Our fowards 1-20

[roopy]

Our forwards as i rate them in order.

1/ Simpson
2/ Woolnough
3/ Perry
4/ Paterson
5/ Sargent
6/ Abraham
7/ Tolar
8/ Reynoldson
9/ Snowden
10/ Tuafua
11/ White
12/ Tanner
13/ Ling
14/ Laban
15/ Willie Tupou
16/ Lucas Miller
17/ Young
18/ Natusch
19/ Edwards
20/ Jon Tupou

 

[Medievalknight]

Our forwards as i rate them in order.

1/ Simpson
2/ Woolnough
3/ Perry
4/ Paterson
5/ Sargent
6/ Abraham
7/ Tolar
8/ Reynoldson
9/ Snowden
10/ Tuafua
11/ White
12/ Tanner
13/ Ling
14/ Laban
15/ Willie Tupou
16/ Lucas Miller
17/ Young
18/ Natusch
19/ Edwards
20/ Jon Tupou

Dont you rate Bedsy Roops????????????

 

[roopy]

Dont you rate Bedsy Roops????????????

left the hookers out deliberately.
they really are a different catagory.

Hookers

Bedsy

daylight

Terrence

daylight

Brown
young
Hunt
thurston

 

[Jono078]

Royal not even in the top 20?

Replace him with Tanner IMO.

 

[roopy]

Royal not even in the top 20?

Replace him with Tanner IMO.

Never rated him - barely a PL player

 

[keeney]

Totally, has feet for hands.

 

[Jono078]

Fair enough, although Tanner is probably still to high for my liking

 

[keeney]

Way too high, tits on a bull last night.

 

[macavity]

my top 10...

1/ Simpson
2/ Woolnough
3/ Paterson
4/ Abraham
5/ Reynoldson
6/ Sargent
7/ Tolar
8/ Perry
9/ Snowden
10/ Taufua

 

[macavity]

I still cant believe we let wooly go.

he is going to come back to bite us.

 

[perverse]

I still cant believe we let wooly go.

he is going to come back to bite us.

yeah i think he's the one major casualty from the cleanout thus far. the rest can go.. but it was a shame to lose wooly. what's impressed me the most is that he really put in against the roosters and got that excellent offload to win it for us.

far more of a clubman than newton was. i'm confident wooly will give us 100% full service until his last breath in the red and blue.

 

[Flange]

Snowden is big and strong, but too slow - move down the list
Tanner is ordinary - move down the list
Youngy, Timmy N & Johnny Toops - move above above Lucas Miller (yet to prove himself).

 

[dontmakemeangry]

Gets very skinny after Simpson, Paterson and Bederus imo. Although Mitchell Sargents comeback looked promising.

 

[roopy]

move above above Lucas Miller (yet to prove himself).

Lucas is number 16 with a bullet in my eyes.
I reckon he will give firstgrade an awful shove next season - and possibly be as successful as Pato.

 

[roopy]

Snowden is big and strong, but too slow -

I reckon Snowy looks a lot slower than he is because of his long striding run.
I'm not saying he is fast - but if you watch Matt White run at the line he will take 5 or 6 shortish steps and make 8 to 10 metres - while Snowy will take 3 or 4 giant strides and make 10 or 12 metres. Snowy looks like he is running in slow motion, but i reckon a frame by frame view would show him covering the same ground as other 110+ kg props.

 

[macavity]

Snowy looks like he is walking at all times.

he reminds me alot of Parso when Parso got cranky - and if he is as good I will be happy.