What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Pacific Championships 2024

titoelcolombiano

First Grade
Messages
6,645
Fish didn't even know we have to play next week either, and he's our captain lol.
I'll give Stacey Jones the benefit of the doubt because he was missing heaps of first choice talent but I'm worried the Kiwis are going into a Kidwell 2.0 phase which would be a huge waste as their best lineup is probably the strongest the Kiwis have ever had.

Shit, now that Madge isn't NSW coach surely he can take them for the internationals once Broncos commitments are done for the year, it's only 3 games.
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
34,310
I'll give Stacey Jones the benefit of the doubt because he was missing heaps of first choice talent but I'm worried the Kiwis are going into a Kidwell 2.0 phase which would be a huge waste as their best lineup is probably the strongest the Kiwis have ever had.

Shit, now that Madge isn't NSW coach surely he can take them for the internationals once Broncos commitments are done for the year, it's only 3 games.
Stacey jones
Kearney
Steve price

lol
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
34,310
Didn’t realise the promotion relegation game was at the same stadium next week

As someone else said should’ve been Allianz commbank is too small for all those games
 

titoelcolombiano

First Grade
Messages
6,645
Didn’t realise the promotion relegation game was at the same stadium next week

As someone else said should’ve been Allianz commbank is too small for all those games
It's a good thing that we have the problem that the stadium is too small. We never thought we'd be having that discussion. Hopefully from now on as the moment builds Pacific Championship Finals are reserved for Suncorp, Allianz or Eden Park.

The good thing about the format for Finals day is that you have all three Pac Cup fan bases to sell tickets to.
 

League Unlimited News

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
8,703
Next Sunday at Commbank Stadium

11:35am PNG Orchids v Fetu Samoa
Womens Pacific Bowl Promotion Final

1:50pm Australian Jillaroos v NZ Kiwi Ferns
Womens Pacific Cup Final

4:05pm Australian Kangaroos v Tonga XIII
Mens Pacific Cup Final

6:20pm New Zealand Kiwis v PNG or Fiji
Mens Pacific Bowl Promotion Final
 

Coastbloke

Bench
Messages
4,170
Let’s see how the week goes in terms of ticket sales. Does anyone know how it’s tracking now?

Both Tongan games have been awesome, so it should sell out. But Sydney and IRL haven’t been mates for years…
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
34,310
Let’s see how the week goes in terms of ticket sales. Does anyone know how it’s tracking now?

Both Tongan games have been awesome, so it should sell out. But Sydney and IRL haven’t been mates for years…
Lower bowl looks sold out

Upper bowl sidelines look full

Just the corner bays have lots of seats left

Pax was 15k last night
 
Messages
12,712
I'll give Stacey Jones the benefit of the doubt because he was missing heaps of first choice talent but I'm worried the Kiwis are going into a Kidwell 2.0 phase which would be a huge waste as their best lineup is probably the strongest the Kiwis have ever had.

Shit, now that Madge isn't NSW coach surely he can take them for the internationals once Broncos commitments are done for the year, it's only 3 games.
Yeah, hopefully Stacey falls on his aword like Kidwell. He's clearly not up to it. His selections in certain positions were awful, and his bench rotation was not up to par.
 

Billythekid

First Grade
Messages
6,837
Another problem with this 3 team format is a matter of fairness in the finals. In the NRL finals we have people blowing up about how it’s completely unfair if a team gets 1 or 2 days extra rest. For this final because of how the draw went Australia got a whole week off extra to prepare for the final. It’s completely unfair on top of being a shit format.

I also don’t like the promotion relegation aspect of this setup and thinks it’s a mistake for the most part. Just pick the teams you want to be there.
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
34,310
Another problem with this 3 team format is a matter of fairness in the finals. In the NRL finals we have people blowing up about how it’s completely unfair if a team gets 1 or 2 days extra rest. For this final because of how the draw went Australia got a whole week off extra to prepare for the final. It’s completely unfair on top of being a shit format.

I also don’t like the promotion relegation aspect of this setup and thinks it’s a mistake for the most part. Just pick the teams you want to be there.
The week off might not be an advantage
 

Matt_CBY

Juniors
Messages
1,856
I also don’t like the promotion relegation aspect of this setup and thinks it’s a mistake for the most part. Just pick the teams you want to be there.
Disagree. Giving Fiji, PNG & Cook Islands and hopefully later other the chance to win their way to playing against the best countries in the world is a great point of difference for this competition.

Even if NZ or Tonga got relegated, those nations playing the Bowl against Fiji and PNG or whichever way it falls is still the pinnacle for NZ/Tonga and a great opportunity for the other nations.

If it was automatic relegation I’d be against it. I.e. bottom of Cup drops down and top of Bowl goes up but having the playoff game means nations have to earn their place.
 

mikail-eagle

Bench
Messages
3,039
If PNG start the same way they did against the Cook Islands then NZ will put the cleaners through them.

Without Justin Olam, Zac Laybutt, Alex Johnston, Edwin Ipape and so many new debutants this tournament, I think they were quite lucky to beat Fiji in the first game.
 

taste2taste

Juniors
Messages
2,495
Another problem with this 3 team format is a matter of fairness in the finals. In the NRL finals we have people blowing up about how it’s completely unfair if a team gets 1 or 2 days extra rest. For this final because of how the draw went Australia got a whole week off extra to prepare for the final. It’s completely unfair on top of being a shit format.

