What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Phil Gould Clanger??

NK Arsenal

Juniors
Messages
1,861
Personally I think Hodges is the best centre in the NRL right now.
So do I.

But there is no doubting that Gasnier has talent.

And for those who don't think that Gus is good at spotting talent then how the hell did he manage to win 2 premierships and 7 State of Origin series ffs?
 

Dazzat

First Grade
Messages
5,919
I'd rate Hodges and Inglis as better centres at the moment. As far as centres that Gould would have "seen", I'd put Mike Cronin, Steve Rogers, Mal Meninga and Gene Miles all in front of Gasnier. I'd put Gasnier and Renouf in about the same class.
 

Johnny Bravo

Juniors
Messages
489
He's the best attacking center I've ever seen. Hodges, Meninga, Cronin etc etc all while being phenomenal players, there is no one in the game that can take it to the line and step a guy who is two inches in front of him like Gasnier can.

Being the best center ever is a joke though, the guy costs plenty of tries with his defence. He rushes out of the line all the time invariably creating an overlap and gifting a try.
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
I dont agree with it, i think i could probably name 5 centres better then him and i havnt been around nearly as long as gould but thats his opinion, so be it.
 

Ausguy

Coach
Messages
14,887
oh my god.... do teams even watch Gasnier play....

im a nobody and even i know he only ever goes on the outside.... never steps inside to beat a player. Defend outside him and you own him. Simple.
 

Godz Illa

Coach
Messages
18,745
oh my god.... do teams even watch Gasnier play....

im a nobody and even i know he only ever goes on the outside.... never steps inside to beat a player. Defend outside him and you own him. Simple.
Nope. Do you watch him play? Laid on a try for Morris against the Sharks by stepping inside Pomeroy.
 

Patorick

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
8,995
He's got a great turn of speed too. It's always really funny when his head start bouncing up and down, you know he's putting on the sprint when you see him do that.

Say what you will about Gasnier the person, as a player he is sensational and Gus is well within his rights to say what he did.

Perhaps he should have prefaced it with "on his day" to appease the negative nancies who support the Dragons?
 

Parra

Referee
Messages
24,900
Good candidate for most overrated centre ever.

Does Gasnier ever get results when the odds are against him??- he has to be the king of soft tries, and then acting like he has scored one like Eric Grothe (the real one). Gasnier plays like a decent touch footy player, a nice little 'jink' and nothing else at all.

"Hannah—
where the f**k are you? There’s
FOUR TOEY HUMANS
in the cab;
it’s twenty to four.
Our c**ks are fat and f**king
ready to spurt
(sauce)
and you’re in bed.
f**k me, fire
up you sad
merkin"
 
Messages
2,524
Gould has also claimed on the spur of the moment that Minichello and Buderus were the greatest in their respective positions in his time of watching league.


More sensationalist crap... needn't pay any attention.
 

Geohood

Bench
Messages
3,712
Gasnier is one of the best.. he can constantly create something out of nothing and is destructive with his limited ball at the Dragons. Could well be better than his uncle but playing in different eras, noone would ever be able to tell.
 

Hanscholo

Bench
Messages
4,818
I hope the Gasnier knockers and Gould haters saw the try Gasnier laid on for Chase, it was sublime.

If Gasnier isnt the best centre I have seen in 32 years, then he is close to it with only Hodges, Meninga and Renouf in the same class.

I dont see Gould's comment being outlandish at all. Gasnier is a freak.
 

RABK

Referee
Messages
20,694
personally i rate ET as the best attacking centre i ever saw, he was faster then gasnier and much more elusive.
 

Raging Rabbit

juniors
Messages
699
I hope the Gasnier knockers and Gould haters saw the try Gasnier laid on for Chase, it was sublime.

If Gasnier isnt the best centre I have seen in 32 years, then he is close to it with only Hodges, Meninga and Renouf in the same class.

I dont see Gould's comment being outlandish at all. Gasnier is a freak.

Agreed, top try.

This isn't about knocking or hating though, it's about 9's nepotism to their employees.

Oh hang on..........you're a Newcastle supporter. :lol::lol:
 

RABK

Referee
Messages
20,694
Hodges last 30 months have been incredible and based on that and the single greatest game i think i've seen from a centre (for the roosters vs the broncos, 2002) i'd say he is the greatest centre i've seen. Including meninga.
 

innsaneink

Referee
Messages
29,368
I find his comments about Grothe Jnr and origin stranger tbh, this
about a bloke thats not minced his words in the past when stating
he's not interested in rep footy.....why would you select someone
that dont wanna be there?
 
Top