Mate, some of us on here can be rational and judge him on his current results. I personally don’t give a f**k what he did years ago at the Warriors or the Tigers.
Ivan has had good results over the years. Took a Warriors side and improved them substantially, including taking a tram that didn’t have any right to be close to a Premiership to the GF.
His first stop with us is nothing to right home about, but at the Tigers he had them playing quite well and the first coach to halt the slide and have them going in the right direction. Only have to look at the undisciplined team they have become following his tenure to see his many times the coach that Madge is. There is a reason that Wests fans hate him; because he offered them hope.
2019 was a transition year, but in 2020 he took a team many thought were terrible (BRL.com ranked the spine the worst in the comp, among many similar articles) and took us to the MP and GF. This year the team has backed that up and should beat the Eels today and play the Storm next week.
Ivan is a very good coach. I live in the UK so only see the Fox related material, but he gets talked down on their programming because he isn’t matey with the reporters in the Murdoch press (like Ricky is with Paul Kent, Wayne and Crawley and Badell, and Hook and Kevvie). But his record of taking squads that are not rated strongly and turning them around speaks for itself.