GE runs on for the Raiders...
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
SACK THE COACH!
Parramatta coach, Brian Smith, has never won a NRL Premiership. But he coached Illawarra to their first semi-final appearance, took Hull to an English final in 1989, coached St George to consecutive Grand Finals in 1992-1993, and led Parramatta to the Grand Final in 2001. He won the Dally M coach of the year in 2001. And he coached the Eels to the NRL Minor Premiership in 2005.
St George Illawarra coach, Nathan Brown is a rookie coach by comparison. He did take the Dragons Jersey Flegg to the Minor Premiership and the Grand Final in 2002. And in 2005 he coached the Dragons NRL side to second on the table.
Earlier this year, things looked much bleaker. The Eels and the Dragons produced poor starts to the season.
Brian Smith has had many chances, bringing his clubs close to, but so far from, the ultimate glory. The prospect of another failed season was too much to bear for the Eels fans, starved of a Premiership since 1986.
Nathan Brown has had a rocky start to a top-line coaching career. And the Dragons fans, brought up on the successes of the past, have waited much longer. The last Grand Final win for the Dragons was in 1979. Since then despite a number of appearances in the final decider they have faltered at the last hurdle.
So early this year, the calls of Sack the Coach! from the Eels and Dragons fans and the media were long and loud. The early season criticism of Smith and Brown recently led Premiership winning coach, Phil Gould, to make this comment:
Any coach experiencing a losing run can soon find himself the target of back-page headlines, gossip columns and talkback radio announcers. But the campaigns against these two were as sustained and vitriolic as any I have witnessed. As it turns out, the media were wrong
Many of these coaches get unfairly criticised by people... who themselves don't know the first thing about coaching.
His thesis is that in todays competition, a key injury or a dropped ball can make the difference between winning and losing. Between making the finals or not. Coaches shouldnt be judged on win/loss ratios. Just because Ricky Stuart did not coach the Roosters to the semi finals this season, he shouldnt be judged by that. He is not suddenly a bad coach, in the space of one season.
That sounds reasonable and is reasonable in many ways. But, ultimately, is it so unreasonable to judge people on their results? In the words of gridiron coach, Vince Lombardi: If winning isnt everything, why do they keep score?
To put it another way, I'm a General Manager at my work. If things go well, I get the credit from clients and my bosses. If things don't go well, I cop the flack. Is it always fair? Possibly not. There are so many things that happen in my Division. I can't always be in control. Staff make mistakes, but I have to take responsibility in the end. Equally, I am sometimes fortunate. Talented staff can really produce and give my Division great results.
What is my role as a leader of the group? I put in place the systems so that the talented staff can shine. I put in place the systems that eliminate the unacceptable risks of things going wrong. I keep my attention on the things that are most critical and try to add value on those things. I try to attract the best people I can for my Division, and make the place somewhere people want to work. I try to coach my staff on the best things to do.
In the end, though, if the organisation fails, it is my neck on the line. I expect that. If we are successful, it is always a group effort. If there is failure, ultimately, the leader of the group has to take responsibility. I might be given some extra chances if I won the Grand Final two years ago. But that cant last forever. This is the way of the world. It won't change.
So, it is the same in rugby league.
In 2005, Smith and Brown did not manage to get their teams, with two of the best playing rosters in the league, to the Grand Final. It's results that count. The coach is the leader of the group. And, at some stage, the buck will eventually stop right there.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
750 words including title