I personally don't feel comfortable singling out a Knights player (or even a former Knights player) as being our worst player over an entire season. IMO pointing out a player's flaws in a single game is a different matter as it's not over such an extended period of time.Oswin said:I must say I'm a bit disappointed with the thread - it's not often we have a free-for-all bash of our own players. Usually the idea is to bag out other players on other teams, not your own. :|
Gee you took it easy on Rudder!! What's wrong??? :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:Bring it home Knights said:Hughes was terrible. I always had the opinion that moodie should have been given a go over hughes.
Ryder was terrible, maddison was poor, Rudder was moved from 5/8 to the forwards. So he obviously wasn't doing a good job at 5/8. Fitlers big enough to be a forward. If they had injuries in the forwards would they put him there. No because they would loose much more with him being out of 5/8.
astrogirl said:I personally don't feel comfortable singling out a Knights player (or even a former Knights player) as being our worst player over an entire season. IMO pointing out a player's flaws in a single game is a different matter as it's not over such an extended period of time.Oswin said:I must say I'm a bit disappointed with the thread - it's not often we have a free-for-all bash of our own players. Usually the idea is to bag out other players on other teams, not your own. :|
Having said that, the way I see it roopy is trying to be a bit more balanced in his posts. By his own admission he does tend to be very complimentary and glowing in his praise of the players.
antonius said:Gee you took it easy on Rudder!! What's wrong??? :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:Bring it home Knights said:Hughes was terrible. I always had the opinion that moodie should have been given a go over hughes.
Ryder was terrible, maddison was poor, Rudder was moved from 5/8 to the forwards. So he obviously wasn't doing a good job at 5/8. Fitlers big enough to be a forward. If they had injuries in the forwards would they put him there. No because they would loose much more with him being out of 5/8.
Bring it home Knights said:antonius said:Gee you took it easy on Rudder!! What's wrong??? :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:Bring it home Knights said:Hughes was terrible. I always had the opinion that moodie should have been given a go over hughes.
Ryder was terrible, maddison was poor, Rudder was moved from 5/8 to the forwards. So he obviously wasn't doing a good job at 5/8. Fitlers big enough to be a forward. If they had injuries in the forwards would they put him there. No because they would loose much more with him being out of 5/8.
It's good to see you didn't bag maddison for the 100th time since he signed last year.
roopy said:I know the coach of Dora Creek under 8s (or their head coach of the juniors anyway). He once had the pleasure of playing in the same team as me - so it will take a good player to shift him.
I pinched the title of this thread from the cronulla section - they seem pretty keen to bag out the former captain of Hunter Sports High (and a guy who nearly didn't get his HSC because of a muck up day prank that involved him getting naked at one stage) - Greg Bird.
Sportsjock said:ANDREW JOHNS :shock: :lol:
Dmac said:Andrew Johns
antonius said:Sportsjock said:ANDREW JOHNS :shock: :lol:
Already been done SJ.
Dmac said:Andrew Johns
LOL. I think your right.Andy said:antonius said:Sportsjock said:ANDREW JOHNS :shock: :lol:
Already been done SJ.
Dmac said:Andrew Johns
Yeah but I have a feeling Dmac meant it! :lol: :lol: