
1,973
Stupid NSW rugby league and their media muppets again bringing shame to the game.
I never read the story as dont read anything this shameful excuse of a new south wales born and bred and reporter writes about the game.
Semi is Fijian, not born or bred anywhere south.
Unlike Luke Kerry who's family and himself were born in Queensland.
The farce continues, rugby league reporting down south continues unabated.
No wonder crowds are now under 10 thousand and fans have walked away and stadiums lay vacant.

The end of days is near for NSW rugby league, the experience is like watching paint dry.
 

Vic Mackey

Referee
Messages
27,477
You won't hear a single nsw fan saying semi should play origin

But whatever keeps you going qld fans
 

timka4

Bench
Messages
2,505
I like the current rules, he doesnt apply simple. He wasn't brought up in aus so he shouldnt represent the states
 

hutch

First Grade
Messages
6,810
Also I'm sure Rothfield doesn't realise that of the 4 players he mentioned 3 would still meet the current eligibility criteria and Lote would only just miss out

How would lote miss out? He moved here as a young child.

It is a pathetic article, radradra could be the best thing to happen to FIJIAN rugby league, rothfield should be promoting that fact instead of making if all about origin. Absolute tool!
 

hutch

First Grade
Messages
6,810
Stupid NSW rugby league and their media muppets again bringing shame to the game.
I never read the story as dont read anything this shameful excuse of a new south wales born and bred and reporter writes about the game.
Semi is Fijian, not born or bred anywhere south.
Unlike Luke Kerry who's family and himself were born in Queensland.
The farce continues, rugby league reporting down south continues unabated.
No wonder crowds are now under 10 thousand and fans have walked away and stadiums lay vacant.

The end of days is near for NSW rugby league, the experience is like watching paint dry.

More trolling.
 

Swarzey

Bench
Messages
4,165
Garbage as usual. Nothing changes.

Bloke had a sook prior to the rules being changed saying that we they making the series a farce. However, he believes the new rules are a farce and should be making exceptions for guys like Semi, Keary, SBW and Burgess.

Joke.
 

Fazz_138

Juniors
Messages
165
The real farce is the word "Origin" being referred to in the same sentence at the Maroons and Blues. Rothfield is an absolute genius, but this is a new level of stupidity.
 
Messages
32
How would lote miss out? He moved here as a young child.

It is a pathetic article, radradra could be the best thing to happen to FIJIAN rugby league, rothfield should be promoting that fact instead of making if all about origin. Absolute tool!

Lote didn't move to Australia until he was 15 and since his dad didn't play State of Origin he wouldn't be eligible under the new rules.
 

Latest posts

Top