I also don’t like the promotion relegation aspect of this setup and thinks it’s a mistake for the most part. Just pick the teams you want to be there.
its definitely a flawed draw, aussies get the week off and Tonga have to back up after an 80min bash a thon.

aussies already have a huge advantage before a balls been kicked.
 

RedVee

First Grade
Messages
7,104
If PNG start the same way they did against the Cook Islands then NZ will put the cleaners through them.

Without Justin Olam, Zac Laybutt, Alex Johnston, Edwin Ipape and so many new debutants this tournament, I think they were quite lucky to beat Fiji in the first game.
Didn’t Laybutt play yesterday?
 

Matua

First Grade
Messages
5,167
Rather than write a new post I'll just copy and paste my post from the NZ section version of this thread. With obligatory congratulations to Tonga first since this is an all comers thread. :)

Two days later and I'm still pee-d off at this result. Rant incoming.

That was a pathetic display from selections down to the poor game management at the end.

I 100% do not buy into any claims we were the underdogs due to a weakened team. Even with a weakened team we should have won. The fact is we got to within 1 point after a first half where we shed 24 points and could barely complete a set without an error and then we should have put the game away before the Tongans got their drop goal.

It was rank stupidity to go into this series with a plan to play a fullback who had an average season as our starting 6, instead of a guy who genuinely had a good season at 6. Love Stacey as a player but getting Kidwell vibes from him as a coach.

The big names in our pack didn't fire a shot in the first half, then came right in the second, if they'd done it from the start we'd have won that.

We made Tui look like a competent half in that first 40, and fat Taumololo look like he was good again.

AFB was never going to pass that close to the line, why hang off him? They did it late in the game too, just hit him when he starts dancing around. TBF getting him to the ground is easier said than done but at least freaking try.

Why was Niukore playing and Riki sitting in the stands. Niukore living off a couple of good years rep, he was mostly mud this year when not injured.

The NZ crowd was pathetic. Turn up for the Warriors yet allow Tonga to take over the ground for test rugby.

Rant over (for now).

Good things. Loved the passion that Crossland showed playing for the Kiwis, he seems like another Foran who will give his all for us despite being raised in Oz. Neame has had great impact. Kini is a talent, a pity he was expected to play 1 and 6 at the same time.

Other things. I dislike Ka Mate so much prefer the Kiwis own haka.

I don't care about Origin from the point of view of players playing for Tonga. There's not many in that team I consider genuine players who really wanted to be Kiwis, Fat Taumalolo yep back in the day, but even a guy like AFB is tenuous, he only used us because he wasn't picked by Tonga. Our NZ Samoans have mostly stayed loyal too. But I think since we're getting beaten by supposed tier 2 teams then is should be opened up to NZers and Origin, therefore guys like Howarth and Ponga could play origin and NZ.

Was going to go to the game next week (Commbank is a great stadium) but my two mates have both said they're not keen after that display. So now, I'm not sure what I'll do. The ticket price would have been fine for two games, but I'll likely bugger off after the Kiwis match as I hate both those two teams playing the final.
 

RedVee

First Grade
Messages
7,104
Rather than write a new post I'll just copy and paste my post from the NZ section version of this thread. With obligatory congratulations to Tonga first since this is an all comers thread. :)

Two days later and I'm still pee-d off at this result. Rant incoming.

That was a pathetic display from selections down to the poor game management at the end.

I 100% do not buy into any claims we were the underdogs due to a weakened team. Even with a weakened team we should have won. The fact is we got to within 1 point after a first half where we shed 24 points and could barely complete a set without an error and then we should have put the game away before the Tongans got their drop goal.

It was rank stupidity to go into this series with a plan to play a fullback who had an average season as our starting 6, instead of a guy who genuinely had a good season at 6. Love Stacey as a player but getting Kidwell vibes from him as a coach.

The big names in our pack didn't fire a shot in the first half, then came right in the second, if they'd done it from the start we'd have won that.

We made Tui look like a competent half in that first 40, and fat Taumololo look like he was good again.

AFB was never going to pass that close to the line, why hang off him? They did it late in the game too, just hit him when he starts dancing around. TBF getting him to the ground is easier said than done but at least freaking try.

Why was Niukore playing and Riki sitting in the stands. Niukore living off a couple of good years rep, he was mostly mud this year when not injured.

The NZ crowd was pathetic. Turn up for the Warriors yet allow Tonga to take over the ground for test rugby.

Rant over (for now).

Good things. Loved the passion that Crossland showed playing for the Kiwis, he seems like another Foran who will give his all for us despite being raised in Oz. Neame has had great impact. Kini is a talent, a pity he was expected to play 1 and 6 at the same time.

Other things. I dislike Ka Mate so much prefer the Kiwis own haka.

I don't care about Origin from the point of view of players playing for Tonga. There's not many in that team I consider genuine players who really wanted to be Kiwis, Fat Taumalolo yep back in the day, but even a guy like AFB is tenuous, he only used us because he wasn't picked by Tonga. Our NZ Samoans have mostly stayed loyal too. But I think since we're getting beaten by supposed tier 2 teams then is should be opened up to NZers and Origin, therefore guys like Howarth and Ponga could play origin and NZ.

Was going to go to the game next week (Commbank is a great stadium) but my two mates have both said they're not keen after that display. So now, I'm not sure what I'll do. The ticket price would have been fine for two games, but I'll likely bugger off after the Kiwis match as I hate both those two teams playing the final.
The Final is the 4pm game.
 
Top