Pat Richards RETURNS

[westie]

Collis and Harrison are yet to prove they are able to handle the step-up to First Grade week-in - week-out.

As soon as they are given adequate game time,they will more than just handle it,they will become two of the games stars.Mark my words!

We all know they have potential but there is no way those two make the top 3 centers at the club.

 

[Mighty Tiger]

We all know they have potential but there is no way those two make the top 3 centers at the club.

So Do you finally admit Westie that Dene is a better center than Collis

 

[tiger78]

Halatau and Collis are different players, who knows maybe they will be centre partners in the future. Elford is by NO means a certain selection every week, although I am a fan of his. really no one is a certainty anymore except probably Prince and he would be feeling a little heat from Kerr so its all good. Why bother debating which is better? They are our players and will be judged by the coach on their merits.

 

[Vicious]

They are both very good.The only difference being Dene has been given more of a chance and proved his worth as a rising top class 1st grader for us all to see!

 

[BJ]

should be interesting to see how pat goes..
and if he comes back and picks up where he left off will be interesting to see how sheens plkays his cards in regards to who stays in the backline and who goes..
hodgson moodie and elford are all safe.. the last two positions are up for grabs i guess..
alot of our attack has been fairly one sided with alot of breaks from moodie and elfords side of the play.. when pat gets back oppurtunities a plus from both sides to score..

 

[Palms]

He has to be on the other wing for sure - Fitzhenry to go no questions asked!

 

[westie]

We all know they have potential but there is no way those two make the top 3 centers at the club.

So Do you finally admit Westie that Dene is a better center than Collis

I have always said that inform players should be selected over those with greater potential. I believe this is why you originally got shitty over my opinion that Greally was not ready for 1st grade over Hodgo.

 

[Mighty Tiger]

I have always said that inform players should be selected over those with greater potential. I believe this is why you originally got shitty over my opinion that Greally was not ready for 1st grade over Hodgo.

Prove it!!!!

I have not once said that Greally is ready for 1st grade, I have on numerous times stated that he isn't ready for first grade - yet again your Wrong

surprise!!! surprise!!! :roll:

 

[brook]

:lol: What westie is talking about is when he claimed that greally wasn't up to premier league

He has since tried to change what the argument was actually about to make it appear he actually might have had a clue what he was talking about

 

[Mighty Tiger]

:lol: What westie is talking about is when he claimed that greally wasn't up to premier league

He has since tried to change what the argument was actually about to make it appear he actually might have had a clue what he was talking about

Its not what he said thought and PL was never brought up - He mentioned 1st Grade and Hodgson - Yet again he is wrong :lol:

 

[brook]

no no no

at the begining of this year westie made one of his usual ignorant comments in which he claimed simon wasn't good enough for premier league.

He was attacked over this and ever since has tried to pretend that the argument was over if he should be in FIRST GRADE in order to make it seem like he had an actual point

 

[gr8_1]

Are you 3 related ?

 

[westie]

Are you 3 related ?

Thankfully not.

I said Greally was not ready for 1st grade as he was only beginning to crack PL (you will remember he wasn't exactly performing at the time). It isn't exactly the greatest step from JF to PL so I have no idea why you would think that any one would suggest he couldn't handle it. It's not exactly like Balmain have a gun fullback to keep him out either so I can't see any reason for a suggestion that there would be a reason not to have him there.

 

[Mighty Tiger]

Are you 3 related ?

Thankfully not.

I don't beleave it I finally agree with Westie for once :lol:

I said Greally was not ready for 1st grade as he was only beginning to crack PL (you will remember he wasn't exactly performing at the time). It isn't exactly the greatest step from JF to PL so I have no idea why you would think that any one would suggest he couldn't handle it. It's not exactly like Balmain have a gun fullback to keep him out either so I can't see any reason for a suggestion that there would be a reason not to have him there.

Westie he would be the 2nd best fullback for the Wests Tigers at the moment and that is why he actually does attend one of the training sessions with the top squad a week

 

[yappy]

BS he still has to get past the Duff man.

 

[Mighty Tiger]

BS he still has to get past the Duff man.

Well apperantly going by the conversation I had with Danny Munk he has been training with Hodgson and apperantly he was going to be selected if Hodgson did get the call up for SOO duties :?

At the moment I don't think he is ready for 1st grade yet and I would prefer him to be playing for Balmain a bit longer as his options sometimes baffell me but if what Danny said is true then well I think you could say he is :?

 

[westie]

Are you 3 related ?

Thankfully not.

I don't beleave it I finally agree with Westie for once :lol:

I said Greally was not ready for 1st grade as he was only beginning to crack PL (you will remember he wasn't exactly performing at the time). It isn't exactly the greatest step from JF to PL so I have no idea why you would think that any one would suggest he couldn't handle it. It's not exactly like Balmain have a gun fullback to keep him out either so I can't see any reason for a suggestion that there would be a reason not to have him there.

Westie he would be the 2nd best fullback for the Wests Tigers at the moment and that is why he actually does attend one of the training sessions with the top squad a week

When did I say he wasn't. BTW Duffy is currently a far more complete and safe fullback.

 

[magpiemax]

BS he still has to get past the Duff man.

Has the Duff come back to earth yet or is he still unconscious???? ;-)

 

[Magpie Nick]

Playing his first game back I think. Was named to play last week but didn't? He is playing off the bench.

 

[yappy]

Duff was injured, so we could both be right on that Mighty, but westie is 100%.