Phil Gould Clanger??

[Ridders]

would sort of ruin the whole concept of colour commentary

 

[perverse]

actually gaz is up there with the best centres i've seen too. big match player and genuine footballer - not just an athlete. we don't have enough of them in the game anymore.

 

[Raging Rabbit]

actually gaz is up there with the best centres i've seen too. big match player and genuine footballer - not just an athlete. we don't have enough of them in the game anymore.

Yes, but is he THE best?

 

[themanonthehill]

Gasnier is up there
But he is a liability in defence
Look at his defence in the 05 prelim
Him and best gave us that game

 

[Hari Kari]

Yes, but is he THE best?

Gould thinks so, not sure it qualifies as a "clanger" though.

Many agree with him at least in attacking aspects.

 

[Raging Rabbit]

Gould thinks so, not sure it qualifies as a "clanger" though.

Many agree with him at least in attacking aspects.

But he is THE BEST HE HAS EVER SEEN!!!!!!

That includes must DEFENCE.

 

[AusKnightRKO]

And on the matt Cooper Comment he did say

" Matt Cooper is the best Defensive centre in the game today"

 

[BeeeeeRad]

And on the matt Cooper Comment he did say

" Matt Cooper is the best Defensive centre in the game today"

Didn't he say like 2 weeks ago that Hodges is the best defending centre in the comp?

 

[Hari Kari]

But he is THE BEST HE HAS EVER SEEN!!!!!!

That includes must DEFENCE.

OK, so what's your point?

I'm saying the comment is somewhat justifiable considering it's just Gould's opinion and he does have people who agree.

Hardly a clanger. Plenty agree Gaz is up there near the top.

 

[perverse]

Yes, but is he THE best?

off the top of my head he's probably right up there with meninga. better? hard to say, very different styles and different eras. he certainly hasn't achieved as much in the game as meninga.

there have been some bloody good centres.. and it's a very hard position to pick 1 that stands above all others. i'd put gaz right up there though.

 

[Hutty1986]

And on the matt Cooper Comment he did say

" Matt Cooper is the best Defensive centre in the game today"

Which he is, comfortably

 

[Risky_6]

RR,

Your mighty South Sydney backline have the chance to mark up on Gasnier Sunday week at anz, be interesting to see how they will go?

 

[Raging Rabbit]

OK, so what's your point?

I'm saying the comment is somewhat justifiable considering it's just Gould's opinion and he does have people who agree.

Hardly a clanger. Plenty agree Gaz is up there near the top.

STFU you dumb merkin, this is all obviously over your flat head.

 

[adamkungl]

STFU you dumb merkin, this all obviously over your flat head.

:lol: Hari Kari is clearly involved with some conspiracy of Gould's to get Gasnier to the Roosters. Because for some "obscure" reason he disagrees with you. f**king souffs germ.

 

[Raging Rabbit]

off the top of my head he's probably right up there with meninga. better? hard to say, very different styles and different eras. he certainly hasn't achieved as much in the game as meninga.

there have been some bloody good centres.. and it's a very hard position to pick 1 that stands above all others. i'd put gaz right up there though.

Rogers, Ella, Fulton, ET, all those named earlier?

The point of this thread is the breadth of his statement, considering he'd be roughly 50.

What could possibly motivate this man to make such a outlandish claim?????

 

[Raging Rabbit]

:lol: Hari Kari is clearly involved with some conspiracy of Gould's to get Gasnier to the Roosters. Because for some "obscure" reason he disagrees with you. f**king souffs germ.

Kunngargler, stop behaving like the jealous little rorter brother that you are.

How did you go with the sheltered workshop assignment, did you keep the screws and bolts in separate bags without weeing your pants?

 

[Hari Kari]

:lol: Hari Kari is clearly involved with some conspiracy of Gould's to get Gasnier to the Roosters. Because for some "obscure" reason he disagrees with you. f**king souffs germ.

I couldn't give a rats arse where Gaz goes.

 

[Dazzat]

Rogers, Ella, Fulton, ET, all those named earlier?

The point of this thread is the breadth of his statement, considering he'd be roughly 50.

What could possibly motivate this man to make such a outlandish claim?????

In a word ... Alzeimers.

 

[Hari Kari]

STFU you dumb merkin, this is all obviously over your flat head.

So as I suspected you have no idea what your point is do you?

You just dribble turds, considering that's what you've been eating for 40 years i guess it's expected.

 

[adamkungl]

I couldn't give a rats arse where Gaz goes.

apparently the sarcasm was lost on you. Waging Wanker seems to think Gus has some secret agenda by praising Gaz.