Overall, who's the better QB -Brady or P Manning?

[Ice Ice Brady]

Another stupid reply :lol: At least your consistent.

What are your American football achievements that make you so much more of a genius than the rest of us?

i actually liked the post... and ice your making pats fans look dumb with some of that crap.....

While manning is a Brilliant player id always take Brady over him... and from watching the last 3 games he has been good and horrible at times....

Will be very interesting to see what the colts do with him in the winter

I'd argue that you're the one who is making Patriots fans to be dumb. It's one thing to have an opinion (that a lot of people share), it's another to have the literacy of a 10 year old.

But I don't represent Patriots fans. Nor do you. So your argument is a bit confusing.

 

[Big Tim]

I still consider manning to be the best QB in football at the moment.

 

[Ron Jeremy]

Again in a big game brady delivers, MVP almost certainly IMO

 

[andrew057]

A very good point was brought up on the Colts board today. Brady has improved every year and is a much better QB the last 4 seasons than he was when he won Superbowls. How many Superbowls has he won since being a MUCH better QB than he was? None! Instead he is out there throwing picks. Thats because its a team game. ***Matt Cassell***

If you want to choose ONE QB to lead your team in the playoffs and you have a great defence and a decent running game and great coaching then sure pick Brady or Montana. If you have a suspect defence that is prone to collapsing (like yesterday), if you have a poor running game and poor coaching, and you want a QB to lead you in the playoffs - you take Manning.

Matt Cassell is having a nice season wouldnt you say 18to87? Just a lazy 23 TD's with only 4 INT, leading the Chiefs to 8-4.

With regards to your second paragraph, lol.

Wonder how you and your fellow friends on the Colts message board are handling things at the moment, suicide watch?

 

[Big Tim]

Again in a big game brady delivers, MVP almost certainly IMO

If the Chargers somehow manage to get in the playoffs, Rivers is a lock.

 

[Ice Ice Brady]

I still consider manning to be the best QB in football at the moment.

You're entitled to your opinion and it is a legitimate one.

Again in a big game brady delivers, MVP almost certainly IMO

One of the best games I've seen the Patriots offence play.

Matt Cassell is having a nice season wouldnt you say 18to87? Just a lazy 23 TD's with only 4 INT, leading the Chiefs to 8-4.

With regards to your second paragraph, lol.

Wonder how you and your fellow friends on the Colts message board are handling things at the moment, suicide watch?

I love this talk about how its the system and defence that makes the Patriots so good. They are last or nearby in almost every yardage statistic for defence. Our turnover ratio is high because TB doesn't throw intercepts.

Our offence is made up of a guy who couldn't do it on another team with a decent QB, 2 running backs that no other team wanted, a short white receiver and 2 rookie TEs. Meanwhile, Peyton had Dallas Clark, Austin Collie, Pierre Garcon and Reggie Wayne.

If the Chargers somehow manage to get in the playoffs, Rivers is a lock.

I disagree that he is a lock but if the award is given to the player who makes the most valuable contribution its hard to dispute that without Rivers, the Chargers would be nothing.

 

[Big Tim]

Turns out that Brady is better....

 

[Ron Jeremy]

lol nice bump.

As much as i love Brady, I have to say Steve Young was the greatest QB i have ever seen. The guy had a gun of an arm, absolute precision with the throw, and he was top three best running QB's i have ever seen. I will always say that if he took over from Montana earlier then 93, he would have atleast 2 more rings. Steve young also has the all time highest QB rating apparently, not surprised.

 

[legend]

Very subjective question but Young and Montana both had an all star cast to throw to, including Jerry Rice. Both were still excellent QB's but Montana didn't fare as well once he went to the Chiefs did he?

Manning has four MVP's but only one SB ring. It depends what you judge greatness on, number of SB victories or number of league MVP's?

Rodgers may have something to contribute to the discussion when all is said and done.

 

[DC_fan]

The best qb I have seen play the game is Peyton Manning followed by Joe Montana.